Key Takeaways

  • Software piracy includes unauthorized duplication, use, or distribution of copyrighted software.
  • Violators may face civil penalties up to $150,000 per infringement and criminal fines up to $250,000 or five years in prison.
  • Common types of software piracy include unlicensed use, counterfeit software, and hard disk loading.
  • Businesses are particularly vulnerable to penalties when using expired, trial, or improperly licensed software.
  • Avoiding software piracy requires clear internal policies, audits, and employee education.
  • International laws and industry watchdogs (like BSA) further enforce anti-piracy standards.

A software license violation penalty is the fine or legal action that occurs as a result of software piracy. Software piracy is the unauthorized use, duplication, or distribution of copyrighted software. It also includes illegal copying, downloading, and expired licenses. The Business Software Alliance and Software and Information Industry Association states that about 40 percent of installed software in the business realm and 23 percent of software overall in the US are illegally copied. Regardless of these statistics, software piracy is a serious criminal offense and may result in severe legal consequences for both businesses and individuals.

Software Piracy Law

In the US, copyright laws classify software piracy into three main categories. Infringement in any category may result in prosecution.

  • Counterfeit sales occur when a person illegally duplicates and sells copyrighted software without the copy owner's permission. Even just purchasing the software can result in a fine.
  • Unlicensed use occurs when consumers or employees copy or share software programs without an appropriate number of licenses. Using restricted-use software for unauthorized purposes (e.g. using academic versions in a business) is also included in this category. It is the most common type of piracy among home users and businesses.
  • Hard disk loading occurs when a third party installs software onto a computer (either new or old) without the permission of the copyright holder. Generally, this occurs in questionable computer shops or with repair technicians.

Types of Software Piracy

Understanding the types of software piracy is essential for prevention. The main categories include:

  • End User Piracy: When individuals or businesses use software without proper licensing. This can include installing a single license on multiple devices or using academic software in commercial settings.
  • Internet Piracy: Involves the illegal distribution of software via online platforms, including peer-to-peer sharing sites or cracked software forums.
  • Client-Server Overuse: Occurs when more users access a central copy of the software than the license permits.
  • Softlifting: A common form of piracy where a legally purchased software copy is shared with others in violation of its license agreement.
  • Counterfeiting: The creation and sale of unauthorized software that imitates legitimate products, including packaging and manuals.

These forms often overlap, making enforcement and auditing critical for legal compliance.

Penalties for Software License Violation

Whenever piracy occurs, the copyright holder loses their rightful profits. If the accused party is found guilty, they will be responsible for paying for any lost profits and damages, in addition to legal fees. If the accused has shared the software with others, they can also be responsible for lost profits and damages associated with each installed copy.

Just like illegally downloading movies and music, software piracy is a federal crime. In some cases, the consequences may go beyond just paying back the copyright holder and may even cause federal statutory damages to be charged. Depending on the case, the amount will vary, but it can be as much as $150,000 per instance.

The legal penalties are much more severe when people or businesses are caught selling illegal software. They may be required to pay fines as high as $250,000 and may face up to five years in prison. In addition, a permanent felony will be on their record.

Civil and Criminal Software Piracy Penalties

Penalties for software piracy can be both civil and criminal, depending on the severity and intent of the infringement.

  • Civil Penalties:
    • Copyright holders can pursue lawsuits against violators to recover:
      • Actual damages: Financial losses directly tied to the infringement.
      • Statutory damages: Ranging from $750 to $30,000 per incident, and up to $150,000 if the piracy is proven to be willful.
    • Additional penalties may include attorneys’ fees and court costs.
  • Criminal Penalties:
    • For intentional piracy involving distribution or commercial gain:
      • Fines up to $250,000
      • Imprisonment for up to five years
      • Permanent felony records

These penalties are enforced under the Copyright Act and strengthened by acts like the No Electronic Theft (NET) Act, which allows for prosecution even when infringement isn’t for financial gain.

Unlicensed Software in the Workplace

Most businesses rely on software to increase employee productivity and overall business efficiency. The reality is that it is relatively easy for a business to obtain unlicensed software. Many employees unknowingly use unlicensed software and some don't even know that it's illegal to use and copy software that the company has not licensed.

Upon installation, software users typically agree to enter End User License Agreements (EULAs). Violating these agreements may result in liability for the business, its officers, and its directors. The Copyright Act of the United States (sometimes referred to as simply the "Act") is the most powerful law used to enforce EULAs. Within this law, various damages (including actual damages and attorneys' fees and costs) are identified, which can be enforced against the use of unlicensed software.

Using unlicensed software not only places the company using it at financial risk, but the copyright owners may choose to seek personal liability against company officers and directors when it becomes clear they knew about, or encouraged using unlicensed software. Because of the significant financial and legal risks to a company, its officers, and its directors, it's important to develop and enforce a policy that prevents the use of unlicensed software. In addition, the company must frequently review the policy and remind all employees of the company's position regarding software licensing.

Many companies have already established policies that prohibit employees from using unlicensed software, but may be unknowingly violating software licensing agreements that apply to trialware. Trialware is the name given to software programs that allow the user to install it for a limited amount of time, after which it must be registered (by purchasing a license) or uninstalled from the computer. If nobody follows up after a trialware installation to determine whether a license was obtained for the software, and the amount of time exceeds the trial period, there's a good chance the use of the software violates the Act.

How to Prevent Software Piracy in Your Organization

To reduce the risk of penalties, organizations should implement strong anti-piracy protocols, including:

  • Audit Software Use Regularly: Conduct internal audits to ensure all software in use is properly licensed and documented.
  • Centralize Software Procurement: Use a centralized process for purchasing and distributing software to maintain compliance.
  • Educate Employees: Train staff on the risks of software piracy and the importance of license agreements.
  • Enforce Usage Policies: Establish a written software policy that clearly defines permitted uses and consequences of misuse.
  • Use License Management Tools: Employ software asset management (SAM) tools to track installations and license expirations.

Proactive management not only prevents legal issues but also saves businesses from costly disruptions.

Global Enforcement of Software Piracy Laws

Software piracy is a worldwide issue, and international laws have been developed to combat it:

  • The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) encourages global protection of software through treaties like the WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT).
  • TRIPS Agreement (Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights), enforced by the World Trade Organization (WTO), obligates member countries to provide software copyright protection.
  • Enforcement agencies such as the Business Software Alliance (BSA) and Software & Information Industry Association (SIIA) conduct audits and legal actions globally.

These international efforts create a unified front against piracy, with cross-border consequences for violators.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the penalty for software piracy?
    Penalties range from civil damages ($750 to $150,000 per infringement) to criminal fines of $250,000 and imprisonment up to five years.
  2. Is software piracy a felony?
    Yes, in cases involving willful and commercial infringement, software piracy can result in a felony charge under U.S. federal law.
  3. Can a business be held liable for an employee's software piracy?
    Yes, if the company fails to enforce licensing compliance or knowingly allows unlicensed use, it may face corporate liability.
  4. How can I tell if my software is pirated?
    Signs include missing license keys, lack of official documentation, altered branding, or software that doesn’t receive updates.
  5. What should I do if I unknowingly used pirated software?
    Immediately cease use, uninstall the software, and consult a legal professional to determine your exposure and how to remedy the issue.

If you need help understanding software piracy penalties, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.