Key Takeaways

  • Deciding whether to form an LLC or incorporate depends on your business goals, growth plans, tax preferences, and investment needs.
  • LLCs provide flexibility, limited liability protection, and pass-through taxation but can face limitations in raising venture capital.
  • C-corps are preferred for companies seeking outside investment, public listing, or complex equity structures but face double taxation.
  • S-corps combine some corporate benefits with pass-through taxation but have strict ownership restrictions.
  • Consider how each structure affects liability, taxes, management, compliance, and long-term growth before deciding.

Should I incorporate or LLC? This is a common question asked by entrepreneurs. Small business owners typically start their companies as sole proprietorships, which means they and their business are essentially the same thing. However, many entrepreneurs overlook the advantages of changing the format of their company to a corporation or limited liability company (LLC). One of the biggest advantages of these structures is that they protect the entrepreneur's personal assets from debt or legal action taken against the business.

Popular Business Types

Small business owners are likely to hear differing opinions about the pros and cons of setting up an LLC or corporation, but they really need to consider what is best for their individual company and situation.

Most entrepreneurs consider three kinds of entities for their startups:

  • LLC
  • C-corp
  • S-corp

Small business owners should take lots of things into consideration when deciding what kind of entity to start, including if they will soon be looking for outside investors and if the company is expected to generate a profit in the near future. Each type of entity has its own pros and cons.

LLC

It is easy and inexpensive to set up an LLC. In an LLC, the owner chooses the members and decides what percentage of the company each member owns. An LLC offers the same amount of personal liability protection as a C-corp.

One of the best advantages of an LLC is that there is limited regulation, so you don't have to follow the same strict rules and disclosures you would have to maintain with a C-corp. LLCs aren't taxed as entities. Instead, members are taxed according to their ownership percentage.

This is helpful because when starting a company, you will initially lose money. Your personal portion of that loss can be used on your personal tax return. If you don't have any personal income, the IRS allows you to either roll the loss forward and offset future income or apply the loss retroactively to the past three years of tax returns. Following either of these paths will lower your adjusted gross income, which often means you'll get a refund.

A C-corp is required to pay tax on all income, which means that money coming into the company is actually getting taxed twice: once when the company pays you and again when you pay your personal income taxes. Considering these circumstances, an LLC is a strong option for a start-up structure.

One disadvantage to an LLC is that it doesn't support shareholders, which means it likely isn't the best option if you have outside investors. In fact, some investors, especially those working with VCs (venture capitalist firms), aren't allowed to invest in LLCs.

Evaluating Whether an LLC Is Right for You

If you're asking, "Should my business be an LLC?" the answer depends largely on your business’s size, growth ambitions, and how you plan to manage taxes and liability. LLCs offer significant advantages for many startups and small businesses:

  • Limited Liability Protection: Like corporations, LLCs shield your personal assets from lawsuits, debts, or business obligations. This makes them a safer choice than sole proprietorships or general partnerships.
  • Pass-Through Taxation: Profits and losses flow directly to members and are reported on their individual tax returns, avoiding the double taxation associated with C-corps.
  • Flexible Structure: LLCs have fewer formalities, less paperwork, and more flexible management arrangements than corporations. They can be managed by members or appointed managers, and there’s no requirement for a board of directors.
  • Profit Distribution Flexibility: Profits can be distributed in ways that don’t strictly match ownership percentages, allowing creative compensation or reward structures.
  • Ideal for Small to Mid-Sized Businesses: If you plan to stay closely held, prioritize operational flexibility, or aren’t seeking venture capital soon, an LLC is often the most practical choice.

However, LLCs may not be ideal if you plan to attract large outside investors or go public. Many venture capital firms cannot invest in LLCs due to regulatory or tax reasons, and the structure may not offer the same credibility to institutional investors.

C-corp

A C-corp is a full corporation. It offers absolute protection for your personal assets because it is its own tax entity. Many C-corps are based in Delaware because the state offers a strong legal framework for corporations, shareholders, and boards. If you choose to create a C-corp, you must have a board of directors and follow strict requirements like reporting revenue and keeping your operations running in an organized manner.

C-corps also have shareholders and can issue stock, which makes them a more enticing structure for investors. If you want to accept money from investors, your company will have to be formed as a C-corp. The only exception to this is if you meet the requirements to be an S-corp.

When a C-Corporation Makes More Sense

While an LLC is attractive for small and midsize businesses, there are situations where a C-corp is clearly the stronger choice:

  • Attracting Investment: C-corps can issue multiple classes of stock, making them the preferred vehicle for venture capital, angel investors, and future public offerings.
  • Unlimited Growth Potential: Unlike LLCs or S-corps, C-corps have no limit on the number or type of shareholders.
  • Perpetual Existence: The company continues even if ownership changes or founders depart, which adds stability and credibility.
  • Tax Opportunities for Reinvestment: While C-corps face double taxation, they can retain earnings to reinvest in the business at the corporate tax rate, which may be advantageous for high-growth startups.
  • Enhanced Credibility: Incorporating can improve your standing with lenders, suppliers, and enterprise-level clients.

However, double taxation remains a major drawback. Profits are taxed at the corporate level and again as shareholder dividends. Additionally, C-corps require more administrative work, including board meetings, annual reports, and strict record-keeping.

S-corp

An S-corp is essentially the same as a C-corp, expect that it is allowed to behave differently in certain situations. “S” refers to a section of the IRS code. To create an S-corp, you must first create a C-corp and then choose the S-election if you qualify. An S-corp provides the regulatory benefits of a C-corp and the tax advantages of an LLC.

One of the biggest downsides to being an S-corp is that the types of investors you can have are extremely restricted. Investors are not allowed to be corporations, such as VCs, or people who aren't residents of America. S-corps also face restrictions on the number of shareholders they can have.

S-Corporation Considerations and Limitations

S-corps blend features of LLCs and C-corps, offering liability protection and pass-through taxation, but they come with important caveats:

  • Ownership Restrictions: S-corps can have no more than 100 shareholders, all of whom must be U.S. citizens or residents. Other companies, trusts, or foreign investors cannot hold shares.
  • One Class of Stock: This restriction simplifies ownership but limits fundraising options compared to a C-corp.
  • Employment Tax Benefits: Owner-operators can pay themselves a “reasonable salary” and take additional profits as distributions, which may be taxed at a lower rate than income.
  • More Formalities than an LLC: While simpler than a C-corp, S-corps still require regular meetings, shareholder approvals, and detailed records.

S-corps can be a powerful tool for small businesses that want some tax advantages of an LLC but need a corporate structure. However, the ownership limitations often make them unsuitable for startups seeking rapid growth or large outside funding.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Should my business be an LLC if I’m the only owner?
    Yes. Single-member LLCs provide liability protection and tax flexibility while maintaining simplicity. They’re a popular choice for freelancers, consultants, and small business owners.
  2. Is an LLC or corporation better for attracting investors?
    Corporations — especially C-corps — are generally preferred by investors because they can issue stock, have unlimited shareholders, and offer more structured governance.
  3. Can I convert my LLC into a corporation later?
    Yes. Many businesses start as LLCs for simplicity and later convert to a C-corp when seeking investment or planning an IPO.
  4. How do taxes differ between LLCs and corporations?
    LLCs use pass-through taxation, while C-corps face double taxation. S-corps offer pass-through taxation but with ownership restrictions.
  5. What is the most flexible business structure?
    LLCs offer the most flexibility in management, profit distribution, and compliance requirements, making them ideal for many small and midsize businesses.

If you need help with knowing if you should incorporate or create an LLC, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.