Key Takeaways

  • Pass-through taxation is one of the main S corp advantages, allowing income to be taxed at the shareholder level and avoiding corporate double taxation.
  • S corps offer limited liability protection, separating personal assets from business debts and obligations.
  • Owners can potentially reduce self-employment taxes by splitting income into salary and dividends.
  • There are ownership and stock restrictions, including a 100-shareholder limit and the requirement for shareholders to be U.S. citizens or residents.
  • Administrative complexity, IRS scrutiny, and compliance obligations are common disadvantages that require careful planning.
  • S corps are often best suited for small to medium-sized businesses with predictable profits and domestic ownership.

Knowing S corporations' advantages and disadvantages can help you decide if this is the right structure for your business. Pros of S corporations include potential tax savings, while cons include limitations on investment opportunities.

An S corporation is a corporation that's chosen a special tax status with the IRS. Like a C corporation, S corporations do the following:

  • Issue stock
  • Have a board of directors, officers, and shareholders

Unlike a C corporation, S corporations aren't taxed twice.

S corporations are similar to partnerships and sole proprietorships in that they pass most of the business income and losses to company shareholders.

The process for forming an S corporation is the same for forming a traditional corporation, which includes the following:

  • File Articles of Incorporation with the state
  • Select a registered agent
  • Pay required fees

When you file to incorporate your business, it's automatically classified as a C corporation, or standard corporation. You must file for Subchapter S to obtain S corporation status. Your business must also meet several standards in order to be approved for this election.

Advantages

S corporation shareholders have limited liability protection, and there are no state residency requirements for S corporations. These businesses enjoy a good amount of privacy protection, particularly in states like Wyoming and Nevada.

An S corporations' pass-through taxation means that profits go to the shareholders, who then pay taxes on them at the individual level. The S corporation structure is beneficial for businesses that:&

  • Provide a service, such as consultants
  • Don't need large, costly equipment purchases before operations can begin
  • Don't have significant startup costs
  • Don't require a great deal of capital investment to make a profit

S corporations can attract investors by selling shares of stock in the company. You can freely transfer interest in an S corporation without worrying about negative tax consequences.

Because shareholders are not personally responsible for business debts, creditors can't go after a shareholder's personal assets — such as homes or personal bank accounts — to pay company debts.

An S corporation's shareholders can also be employees of the company and earn salaries. They're also able to receive dividends and other tax-free distributions from the corporation.

For new businesses, operating as an S corporation can quickly establish credibility with partners, vendors, investors, and potential customers, since they'll see the formal commitment owners have made to their company.

If an owner dies or leaves an S corporation, the business continues because it has perpetual existence.

Expanded S Corp Advantages

Pass-Through Taxation and Tax SavingsOne of the most significant S corp advantages is its tax treatment. Because S corporations are “pass-through” entities, income, deductions, credits, and losses flow directly to shareholders’ individual tax returns. This avoids the double taxation faced by C corporations, where profits are taxed at the corporate level and again as shareholder dividends. For many small businesses, this structure can lead to substantial tax savings, especially when combined with strategic income allocation between salary and distributions.

Reduced Self-Employment Tax BurdenUnlike sole proprietorships or partnerships, S corporation shareholders who work for the company can receive a reasonable salary and take the remaining profits as dividends. Because only the salary portion is subject to employment taxes (Social Security and Medicare), owners can often significantly reduce their self-employment tax liability.

Attractive to Investors and Easier Transfer of OwnershipAlthough S corps have restrictions on who can own shares, they can still issue stock (albeit a single class), which makes raising capital easier than in many other business structures. Shares can also be freely transferred without triggering complex tax consequences, which is especially useful when planning for succession or bringing in new partners.

Enhanced Credibility and Perpetual ExistenceForming an S corporation can boost a business’s credibility with lenders, investors, vendors, and customers, signaling a higher level of formality and commitment. Moreover, the business continues to exist even if an owner dies or leaves, providing stability and continuity.

Additional Tax Deductions and Fringe BenefitsS corporations can deduct a range of business expenses — such as employee benefits, retirement plan contributions, and health insurance premiums — which reduces taxable income. Owners who are employees may also qualify for certain deductions not available in other business structures.

Disadvantages

In court proceedings, S corporation shares are subject to sale and seizure at the shareholder level. Shareholders in a high-income tax bracket will pay more taxes on their distributions since they're taxed at the individual level.

Your business must meet certain requirements in order to be structured as an S corporation. If your business fails to meet the requirements, the IRS can revoke its tax status and charge back taxes for several years. You'll also have to wait five years before you can make the election again.

Your S corporation must adopt a certain tax year as outlined by the IRS. If you want a different fiscal year, you'll have to show a specific business purpose for it.

S corporations can only issue one class of stock, although voting and non-voting shares are allowed. The restriction on the amount of stock an S corporation can issue also means the business can't easily allocate income or losses to specific shareholders.

An S corporation can have no more than 100 shareholders, and none can be foreign individuals or foreign entities.

The IRS carefully scrutinizes S corporation payments because business income can be either listed as salary or dividends for shareholder-employees. You must pay owner-employees a reasonable salary. If the IRS identifies any issues with this, they may characterize wages as dividends. As a result, the company loses a deduction for paid compensation.

Every business type has its own pros and cons. S corporations are generally preferred by small business owners who have no plans for international expansion. In fact, the IRS created this structure specifically to encourage the creation of small businesses. Knowing the advantages and disadvantages will help you determine if this is the right structure for your company.

Additional Disadvantages to Consider

Strict Eligibility Requirements and Ongoing ComplianceTo qualify for S corp status, the business must meet several requirements, including having no more than 100 shareholders, issuing only one class of stock, and ensuring all shareholders are U.S. citizens or residents. Failure to meet these criteria can result in loss of S corp status, potentially triggering back taxes and penalties.

Increased IRS Scrutiny on CompensationBecause S corp owners often try to minimize self-employment taxes by paying themselves a lower salary, the IRS closely monitors shareholder-employee compensation. If salaries are deemed “unreasonably low,” the IRS may reclassify distributions as wages, resulting in additional taxes, penalties, and interest.

Limited Ownership FlexibilityS corporations face ownership restrictions that can limit their growth potential. They cannot have foreign shareholders, certain types of entities as owners, or multiple classes of stock. These restrictions may make them less attractive for businesses seeking significant outside investment or planning to go public.

State-Level Taxes and FeesWhile S corps avoid federal corporate income tax, some states impose franchise taxes or other fees on S corporations. These state-level obligations can diminish some of the tax benefits and add to the overall cost of maintaining the business structure.

Administrative Complexity and CostsS corporations require more formalities than sole proprietorships or partnerships, such as holding regular board meetings, maintaining corporate minutes, and filing additional paperwork. These compliance obligations can increase legal and accounting costs, particularly for small businesses with limited resources.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can an LLC become an S corporation?
    Yes. An LLC can elect S corporation tax status by filing IRS Form 2553, provided it meets eligibility requirements such as the shareholder limit and citizenship rules.
  2. How does an S corp help reduce self-employment taxes?
    Owner-employees can pay themselves a reasonable salary (subject to employment tax) and receive remaining profits as dividends, which are not subject to self-employment tax.
  3. What happens if an S corporation violates eligibility rules?
    If an S corp no longer meets eligibility criteria, the IRS may revoke its status, reclassify it as a C corporation, and potentially assess back taxes and penalties.
  4. Can S corporations retain earnings?
    Yes, but retained earnings may be subject to passive income restrictions. If passive income exceeds certain thresholds, the S corp could risk losing its status.
  5. Who is the ideal candidate for S corporation status?
    S corps are generally best for small to medium-sized businesses with consistent profits, domestic ownership, and no plans for complex stock structures or foreign investors.

If you need help learning more about S corporations or other business types, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.