S Corp vs C Corp Tax Advantages Explained

Key Takeaways

• A C corporation is taxed as a separate entity and may face double taxation—once at the corporate level and again on shareholder dividends.
• An S corporation avoids double taxation by allowing income, losses, deductions, and credits to pass through to shareholders’ personal tax returns.
• C corps can attract more investors through multiple stock classes, while S corps face restrictions on shareholder types and numbers.
• C corps may benefit from a flat 21% federal tax rate, while S corps may offer self-employment tax savings for shareholder-employees.
• The best choice depends on your company’s growth goals, ownership structure, and plans for reinvestment or distributions.

To better understand S corp vs C corp tax advantages, it's important to understand the differences between the two types of corporations in relation to taxation. A C corporation is a taxpaying entity that is separate from its owners, while an S corporation is known as a pass-through tax entity. Understanding the tax and nontax ramifications is a top priority when determining the structure of a business.

What Are the Differences between a C Corporation and an S Corporation?

 When people think about corporations, they typically think of a C corporation. C corporations are the default type of formation when incorporating. Unless you elect S corporation status, you have a C corporation, which is the most common type of corporation in the United States.  

In C corporations, the business owners are individual shareholders and it's considered a separate legal entity. They have special liability protections and therefore individual shareholders are typically shielded from personal liability for business debts or lawsuits. 

To form a  corporation, you still have to file a variety of paperwork with your respective state government, including Articles of Incorporation. Once the business is active, there are compliance obligations and document requirements that must be met, which can include stock issuance, paying fees, and holding director and shareholder meetings. 

Key Tax Differences Between S Corps and C Corps

The biggest distinction between an S corporation and a C corporation lies in how each is taxed by the IRS.

• C Corporation Taxation: C corps are considered separate tax entities. They pay federal corporate income tax (currently a flat 21%) on profits. If the company distributes dividends, shareholders also pay personal taxes on those dividends—this is known as double taxation. However, retained earnings can be reinvested in the business at the lower corporate tax rate, which can be beneficial for growth-focused companies.
• S Corporation Taxation: In contrast, an S corp is a pass-through entity. It doesn’t pay corporate income tax; instead, profits and losses are reported on shareholders’ individual tax returns. This structure avoids double taxation and may reduce overall tax liability, especially for small or closely held businesses.
• Self-Employment Tax: One advantage of S corps is the ability to classify part of a shareholder’s earnings as salary (subject to employment taxes) and the rest as distributions (not subject to self-employment tax). This can significantly reduce overall tax liability when structured properly.
• Qualified Business Income (QBI) Deduction: S corp shareholders may qualify for up to a 20% QBI deduction, while C corp shareholders do not. However, eligibility depends on the nature of the business and income thresholds.

How to File a C Corporation

Here is how to file a C corporation: 

• Choose the business's name and file it with the respective secretary of state office. 
• File the Articles of Incorporation and pay the applicable fee. 
• Draft corporate bylaws and hold your board of directors meeting. Once the Secretary of State office confirms your Articles of Incorporation, the next step is to issue stock certificates to the initial shareholders.  
• Apply for pertinent business licenses and any necessary permits required. 
• Obtain your Employer Identification Number (EIN) through the IRS. 
• Check with state and local government offices to verify whether you need any other permits or ID numbers.

Tax Filing and Compliance for C Corps vs S Corps

Both entities have specific tax filing and compliance obligations:

• C Corporations: Must file Form 1120 annually with the IRS. They’re responsible for paying corporate income taxes directly and issuing Form 1099-DIV to shareholders who receive dividends. State filings may also be required, depending on the state of incorporation.
• S Corporations: Must file Form 1120-S and provide Schedule K-1 to each shareholder, detailing their share of income, deductions, and credits. Each shareholder then reports these figures on their personal tax returns.

Both must also adhere to corporate formalities such as maintaining meeting minutes, adopting bylaws, and issuing shares. However, S corps must additionally maintain eligibility by ensuring they have no more than 100 shareholders, all of whom are U.S. citizens or residents, and only one class of stock.

What to Know About S Corporation Structure

An S corporation is primarily the same as a C corporation, with shareholders, a board of directors, and executive officers. Like the C corporation, an S corporation also has some liability protection that protects owners from personal liability and corporate debts. Also, S corporations are required to file Articles of Incorporation, issue stock, hold meetings, and pay applicable fees. 

There are some differences though. S corporations are allowed only 100 shareholders max, and the shareholders can only be U.S. citizens. Essentially, an S corporation is primarily just a tax election rather than a different corporation set up. 

To set up an S corporation, you complete the same steps as the C corporation, but you also have to file IRS Form 2533 within 75 days of forming the corporation. Although forming an S corporation is only one additional step, maintaining its status requires diligence. If you mess up the requirements, you may lose your S status and go back to a C corporation. 

It's important to note that some states don't recognize the "S" corporation for tax purposes. Be sure to check your particular state to see whether it recognizes S corporation status before you make a decision on your corporation's status. The main reason to elect S corporation status is for the pass-through tax benefits whereas C corporations pay taxes on corporate income. 

Choosing Between S Corp and C Corp: Which Is Better for Taxes?

The choice between S corp and C corp status depends on your business goals and how you plan to use profits.

• When a C Corp May Be Better:
  • You plan to reinvest most profits into the business.
  • You want to attract venture capital or issue multiple stock classes.
  • You expect to go public in the future.
  • The 21% corporate tax rate offers long-term savings if profits remain within the company.
• When an S Corp May Be Better:
  • You want to avoid double taxation.
  • You plan to distribute profits annually to shareholders.
  • You want potential self-employment tax savings through the owner-employee structure.
  • Your business has a small, domestic ownership group.

The “best” structure ultimately depends on factors like anticipated profits, shareholder numbers, and whether the company plans to retain or distribute earnings.

Possible Advantages and Disadvantages of Each

There are some advantages to operating as an S corporation vs a C corporation: 

• One level of taxation as the S corporation doesn't pay taxes on the income, only the shareholders pay the taxes. 
• Losses can be deducted from shareholders' individual tax returns whereas income losses in a C corporation are only offset at the corporate level. 
• S corporations offer an advantage to split income between family members. 

While there are some tax benefits to S corporation status, there are also some disadvantages as well:   

• An exclusion for up to 50 percent of gains on "qualified small business stock" is not applicable to S corporations. 
• Shareholders of C corporations have greater tax-free fringe benefits. 
• Stock in S corporations can only be transferred to very specific and eligible shareholders and it cannot have more than 100 shareholders. This also restricts the ability to raise more capital. 
• Estate planning can be more complicated. 
• Tax rates are typically higher for individuals versus the rates that would apply to C corporations. 

Both types of corporations require personal income tax to be paid on any salary received as well as dividends. 

If there are no plans to distribute all profits, forming a C corporation might be better since you can take advantage of "income splitting. "This is where the business income is split in such a way that part of it is taxed at the corporate level and part of it then taxed to the individual owners. This puts them in a lower tax bracket rather than either one being in a higher tax bracket if they had earned all the income. 

Long-Term Tax Strategy Considerations

When evaluating S corp vs C corp tax advantages, it’s important to think long-term.

• Accumulated Earnings: C corporations can retain earnings for future growth but may face an Accumulated Earnings Tax (AET) if profits are not reasonably used for business purposes.
• Loss Utilization: Shareholders in an S corporation can deduct business losses on personal returns, but only up to their investment (basis) in the company.
• Fringe Benefits: C corp shareholders often receive better tax-free benefits (like health insurance, life insurance, and retirement plans) than S corp shareholders, whose benefits may be partially taxable.
• Conversion Flexibility: It’s easier to switch from C corp to S corp than vice versa. Once an S corp revokes its election, it typically cannot reelect S status for five years.

Before deciding, consult a qualified tax professional. Choosing the wrong structure could increase your tax burden or limit your growth opportunities.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the main tax difference between an S corp and a C corp?
   A C corp pays corporate income tax, while an S corp’s income passes through to shareholders’ individual tax returns, avoiding double taxation.
2. Can an S corp have foreign shareholders?
   No. Only U.S. citizens or resident aliens can own shares in an S corp, unlike C corps, which can have foreign shareholders.
3. Is the 21% corporate tax rate always better for C corps?
   Not necessarily. While the corporate rate is lower, double taxation on dividends can reduce overall savings unless profits are retained or reinvested.
4. Can a business switch from C corp to S corp status?
   Yes. A C corp can elect S status by filing Form 2553 with the IRS, typically within 75 days of the start of the tax year.
5. Which is better for small business owners—S corp or C corp?
   For most small businesses aiming to avoid double taxation and reduce self-employment taxes, the S corp structure is more beneficial. Larger or fast-growing companies may prefer a C corp for flexibility in investment and growth.

If you need help with S corp vs C corp tax advantages, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel only accepts the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.