Key Takeaways:

  • Buyers have multiple legal remedies if a seller breaches a contract, including monetary damages, specific performance, and contract termination.
  • Specific performance is often pursued when monetary compensation is insufficient, particularly in real estate transactions.
  • Buyers may seek damages for non-delivery, breach of warranty, or contract repudiation.
  • Real estate contracts often contain contingencies that may allow a seller to back out without repercussions.
  • State laws govern the extent of damages available to buyers, influencing compensation amounts.
  • The legal process for suing a seller for breach of contract in real estate varies by jurisdiction and contract terms.
  • Buyers should carefully review contract terms and seek legal advice before taking action.

Several remedies are available to buyer for breach of contract by seller. For example, the buyer could pursue monetary damages or could sue to force the seller to abide by the specific terms of the contract.

Buyer's Remedies for Breach of Contract

When a seller commits a breach of contract, the buyer who was harmed by the breach has access to a variety of remedies.

One of the most common remedies chosen by buyers after a breach of contract by the seller is a lawsuit for damages for non-delivery. These suits occur if the seller fails or simply refuses to deliver the goods that were promised in the contract. In addition to suing for damages, the buyer can request that the money they've already paid be returned. A suit for price is another remedy available for a contract breach. These suits involve the money that the buyer has paid for goods that were not delivered by the seller.

In some contracts between buyers and sellers, the goods described are specific, meaning if these goods are not delivered, monetary damages would not be enough to make up for the loss. In these circumstances, the buyer can file a suit for specific performance. If the buyer wins the suit, the seller will be forced to abide by the terms of the contract, meaning they would need to deliver the specific goods that were promised.

Several other damages are available to buyers who have been harmed by a breach of contract:

  • Suit for Breach of Warranty: If the seller breaches a warranty, or the buyer is forced to consider a conditional breach as a breach of warranty, the goods cannot be rejected by the buyer. The buyer can, however, sue for damages resulting from the breach of warranty.
  • Suits for Damages of Repudiation: If a contract is repudiated by the seller for the dates the goods were due to be delivered, the buyer can either sue for damages for an anticipatory breach or can consider the contract as active and wait until the delivery date to take action.
  • Suit for Interest: In some cases, a buyer can file a suit for interest, which means they could receive special damages in the form of interest on the original price paid.

Common Types of Breaches by Sellers

When a seller breaches a contract, the violation can take different forms, each requiring specific legal actions. Common types of contract breaches by sellers include:

  • Failure to Deliver Goods or Services: The seller refuses or is unable to provide the agreed-upon goods.
  • Misrepresentation or Fraud: The seller provides false information about the product, service, or property.
  • Failure to Meet Contractual Obligations: The seller does not fulfill specific duties outlined in the contract, such as warranties or delivery timelines.
  • Anticipatory Breach: The seller indicates, before the delivery date, that they will not fulfill the contract.

Each of these breaches may entitle the buyer to different legal remedies, including monetary damages, contract rescission, or specific performance.

Buyer's Remedies for Breached Real Estate Contracts

In most cases, when a person is selling a home, they will want to close a sale as quickly as possible, meaning they'll do everything in their power to avoid messing up a deal. Unfortunately, on some occasions, a home seller will back out of a deal, usually because they've decided they don't actually want to sell or a better offer has been made by another buyer.

Luckily, if a home seller reneges on an agreement to sell their home, the harmed buyer has several remedies at their disposal, including:

  • Seeking monetary compensation for breach of contract.
  • Terminating the contract and requesting that their deposit be returned and that reasonable expenses be covered.
  • Pursuing specific performance, meaning the home seller would be forced to complete the sale.

Before a homebuyer pursues any of these remedies, they should keep in mind that most real estate contracts include contingencies, which is a legal method for both the buyer and the seller to exit the contract without repercussions.

For instance, in some real estate contracts, there is a contingency that states that a house can only be sold once the seller finds another home to purchase. If the seller makes a good-faith effort to find a new home but is unable to find a suitable property, they will have the right to terminate the contract without being punished. If this occurs, no legal remedies would be available to the buyer because the contract hasn't actually been broken.

After a real estate contract has been breached, suing for monetary damages is a common remedy. To receive these damages, the buyer would need to provide evidence that they suffered financial harm from the breach of contract. The amount of monetary damages a buyer can receive largely depends on the applicable state laws. For instance, if the seller was acting in good faith, the buyer may only be able to receive damages in the form of their deposit and a few additional expenses.

Legal Steps When Suing a Seller for Breach of Contract in Real Estate

If a seller breaches a real estate contract, the buyer may need to take several legal steps to enforce their rights. These steps typically include:

  1. Reviewing the Contract:
    • Determine if the contract includes contingencies allowing the seller to back out legally.
    • Identify clauses related to breach consequences and dispute resolution.
  2. Issuing a Demand Letter:
    • The buyer can send a formal notice demanding compliance or compensation.
    • This letter may outline potential legal actions if the seller does not comply.
  3. Negotiating a Settlement:
    • Mediation or negotiation may resolve the dispute without legal action.
    • In some cases, the seller agrees to a monetary settlement or alternative resolution.
  4. Filing a Lawsuit:
    • If negotiations fail, the buyer can file a lawsuit for damages or specific performance.
    • The case may proceed through state courts, requiring legal representation.
  5. Court Proceedings and Judgment:
    • If the court rules in the buyer's favor, the seller may be required to pay damages or complete the sale.
    • State laws and contract terms impact the final ruling and available remedies.

Buyers should consult an attorney to determine the best course of action based on contract specifics and jurisdictional laws.

Damages Available to Buyers in Real Estate Contract Breaches

When a seller breaches a real estate contract, buyers may recover different types of damages, depending on the case's specifics:

  • Compensatory Damages: Covers direct financial losses, such as lost deposits, moving expenses, or increased costs to secure a similar property.
  • Consequential Damages: Applies when the breach causes additional losses, such as lost investment opportunities or financial hardship.
  • Liquidated Damages: If the contract includes a liquidated damages clause, the seller may be required to pay a pre-determined amount upon breach.
  • Punitive Damages: Rare in real estate cases but may apply in cases of fraud or deliberate deception.

The buyer must present evidence of financial harm to claim damages, and state laws influence the compensation available.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can a seller legally back out of a real estate contract?
    Yes, but only under specific contingencies outlined in the contract. Otherwise, the seller may be held liable for breach of contract.
  2. What should I do if a seller refuses to complete a home sale?
    Buyers can issue a demand letter, negotiate a resolution, or sue for specific performance or damages. Consulting a real estate attorney is recommended.
  3. What happens if a seller misrepresents property details?
    Buyers may sue for fraud or misrepresentation and seek damages, contract rescission, or compensation for financial losses.
  4. Is specific performance a common remedy in real estate disputes?
    Yes, courts often order specific performance in real estate disputes since every property is unique, making monetary damages inadequate.
  5. How long do I have to sue a seller for breach of contract?
    The statute of limitations varies by state but typically ranges from 3 to 6 years. Buyers should act promptly to preserve their legal rights.

If you need help with remedies available to buyer for breach of contract by seller, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.