Key Takeaways

  • A breach of contract occurs when a party fails to fulfill the essential terms of a binding agreement.
  • A breach of warranty involves the failure of a promise or assurance (express or implied) about a product or service’s quality, performance, or ownership.
  • Warranties can be express (clearly stated), implied (legally assumed under the Uniform Commercial Code), or statutory (imposed by law).
  • Remedies for a breach of warranty often include repair, replacement, refund, or damages measured by the difference in value between promised and delivered goods.
  • Breach of contract remedies may allow for termination of the agreement and broader recovery of damages, while breach of warranty remedies are narrower and focused on compensation for the defect.

The difference between breach of contract and breach of warranty can be understood by looking at the different parts of legal agreements or contracts. Contracts are legal agreements made between two or more parties that designate the obligations required by each. A contract must contain an offer, acceptance, and consideration. If a party fails to complete their contractual obligations, it results in a breach of contract.

Breach of Contract

One type of breach of contract is a material breach, in which one party does something that contradicts their obligation in the agreement. An immaterial breach is one that is determined by the court to not have any significant effect on the contractual terms, such as a new car arriving with a minor scratch on it. When a breach of contract occurs, the parties may choose to have the contract enforced on its own terms or dissolved altogether and a new solution found. A breach must be proven to affect the very nature of the contract in order for it to be terminated.

A successful breach of contract claim will result in damages. If you pay someone to do a job and they don't do any part of it, the monetary amount you pay them is the monetary amount of your damages.

The first thing to do is to attempt to work it out directly with the other party - discuss, argue, and negotiate. If you can't make it work and if the amount of damages is small, you can file a claim in your area's small claims court. Each state has its own maximum amount that a small claims court can deal with, typically from $3,000 to $5,000, but occasionally more. Call your local small claims court to find out what the amount is.

Next, find out the legal name of the person or business you wish to file a claim against. Don't use the wrong name or you might end up with a judgment against the wrong person. Next, hire a lawyer to handle the case for you. Legal processes may be difficult to understand. If you accidentally don't comply or something goes wrong, you might lose your case. Acting "pro se" (in other words, handling your own case) is very risky and it's best to consult a lawyer beforehand if you wish to go this route.

State laws vary in the amount of time that a party has to file a breach of contract claim. Some states allow up to four years, while others allow even more time. Look up your state laws or talk to a contract law lawyer in your area. In general, it's best to act as quickly as possible.

Types of Contract Breaches and Their Impact

Contract breaches may be categorized in several ways beyond material and immaterial breaches. Courts often distinguish between:

  • Minor breaches – Small deviations from contract terms that do not undermine the overall agreement.
  • Anticipatory breaches – When one party makes it clear, either through words or conduct, that they will not perform their obligations.
  • Fundamental breaches – Severe breaches that strike at the core of the contract and justify termination.

The severity of the breach determines the remedies available. For example, an anticipatory breach allows the non-breaching party to seek damages immediately rather than waiting until the contract is due for performance.

Breach of Warranty

A warranty is a stipulation that a particular fact related to the subject of the contract is or will be as promised or stated. Warranties are meant to protect the recipient against loss, should the fact be or become untrue. For example, a warranty for a refrigerator may explicitly state that it will last for at least 15 years. This implies that the refrigerator will be fully functioning for that time. Warranties offer customers protection in numerous areas, including the quality and functioning of products, ownership of shares, and the right to intellectual property.

If a seller breaches a warranty, the customer has several options to remedy the situation, including:

  • If the buyer rejects unacceptable goods, or if the discrepancy reduces the value of the entire contract, the buyer may cancel the contract altogether.
  • The buyer may purchase substitute goods and recover the difference between the contractual price and the market price. If the buyer accepts the original goods, they have the right to monetary compensation (damages).
  • The buyer must provide notice of the breach within a reasonable time. Damages are measured as the amount between the value of the accepted goods and the value they would have had if they had been as warranted.

Breach of Warranty in Class Actions

Breach of warranty claims frequently appear in consumer class actions, particularly when a manufacturer or seller makes uniform representations across a wide range of products. For example, defective automobile parts, faulty medical devices, or misleading food labeling often lead to breach of warranty class suits. Courts will evaluate whether the warranty statements were consistent across the class and whether common issues predominate, making group litigation appropriate.

Legal Remedies for Breach of Warranty

When a breach of warranty occurs, buyers may pursue several remedies depending on the situation:

  • Repair or replacement of the defective goods.
  • Rescission of the contract, which cancels the agreement and restores parties to their pre-contract positions.
  • Damages, often measured as the difference between the value of goods as delivered and their value as warranted.
  • Incidental and consequential damages, such as costs of obtaining replacement goods or losses resulting from defective products.

It is important to note that while breach of contract may allow termination of the entire agreement, breach of warranty usually leads to compensation rather than cancellation of the contract.

Common Examples of Breach of Warranty

Examples of situations where breach of warranty claims may arise include:

  • A new appliance that repeatedly malfunctions despite a warranty claiming it is free from defects for three years.
  • A used car sold as “never having been in an accident,” later revealed to have had significant collision repairs.
  • A software license sold without proper intellectual property rights, resulting in legal disputes for the buyer.

These examples highlight how warranties provide assurances that, when broken, can lead to legal claims for damages.

Types of Warranties

Warranties take several forms, each with different legal implications:

  • Express warranties: Explicit promises or statements made by a seller about the product or service. For instance, “This vehicle has never been in an accident.”
  • Implied warranties: Assurances created by law, even if not written in the contract. Under the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), two key implied warranties exist:
    • Implied warranty of merchantability – Goods must be fit for ordinary use.
    • Implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose – Applies when a buyer relies on the seller’s expertise to select suitable goods.
  • Statutory warranties: Legal protections imposed by state or federal law, such as lemon laws in consumer protection contexts.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the main difference between breach of contract and breach of warranty?
    A breach of contract is the failure to perform obligations under an agreement, while a breach of warranty is the failure of a promise or guarantee about a product or service’s quality or condition.
  2. Can a breach of warranty exist without a breach of contract?
    Yes. A product may be delivered as agreed under a contract, but if it fails to meet warranty assurances (such as durability or quality), a breach of warranty claim may arise.
  3. What remedies are available for breach of warranty?
    Remedies typically include repair, replacement, rescission of the contract, or damages reflecting the reduced value of the goods.
  4. Are implied warranties legally enforceable?
    Yes. Even if not written, implied warranties—such as the warranty of merchantability—are enforceable under the Uniform Commercial Code.
  5. How long do I have to file a breach of warranty claim?
    The statute of limitations varies by state, but under the UCC it is often four years from when the breach occurred, subject to exceptions in consumer protection laws.

If you need help understanding the difference between breach of contract and breach of warranty, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.