Promissory Estoppel Example: Legal Definition & Key Cases

Key Takeaways

• Promissory estoppel is a legal principle that enforces a promise when a party has relied on it and suffered a detriment.
• It does not require consideration for enforcement but must meet legal criteria, such as reasonable reliance and economic loss.
• Real-life examples include employment promises, business agreements, and contract disputes where a party acts on a promise.
• Promissory estoppel vs. contract law: While contracts require formal consideration, promissory estoppel enforces promises based on reliance and fairness.
• The doctrine varies by state in the U.S., but courts generally uphold it when injustice would otherwise occur.
• Landmark cases demonstrate how courts interpret and enforce promissory estoppel in different legal scenarios.

A promissory estoppel example involves a false statement that the court treats as a promise. In this regard, the person who made the false statement will be unable to deny it, making their promise enforceable, or a promissory estoppel. When a person has relied upon someone else's statement in good faith, a judge will prevent the person who made the statement from denying it.

In many cases, a contract becomes enforceable when a set amount of money is either agreed upon or exchanged. To be truly fair, you may discover that a court will enforce the promise even if no exchange was made. Simply put, a promise must be made and, upon the reliance of said promise, a significant loss must have been suffered. 

Promissory Estoppel Further Explained

Promissory estoppel is a formal legal principle. By law, a promise that was made becomes enforceable, even when it's made without any formal considerations. In essence, when someone makes a commitment to someone who goes on to rely on that promise, only to experience some sort of detriment, promissory estoppel may be enforced. This principle was created in order to prevent a promisor from arguing against the enforcement of their former promise.  

Legal Foundations of Promissory Estoppel

Promissory estoppel originates from equity law, ensuring fairness when formal contract elements are missing. Courts use this principle to prevent unjust outcomes by enforcing promises where:

1. A clear and definite promise was made.
2. The promisee reasonably relied on it.
3. The reliance resulted in significant harm.

This doctrine balances contract law principles with equity, ensuring that individuals and businesses do not suffer due to broken commitments, even when a formal contract was absent.

Promissory Estoppel Example

Let's say Mr. Smith has a contract to create a movie. As such, he decides to hire an artist to paint the set and agrees to pay him a portion of the profits. If the artist goes on to paint the entire set and then Mr. Smith reveals he never even had a contract, and there are therefore no proceeds to share, the artist may decide to sue him. In this instance, a judge may find that Mr. Smith can't deny he had a contract with the painter, and the artist will likely receive a judgment providing compensation for his work. 

Real-Life Promissory Estoppel Cases

Promissory estoppel has been upheld in numerous court cases. Here are some notable examples:

• Central London Property Trust Ltd v High Trees House Ltd (1947) – A landlord agreed to reduce rent during wartime. When they later sought full rent, the court held that the landlord was estopped from claiming back payments for the reduced period.
• Cohen v. Cowles Media Co. (1991) – A newspaper promised anonymity to a source but later disclosed their identity. The court ruled in favor of the source, emphasizing reliance and detriment.
• Drennan v. Star Paving Co. (1958) – A contractor relied on a subcontractor’s bid, which was later revoked. The court held that promissory estoppel applied since the contractor relied on the bid to their detriment.

These cases highlight how courts apply promissory estoppel to protect individuals and businesses from harmful reliance on broken promises.

Elements of a Promissory Estoppel

Certain legal requirements must be fulfilled in order to trigger a promissory estoppel. Of course, at its base, there must be someone making a promise, a promisee, and some type of detriment suffered by the promisee. Here are five legal elements of a promissory estoppel:

• Legal Relationship - A legal relationship must exist between two parties.
• Promise - The promisee must have relied on the promisor's guarantee, within reason.
• Reliance - It must be proven that the promisee took action based upon the promise that was made.
• Detriment - The promisee must also have suffered an economic loss due to the promisor's failure to abide by their promise.
• Unconscionability - The promisor's actions must be proven as unconscionable for failing to maintain his or her promise.

Here's another example of a promissory estoppel. Let's say an employer entered into a verbal agreement with an employee, whereby they would pay that employee an agreed-upon amount throughout the duration of their retirement. If that employee then proceeds to file for retirement, based on the promise made by the employer, the employer could be legally estopped from not delivering on the payments throughout the course of the former employee's retirement. 

Defenses Against Promissory Estoppel Claims

While promissory estoppel can make promises legally enforceable, defendants may use the following defenses:

1. No Clear and Definite Promise – If the statement was vague or conditional, courts may not enforce it.
2. Unreasonable Reliance – If the reliance on the promise was not justified, the claim may fail.
3. Lack of Detriment – If the promisee did not suffer actual harm, promissory estoppel does not apply.
4. Statute of Frauds – Some states require certain promises to be in writing, which can limit promissory estoppel claims.

Courts assess each case individually to determine whether these defenses apply, ensuring fairness in legal proceedings.

Promissory Estoppel in Contract Law

You will come across promissory estoppel most commonly in the field of contract law. The entire premise surrounding a contract involves two parties who negotiated an agreement based upon a promise. 

Typically, contract law requires that a person receives a certain amount of consideration before entering into a promise. This makes legal consideration of value when two parties enter into an agreement or contract. A consideration such as this may include the exchange of money or a promise to avoid a certain action. These types of actions will make a contract legally enforceable. 

When a court is attempting to deliver justice, you may find that it enforces a promise without any consideration. This will depend upon the promise, with evidence that it was reasonably relied upon and that dependence resulted in some sort of damage to the promisee. 

While all fifty states enforce promissory estoppel, requirements will vary state by state. Generally speaking, you'll be looking at a case where an injured party is seeking to recover from a promise he or she relied upon, only to suffer a subsequent loss. 

Promissory Estoppel vs. Contract Law

Promissory estoppel and contract law share similarities but have distinct differences:

While contracts require an exchange of value, promissory estoppel applies when reliance on a promise causes harm, even without formal agreement terms.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the main purpose of promissory estoppel? Promissory estoppel ensures fairness by preventing a promisor from going back on a promise if the promisee reasonably relied on it and suffered a loss.

2. How does promissory estoppel differ from breach of contract? A breach of contract requires a legally binding agreement, while promissory estoppel enforces promises without formal contracts if reliance leads to harm.

3. Can promissory estoppel be used in employment cases? Yes. If an employer makes a clear promise (e.g., guaranteed job security or retirement benefits) and an employee relies on it, courts may enforce the promise.

4. Does promissory estoppel require written proof? Not always. While written proof strengthens a case, courts enforce oral promises if the reliance and detriment are clear.

5. Is promissory estoppel recognized in all states? Yes, but state laws vary in their application. Some states may require additional conditions for enforcement.

If you need help with a promissory estoppel example, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.