Key Takeaways:

  • Definition of Breach: A breach of a confidentiality agreement occurs when confidential information is disclosed without authorization.
  • Common Defenses: Defendants may argue lack of confidentiality, prior disclosure, public domain information, or mutual breach.
  • Types of Confidentiality Agreements: NDAs can be unilateral or mutual, with varying levels of restriction.
  • Legal Remedies: Breach consequences include financial damages, injunctions, and contractual penalties.
  • Importance in Business: Confidentiality agreements are crucial in employment, business negotiations, and intellectual property protection.
  • Limitations: Confidentiality agreements cannot override legal obligations to disclose information (e.g., subpoenas).
  • Preventive Measures: Proper contract drafting, training, and security protocols reduce the risk of breaches.
  • Hiring Legal Help: Consulting an attorney can help draft, enforce, and defend confidentiality agreements effectively.

When Does a Breach of a Confidentiality Agreement Arise?

A breach of a confidentiality agreement may occur when individuals make public information that they agreed to keep secret.

Confidentiality Agreements

Employers and employees generally sign confidentiality agreements to protect the company’s sensitive information from unauthorized disclosure.

What Is the Nature of Confidentiality Agreements?

Employers that need to protect their sensitive information generally have their employees enter a confidentiality agreement promising that they won't publicize certain information related to their work.

Where Are Confidentiality Agreements Included?

Confidentiality agreements may form part of the terms of an individual's employment contract, and they can also be signed mid-employment when the need arises.

What Are Examples of Breaches of Confidentiality Agreements?

Breach of confidentiality agreements can occur in the following situations:

  • Disclosing proprietary information through publication in a written document, online article, newspaper, and related media.
  • Revealing the information orally to another person.
  • Using nonverbal communication to disclose information.
  • Revealing an item or product which shouldn't be seen yet by other people.
  • Revealing sensitive details about recipes, formulas, construction plans, and other information.

What Does Enforcing a Confidentiality Agreement Involve?

Generally, enforcement of a confidentiality agreement often involves awarding monetary damages to the party seeking enforcement.

Additionally, a confidentiality agreement can also be enforced by terminating the employment of the breaching party, forcing the employee to return any information or product belonging to the employer, or applying punitive measures on the employee.

Common Defenses Against a Breach of Confidentiality Agreement

When accused of breaching a confidentiality agreement, the defendant may raise several defenses to challenge the claim. These include:

  • Lack of Confidentiality: The plaintiff must prove that the disclosed information was indeed confidential. If the information was already publicly available, the agreement may not be enforceable.
  • Prior Disclosure: If the information was disclosed by the plaintiff to third parties before the agreement, the defendant may argue that it was not protected.
  • Public Domain: If the information became public through no fault of the defendant, they cannot be held liable.
  • Mutual Breach: If both parties failed to uphold their obligations under the agreement, the defendant may claim that the contract is void.
  • Unreasonable Restrictions: Some agreements impose overly broad restrictions that courts may find unenforceable. For instance, NDAs that last indefinitely or cover non-sensitive information may be invalidated.

Are There Any Defenses for a Breach of Contract Agreement?

Several breaches of contract defenses apply to breach of confidential agreement cases. One remedy that can be used is the defense of unclean hands. The defense of unclean hands is used where the party seeking enforcement has also engaged in the same type of conduct over which it is suing the breaching party, which makes them ineligible for seeking legal redress.

Where Are Confidential Agreements Used?

Typically, confidential agreements or nondisclosure agreements are employed in various contexts, such as:

  • Employment contracts
  • Business transactions
  • Intellectual properties
  • Litigation settlements

Limitations and Legal Considerations for Confidentiality Agreements

While confidentiality agreements are powerful tools, they have limitations, including:

  • Cannot Override Legal Obligations: Confidentiality agreements cannot prevent disclosures required by law, such as court orders or regulatory investigations.
  • Must Be Reasonable in Scope: Courts may refuse to enforce agreements that impose excessive restrictions on employees or business partners.
  • Lack of Enforcement Mechanisms: If an agreement does not specify consequences for breach, enforcement can be difficult.

Businesses should carefully draft NDAs and seek legal counsel to ensure enforceability.

Is Violating a Confidentiality Agreement a Breach of a Contract?

Violating a confidentiality agreement is considered a breach of contract.

Legal Remedies for Breach of a Confidentiality Agreement

A breach of confidentiality can result in various legal remedies, including:

  1. Monetary Damages – Courts may award damages to compensate for financial losses resulting from the breach.
  2. Injunctive Relief – A court may issue an injunction to prevent further disclosure of confidential information.
  3. Liquidated Damages – Some agreements specify a predetermined amount payable upon breach.
  4. Return of Confidential Materials – The court may order the breaching party to return any sensitive documents or information.
  5. Employment Termination – A confidentiality breach in the workplace may result in dismissal.

Can Legal Action Be Made for Breach of Contracts?

Any party that suffers losses due to a breach can take legal action, including seeking damages.

What Are the Factors to Consider When Signing a Confidentiality Agreement?

Before signing a confidentiality agreement, be sure you clearly understand the statements, events, and acts covered by its terms.

Forms of Confidentiality Agreements

Confidentiality agreements can take different forms, including:

  • Least Restrictive Agreement: This type of agreement only restricts a person from revealing the financial terms of a legal settlement to the media.
  • More Restrictive Agreement: This type of agreement prohibits a party from disclosing the details of a lawsuit, legal theories of the plaintiff or defendant in a lawsuit, or the provisions of a legal settlement.

In employment contracts, a nonsolicitation agreement is less restrictive, while a non-compete agreement is highly restrictive. The purpose of each agreement is to prohibit employees and ex-employees from engaging in certain conducts.

What Can a Party Who Files a Breach of Contract Lawsuit Include?

Most times, a party that files a breach of contract lawsuit usually include a demand for damages as compensation for the loss it suffered due to the conduct of the breaching party.

What Is the Penalty for Violating a Confidentiality Agreement?

Violating a confidentiality agreement attracts penalties based on the provisions of the agreement. The breaching party may be compelled to pay an agreed sum of money according to the terms of the agreement, or the provisions of the agreement may require the breaching party to lose any money it was awarded in a legal settlement.

If the terms of the agreement do not mention damages, the plaintiff must prove the damages it suffered as a result of the violating party's conduct and will only receive compensation for those damages.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What qualifies as a breach of a confidentiality agreement?
    A breach occurs when confidential information is disclosed to unauthorized parties without permission, violating the terms of the agreement.
  2. Can you defend against a confidentiality breach claim?
    Yes. Common defenses include lack of confidentiality, prior disclosure, public domain information, and unreasonable restrictions in the agreement.
  3. What are the penalties for breaching a confidentiality agreement?
    Penalties may include financial damages, injunctions, contract termination, and return of confidential materials.
  4. Are confidentiality agreements always enforceable?
    Not always. If an agreement is overly broad, contains unreasonable restrictions, or conflicts with public policy, courts may refuse enforcement.
  5. What should I do if I am accused of breaching a confidentiality agreement?
    Consult a legal professional immediately to assess your defense options and respond appropriately to avoid legal consequences.

If you need more information about penalties for breach of contract, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.