Is a Verbal Agreement Binding in PA? Laws & Limitations
Is a verbal agreement binding in PA? Learn about enforceability, legal exceptions, and how to prove an oral contract. Get expert insights on Pennsylvania contract law. 6 min read updated on February 12, 2025
Key Takeaways:
- Verbal agreements are generally binding in Pennsylvania, but certain types of contracts must be in writing to be enforceable under the Statute of Frauds.
- Essential elements of a valid verbal contract include an offer, acceptance, and consideration.
- Proving a verbal agreement can be challenging, requiring evidence like witness testimony, emails, text messages, or past dealings.
- Limitations and exceptions apply, such as real estate transactions, sales of goods over $500, and agreements lasting more than one year.
- Partial performance can sometimes make an oral contract enforceable if one party has taken significant steps to fulfill the agreement.
- Common disputes arise over misunderstandings due to the lack of written documentation.
- Legal recourse is available if a party breaches a verbal contract, but proving terms in court can be difficult.
- Consulting an attorney is advisable for those entering or disputing a verbal contract in Pennsylvania.
About PA Verbal Contract Law
The Offer
An offer is an objective process of intent to be bound by an agreement. For example, when you're shopping, you place an item on the checkout counter and present your credit card. That may suffice as a contract. On the other hand, asking the cashier if they will take $500 for the item versus the actual price of $600 does not constitute a contract.
The Acceptance
An acceptance is when the offer is accepted via communication that specifies an intent to be bound that is consistent with the offer. Using the shopping experience as an example, if you place an item on the counter and the sales clerk goes outside and places a note on your vehicle stating they accept your offer, it is not a contract since you needed to know if the offer was accepted before leaving the store.
When you placed the item on the checkout counter and presented your credit card, however, it was implied the offer was accepted by scanning your card. While this may seem confusing, a court would look at the objective implication of the conduct of the parties involved.
In Pennsylvania, a contract does not need to be in writing for it to be considered valid. This can lead to confusion when one party thinks a contract is in place and the other party disagrees that no agreement/contract exists. In addition to misunderstandings between the parties, the addition of emails and texts play a role requiring the courts to determine and resolve if these methods constitute a contract.
The Consideration
A unilateral contract is unenforceable since it means only one party has the responsibility to do something. For example, promising a gift is not enforceable. For the contract to be enforceable, both parties must have something specific to exchange. This could be anything from a promise for a promise or a service provided or something in exchange. When this happens, it is referred to as consideration. Agreeing to pay $10 for a new car is a consideration if that is the intent of the seller.
Exceptions exist in most cases, and a claim may exist for detrimental reliance or "promissory estoppel" even if the consideration is lacking and one party has relied on a promise that proves to be detrimental. In this case, the relying party had the option to sue but only to the extent of his or her reliance.
An example would be when one party promises to give their car to another party. Based on that promise, the receiving party donates their car to a charity based on reliance. In this case, the party promising the car may be liable for the cost of replacing the second party's car if the promise is broken.
In the event a contract does not exist, if one party unjustly enriches another party by doing something, there may be a claim for the amount of the enrichment. In this example, a contractor builds a garage at the wrong address. Obviously, he has no contract with the property owner. The garage, however, increases the property value. The contractor may have a claim for unjust enrichment if the court deems that fairness is required.
Reasonably Specific Terms
Agreements must include essential terms that all parties have agreed to. Essential terms are specified depending on the nature of the transaction. For example, when buying a car, the price is considered an essential term. A court may imply non-essential terms regarding the intent of the parties but not the essential terms.
The Role of Partial Performance in Oral Contracts
Even if a contract should be in writing under the Statute of Frauds, courts may enforce it if one party has partially performed the agreement. Partial performance occurs when:
- One party pays a portion of the agreed-upon amount
- Work or services have already been partially completed
- A party relied on the contract and took significant action, such as moving into a rented property
For example, if a landlord and tenant make a verbal rental agreement, and the tenant moves in and pays rent, the court may enforce the contract even if it wasn’t written.
The Role of the Statute of Frauds in Pennsylvania
In Pennsylvania, the Statute of Frauds dictates that certain contracts must be in writing to be enforceable. This law exists to prevent fraudulent claims and ensure clarity in agreements. Examples of contracts requiring a written agreement include:
- Agreements for the sale of real estate
- Contracts that cannot be performed within one year
- Promises to pay another person's debt
- Marriage-related contracts, including prenuptial agreements
- The sale of goods over $500, as governed by the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC)
If a verbal agreement falls under any of these categories, it is unenforceable in court unless there is a written contract signed by both parties. However, certain exceptions, such as partial performance or admissions in court, can make an oral contract enforceable.
Types of Contracts
There is a difference between oral contracts, which are sometimes referred to as "verbal contracts" or "verbal agreements." An oral contract means it is spoken. A verbal contract can be anything that involves words or is verbalized. Verbalized can be through speech or writing.
Contract types include:
- Service contracts such as agency agreements or car washes.
- The sale of goods that are not part of the Uniform C Code (UCC).
- Lawsuit settlements.
- Landlord-tenant leases.
- Agreements that may be performed within a year.
Challenges of Enforcing a Verbal Agreement
While Pennsylvania law recognizes verbal contracts, enforcing them in court can be difficult due to the lack of documentation. When a dispute arises, proving the contract's existence and terms requires supporting evidence, such as:
- Witness testimony from individuals who heard the agreement being made
- Emails or text messages referencing the contract
- Bank statements or receipts showing transactions related to the contract
- Previous dealings between the parties, establishing a pattern of similar agreements
Courts will also examine the credibility of the parties involved, any partial performance, and whether unjust enrichment occurred—where one party benefited unfairly at another's expense.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. Is a verbal contract legally enforceable in Pennsylvania?Yes, verbal contracts are generally enforceable in Pennsylvania, provided they include an offer, acceptance, and consideration. However, certain agreements must be in writing under the Statute of Frauds.
2. What types of verbal agreements are not legally binding in PA?Contracts for real estate, agreements lasting over a year, promises to pay another’s debt, and sales of goods over $500 must be in writing to be enforceable.
3. How can I prove a verbal contract in court?You can provide witness testimony, written communications (emails, texts), payment records, or evidence of past business dealings to support your claim.
4. Can a verbal contract be broken in Pennsylvania?If both parties mutually agree to terminate the contract, it can be dissolved. However, if one party breaches it without agreement, the other party may seek legal action.
5. Should I consult an attorney for a verbal contract dispute?Yes, consulting an attorney is highly recommended. Given the challenges of proving verbal agreements, legal guidance can help you understand your rights and options.
If you need help with PA verbal contract law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.