Key Takeaways

  • New Jersey does not require franchise disclosure document (FDD) registration but mandates compliance with federal franchise laws.
  • The New Jersey Franchise Practices Act protects franchisees with rights like notice before termination and fair transfer approvals.
  • LLCs in New Jersey are taxed as pass-through entities at the federal level, though they may face state-level obligations like minimum business taxes.
  • Franchise owners often choose an LLC structure for liability protection, flexible taxation, and easier compliance compared to corporations.
  • The New Jersey LLC franchise tax may include annual report fees, minimum business tax, and, in some cases, corporate business tax depending on classification.

New Jersey's Franchise Disclosure Document Registration

Unlike some states, New Jersey does not require that businesses register their franchise disclosure documents (FDD) with its state regulator; however, business owners must ensure that their franchises operate according to Federal Franchise Laws. This means that owners have to retain current FDD that they can present to any potential New Jersey franchisees prior to selling their franchises.

The New Jersey Franchise Practices Act was created to provide protection and rights to New Jersey franchisees after signing franchise agreements. This act forbids specific provisions and actions through the agreement that pertain to the relationships between franchisors and franchisee.

New Jersey's FDD is ruled by the FTC Franchise Rule. This rule demands that a franchisor provide a legal and current FDD to any potential franchisees within 14 days prior to signing an agreement or exchanging any money.

Franchise Ownership Through an LLC

Many entrepreneurs considering a franchise in New Jersey choose to form an LLC for their business. Using an LLC as the ownership entity provides liability protection for the owners, separating personal assets from business obligations. For franchisees, this is especially valuable because franchising often involves significant investment and contractual obligations.

Key reasons franchise owners select an LLC include:

  • Liability Protection: The LLC shields personal assets from lawsuits, debts, or claims against the franchise.
  • Flexibility in Management: LLCs allow members to structure management in a way that best fits their business model.
  • Franchise Agreement Compliance: Most franchisors permit ownership through an LLC, provided it meets financial and operational requirements.

However, franchisees must ensure the LLC structure aligns with the franchisor’s approval process. In some cases, franchisors require the LLC to include specific members as guarantors on franchise agreements.

New Jersey's Franchise Practices Act

The New Jersey Franchise Practices Act was designed to oversee the interactions and relationships between franchisees and franchisors. Under this act, franchisors need to be aware of the additional obligations the act puts in place, and franchisees should be aware of the supplemental benefits it gives them.

Following are a few examples of these additional rights and obligations imposed under the New Jersey Franchise Practices Act:

  • Franchisors are obligated to give franchisees a minimum of 60 days' notice and explanation prior to terminating, canceling, or denying renewal of a franchise.
  • When a franchisee requests permission from the franchisor to sell or transfer the franchise, the franchisor has 60 days to either approve or deny this request and provide his or her reasoning. If the franchisor fails to reply within 60 days, the request is automatically approved.
  • A franchisor cannot force a franchisee to sign a release form as a requirement to own a franchise.

Other regulations and rules in the New Jersey Franchise Practices Act focus on monitoring the relationship between the franchisor and franchisee as well as protecting the franchisee from any unreasonable interference by the franchisor concerning the operation of the franchise.

How New Jersey Taxes LLC Franchise Owners

While the federal tax system treats LLCs as pass-through entities, New Jersey imposes additional requirements that affect LLC franchise owners. These include:

  • Annual Report Fee: New Jersey LLCs must file an annual report and pay a $75 fee to remain in good standing.
  • Minimum Business Tax: Multi-member LLCs classified as partnerships may be subject to a minimum business tax in New Jersey, even if no income is reported.
  • Corporate Business Tax (CBT): If an LLC elects to be taxed as a corporation, it may owe the New Jersey CBT, which applies to C-corporations and certain S-corporations.

These taxes and fees are separate from the federal pass-through tax rules and can affect a franchise’s profitability if not budgeted for properly.

LLC Federal Taxes

All federal taxes are submitted to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). In New Jersey, limited liability companies (LLCs) report their taxes to the IRS, but they do not pay their taxes. This is because an LLC is a flow-through entity, meaning the profits and losses of the business pass on to the owners. The owners then file and pay the LLC's taxes on their individual tax return. The IRS automatically taxes the LLC based on the number of owners it has.

If an LLC in New Jersey has only one owner, it is taxed as a disregarded entity:

  • If the one owner is an individual, the LLC is considered a sole proprietorship.
  • If the one owner is another business, the LLC is considered a section or branch of the parent business.

As mentioned previously, LLCs and sole proprietorships are taxed as flow-through entities, meaning their owners report and pay the taxes of the business on their individual tax returns or 1040 forms. Usually, any profits and losses of the business are reported on a Schedule C. Depending on the business, other schedules and forms may be required.

If an LLC in New Jersey has more than one owner, then it is taxed as though it is a partnership. As a partnership, an LLC must report and file its own tax return or Form 1065. It is also required to provide each owner with a K-1, detailing the percentage of the LLC's profits. The owners include the K-1 with their individual tax returns.

An LLC is elected as a sole proprietorship or partnership automatically by the IRS. When the LLC applies for an employer identification number (EIN), it lists the number of owners of the LLC. The IRS uses this information to determine which tax election to assign.

If desired, an owner can also request to be taxed as a corporation. There are two types of corporations with different taxation requirements:

Pros and Cons of an LLC for Franchise Operations

Choosing an LLC structure for a franchise offers several advantages, but there are also potential drawbacks to consider.

Advantages:

  • Pass-Through Taxation: Profits and losses flow directly to the members’ individual tax returns, avoiding double taxation.
  • Simpler Compliance: LLCs have fewer ongoing compliance requirements compared to corporations.
  • Flexibility: Owners can elect corporate taxation if it benefits the franchise financially.

Disadvantages:

  • Self-Employment Taxes: LLC members may owe self-employment tax on their share of profits, which can be higher than corporate tax rates.
  • Franchisor Requirements: Some franchisors may prefer corporate structures for ease of oversight, which could limit LLC use in certain franchise systems.
  • State-Level Costs: New Jersey’s annual fees, minimum tax, and possible CBT classification can increase operating costs.

For many franchise owners, the benefits of forming an LLC outweigh the drawbacks, but careful tax planning is essential.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Does New Jersey have a specific franchise tax for LLCs?
    Not directly. LLCs in New Jersey pay annual report fees and may owe a minimum business tax or corporate business tax depending on their classification.
  2. Can I operate a franchise through an LLC in New Jersey?
    Yes. Most franchisors allow LLC ownership, but they may require members to personally guarantee the franchise agreement.
  3. How much is the New Jersey LLC annual report fee?
    It is $75, payable each year to keep the LLC in good standing.
  4. Do single-member LLCs owe New Jersey franchise taxes?
    Single-member LLCs generally report income on the owner’s personal return, but they must still file annual reports and pay the fee.
  5. What are the advantages of using an LLC for a franchise?
    LLCs provide liability protection, pass-through taxation, and management flexibility, though owners should consider state-level tax costs.

If you need help with the New Jersey franchise tax, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.