Key Takeaways

  • Franchise liability determines whether a franchisor, franchisee, or both are legally responsible for debts, lawsuits, or damages.
  • Liability often depends on the business structure, the franchise agreement, and how much control the franchisor exercises over daily operations.
  • Most franchisees benefit from limited liability protection, but certain actions (like negligence or contractual breaches) can expose personal assets.
  • Franchisors can also face liability under “vicarious liability” principles if they exert significant control over franchise operations.
  • Risk mitigation strategies — such as strong franchise agreements, insurance, and compliance programs — are critical to protecting both parties.

Franchise limited or unlimited liability are issues that could arise for a franchise owner. When any person forms a business, he or she must keep in mind the type of business structure that is being established to be able to identify if the law protects that owner from liability over the company’s outstanding debts.

Franchise: An Overview

A franchise is a type of ownership that allows the franchisee to borrow the franchisor’s business model and brand for a period of time during the franchise operations.

Such franchises are set up through a licensing agreement with the franchisor. The contractual relationship itself will identify how the franchisee must run the business, what items must be sold, the pricing points, among several other items.

Generally, franchises are quite popular, as a lot of restaurants you see today are in fact franchises. Some examples of franchises include fast food restaurants, such as Burger King, McDonalds, Dairy Queen, Wendy’s, and others. Owning a franchise allows you to own a well-known brand, which will help you quickly overcome any issues that most owners have running their own business, particularly, if it’s a brand-new business that isn’t already well established and known by the public.

Legal Basis of Franchise Liability

Franchise liability refers to the legal responsibility a franchisor or franchisee holds for debts, damages, or legal claims arising from the franchise’s operations. Determining who is liable often depends on two key factors: the franchise agreement and the level of control the franchisor exercises over the franchisee’s daily operations.

Generally, franchisees operate as independent businesses. This means they are typically responsible for obligations such as rent, payroll, tax liabilities, and lawsuits involving their employees or customers. However, if the franchisor exerts significant control — particularly over hiring, training, pricing, or daily management — courts may find the franchisor jointly liable under a legal doctrine known as vicarious liability.

Courts analyze the nature of the relationship between franchisor and franchisee to decide liability, often looking at:

  • The degree of operational control.
  • Whether the franchisor’s policies contributed to a legal violation.
  • How the franchise is presented to the public (e.g., branding, signage, marketing).

How the Franchisor Helps

The franchisor helps the franchisee in the following ways:

1.Finds the premise for the franchisee

2.Assists in constructing and/or refurbishing the premises

3.Helps obtain planning approvals, business permits, etc.

4.Helps with purchasing of inventory

5.Provides training on how to operate the franchise

6.Provides the necessary systems and other technologies required for daily operations

7.Trains you on how to market and advertise what you are selling

8.Provides a list of other franchisees that own and operate the same type of franchise, i.e., fast food restaurant

The franchisor also provides managerial advice and guidance to the owner and manager in how to own and operate a business, and overcome any issues that they might face with customers or employees.

Disadvantages of a Franchise

While there are several benefits to owning a franchise, there might be some disadvantages, too, including:

1.Franchise fees

2.Restrictions on managing the business

3.Royalties

While the franchisee owns the franchise, the franchisor still has a lot of control over how the franchise will be maintained. Therefore, all franchisees operating under the franchisor will need to abide by the requirements set forth by the franchisor. Furthermore, the franchisee has little control over which suppliers they can purchase from. Even if the franchisee can purchase supplies at a cheaper cost elsewhere, they might be required to spend more money if the supplier they want to use isn’t on the list. What’s more, the franchisor can, at any time, modify the operating agreement, requiring that the franchisee significantly alter their way of operating, even if that means spending more money. If the franchisee eventually wants to sell the franchise, the franchisor must approve the sale, along with the buyer.

Common Legal Risks for Franchisees

While a franchise provides brand recognition and support, franchisees still face several types of legal risks. Understanding these risks can help minimize exposure and protect the business.

  1. Contractual Liability: Franchisees are bound by the terms of the franchise agreement. Breaching this agreement — such as failing to meet performance standards or using unapproved suppliers — can result in lawsuits or termination.
  2. Employment Claims: Franchisees are typically responsible for their employees. Wrongful termination, wage disputes, or discrimination claims can lead to costly litigation.
  3. Premises Liability: Accidents or injuries occurring on the franchise premises (like slip-and-fall incidents) often fall on the franchisee.
  4. Product Liability: If defective products or unsafe food cause harm, the franchisee — and in some cases the franchisor — may face legal action.
  5. Intellectual Property Misuse: Unauthorized use of the franchisor’s brand or IP beyond agreed terms can result in penalties.

While limited liability structures can shield personal assets, franchisees should maintain adequate insurance coverage and follow compliance protocols to reduce risks.

Limited Liability

Franchises offer limited liability for the franchisee from any legal suits brought by customers or employees. This means that the franchise owner’s personal assets cannot be affected by the outstanding debts of the franchise.

When Limited Liability May Not Apply

Although limited liability protects a franchisee’s personal assets in most circumstances, certain actions can pierce that protection. Courts may “pierce the corporate veil” — making the owner personally liable — if the franchisee:

  • Engages in fraud or intentional misconduct.
  • Commits gross negligence or unlawful acts.
  • Fails to maintain separate personal and business finances.
  • Under-capitalizes the business or misrepresents its financial position.

Similarly, franchisors can lose liability protection if they overstep their boundaries. If they control day-to-day operations beyond brand standards or are directly involved in employment decisions, they could be held liable for workplace violations, discrimination, or wage-and-hour claims.

Role & Responsibilities of a Franchisee

Once you are ready to purchase a franchise, you will need to submit an application and show proof that you can meet the financial responsibilities of owning a franchise. If accepted, you will likely need to meet with a representative of the franchisor to discuss your goals. This meeting is essentially an interview wherein you can ask any questions you might have pertaining to the franchise, while the representative can evaluate your qualifications and understanding of what it takes to manage a franchise.

If both parties choose to continue, a second meeting will be held to formalize the agreement. Before doing so, you might want to speak to a qualified attorney who can assist you throughout the process. In addition to the initial fee for purchasing the franchise, there will be ongoing fees and royalties.

As previously noted, you will need to evidence that you are financially stable enough to manage the franchise. If you don’t have enough money to initially purchase the franchise, then the franchisor will not approve your application. But even if you have enough funds, you must show that you have additional funds to be able to afford other costs associated with the franchise, including purchasing/leasing a location along with marketing and advertising materials.

Risk Mitigation Strategies for Franchisees and Franchisors

Both parties can significantly reduce franchise liability with proactive strategies, including:

  • Well-Drafted Franchise Agreements: Clearly outline operational boundaries, responsibilities, and liability limitations.
  • Proper Business Formation: Operating as an LLC or corporation helps shield personal assets.
  • Insurance Coverage: Liability, employment practices, and product liability insurance can provide critical financial protection.
  • Compliance Training: Regular training on labor laws, health and safety regulations, and consumer protection laws helps prevent legal violations.
  • Operational Independence: Franchisors should limit involvement in daily operations to brand standards, while franchisees should avoid implying they are agents of the franchisor.

These steps can help ensure that franchise relationships remain mutually beneficial while minimizing legal risks for both parties.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Who is responsible for lawsuits in a franchise business?
    Usually, the franchisee is responsible since they operate the business. However, the franchisor can also be held liable if they exert significant operational control or contribute to the cause of the lawsuit.
  2. Can a franchisor be sued for an employee’s actions?
    Yes. Under vicarious liability, a franchisor may be held liable if they direct employment policies, participate in hiring, or maintain control over employee conduct.
  3. Does forming an LLC protect a franchisee from liability?
    Forming an LLC or corporation generally protects personal assets from business debts and lawsuits, but this protection can be lost if the owner commits fraud, mixes finances, or violates laws.
  4. What happens if a franchise agreement is breached?
    A breach can lead to termination of the agreement, legal claims for damages, or injunctions. The specific consequences depend on the terms of the contract.
  5. How can franchise liability be minimized?
    Using comprehensive contracts, obtaining insurance, adhering to laws, and maintaining operational independence are key steps in reducing liability for both franchisors and franchisees.

If you need help with franchise liability, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law, and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.