Key Takeaways

  • LLCs can elect Subchapter S status to benefit from pass-through taxation while minimizing self-employment taxes.
  • S Corp status requires careful compliance with IRS rules and timely filing of Form 2553.
  • The S Corp structure is ideal for businesses that can pay owners a reasonable salary and take advantage of distributions.
  • There are limitations on ownership and stock structure to qualify for Subchapter S status.
  • Making this election can impact your broader business strategy, including your HR business plan if you're hiring or growing rapidly.

For tax status, LLC subchapter S election is like having the best of both worlds for your business. It may come as a surprise that you may freely choose which tax type your business entity should have, including corporation, partnership, and subchapter S corporation. Although the partnership option is popular, choosing Subchapter S status has many benefits. Both have pass-through tax treatment. Both the LLC and Subchapter S structures are not responsible for paying their own taxes. Profits pass on to the owners, who report the income on their own 1040 tax forms. Also, both separate the business from personal assets in terms of liability.

Differences Between LLCs and S Corporations

There are a few important differences between the two structures. LLCs are generally simpler to run. You'll need fewer meetings, less documentation, lower startup capital, and fewer state filings and forms. Many business owners appreciate this. 

The LLC is also more flexible in how the profits and losses are distributed among the owners. In an LLC, even if two owners have the same percentage of ownership, they may elect to split the profits and losses according to how much time was spent running it. In an S corporation, each would automatically be taxed on 50 percent of the profits.

On the other hand, the S corporation offers more flexibility in how profits are distributed. With an LLC, profits are considered self-employment income, so the owners must pay self-employment tax. With an S corporation, earnings are considered wages and distributions. Deductions for Social Security and Medicare only apply to the wages, not the distributions. The only restriction is that owners must be paid a reasonable salary.

What most people are unaware of, however, is that an LLC can be set up so the IRS treats it as an S corporation. Although the business enjoys all the advantages of having an LLC, owners can receive some of the profits as distributions instead of salary, thereby avoiding taxes for Medicare and Social Security.

When an LLC Should Consider S Corporation Status

An LLC might consider electing S corporation status when the business begins generating substantial profits beyond the owners’ reasonable compensation. In these cases, the S corp structure allows owners to divide income into salary and distributions, reducing self-employment tax obligations. Additionally, businesses with stable operations and plans for employee expansion often benefit from S corp status, particularly when preparing an HR business plan that includes salary structures and benefit offerings.

It’s also a strategic move for LLCs that want to formalize their compensation model while still maintaining pass-through taxation. Owners who plan to reinvest profits or scale without seeking outside investors might find the S corp election especially appealing.

How S Corporation Tax Works

S corporations and LLCs are both pass-through entities, which means income and losses are passed along to the owners, who report it on their own taxes. S corporations need to file informational returns (Form 1120S) to report the business's profits, losses, deductions, and other details each year. Shareholders are provided with a Schedule K-1 with information on their shares of each of the above items. In turn, shareholders file Schedule E when paying their yearly taxes.

S corporation owners who work within the business are considered employees as well as owners. Therefore, they are paid a salary for their labor. Although the tax rate for Medicare and Social Security remains the same, it's paid in a different way. Half is paid by the employee and half by the employer. As an owner, you are paying the same amount, even though it's split.

Subchapter S Election and Your HR Business Plan

Choosing to be taxed as an S corporation can directly influence your HR business plan. Because the IRS requires reasonable salaries for shareholder-employees, this decision may shape payroll practices, benefits packages, and long-term compensation strategy.

When developing an HR business plan, consider the following:

  • Reasonable Compensation: You must pay shareholder-employees a fair market wage before issuing distributions. This requirement impacts payroll planning and budgeting.
  • Payroll Taxes: Since distributions aren’t subject to payroll taxes, you can structure compensation efficiently, optimizing both tax liability and cash flow.
  • Employee Benefits: Electing S corporation status may enhance your eligibility for certain tax-advantaged benefit programs, including retirement plans and health insurance reimbursement arrangements.
  • Hiring Strategy: If your business anticipates hiring full-time employees, factoring these payroll obligations into your HR business plan will be essential.

By aligning your S corporation election with a thoughtful HR strategy, you can ensure compliance while maximizing financial efficiency and growth potential.

Can Your LLC Elect S-Corp Status?

There are some restrictions on who can form an S corporation. You can elect S-corporation status if:

  • The owners are U.S. citizens or residents with valid Social Security numbers
  • You are the single member in an LLC, considered a disregarded entity
  • There are two or more members in your LLC, considered a partnership
  • You have an EIN (Federal Tax ID Number) for your LLC
  • Your business is already formed as an LLC — it may not begin as an S corporation
  • Your business has no more than 100 shareholders
  • Your business has only one class of stock
  • None of the company's shareholders are other partnerships or corporations

To elect an S-corporation taxation entity for your business, you must submit IRS Form 2553. This must take place no more than two months and 15 days after the tax year that you want this change to go into effect. Doing this on time eliminates a lot of paperwork normally required by a corporation. The effective date can be no more than 12 months after the date of filing.

Although pass-through entities are popular in the U.S., it's not necessarily the right choice for every business. Remember, if such an election is made, revisions to the company's operating agreement must take place, as well as adherence to all rules and regulations. If this is done improperly, the IRS may consider the company a C corporation instead. 

Steps to Maintain Compliance After Electing S Corp Status

Once your LLC elects S corporation tax treatment, maintaining compliance is crucial. Failure to follow the IRS’s rules may result in disqualification and default taxation as a C corporation. To stay compliant:

  • Pay Reasonable Salaries: Ensure owner-employees are paid fair wages before taking distributions.
  • File Form 1120S: Submit your annual S corporation tax return and issue Schedule K-1 to each shareholder.
  • Update Operating Agreement: Reflect the S corp election and salary/distribution arrangements in your LLC’s internal documents.
  • Limit Stock Classes: Avoid creating different classes of stock, as only one is permitted under S corp rules.
  • Track Shareholder Changes: Ensure all shareholders are individuals or qualifying trusts, and none are partnerships or corporations.

Staying organized with these practices is particularly important if your HR business plan includes onboarding multiple employees, offering benefits, or expanding into new states.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the main benefit of electing S corporation status for an LLC?
    The main benefit is reducing self-employment taxes by splitting income into salary and distributions while maintaining pass-through taxation.
  2. How does electing S corp status impact my HR business plan?
    It requires you to establish and justify salaries for owners, affecting payroll planning, tax strategy, and benefits administration.
  3. Can a multi-member LLC choose S corp status?
    Yes, as long as it meets IRS requirements, including the shareholder and stock class limitations.
  4. Is there a deadline to file Form 2553 for S corp election?
    Yes, it must be filed no later than 2 months and 15 days after the start of the tax year in which the election is to take effect.
  5. What happens if an LLC fails to follow S corp rules?
    The IRS may revoke the S corp status, and the entity may be taxed as a C corporation, which could lead to double taxation.

If you need help with LLC subchapter S election, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on our behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.