Key Takeaways

  • LLCs and S corporations both offer liability protection and pass-through taxation, but their tax treatment, ownership restrictions, and operational structures differ significantly.
  • Electing Subchapter S status allows an LLC to reduce self-employment taxes while retaining flexible management and liability protections.
  • S corporations require stricter compliance (e.g., issuing stock, holding meetings, filing Form 1120-S) but can offer tax savings and more predictable compensation strategies.
  • When evaluating subchapter S vs LLC, consider factors like number and type of owners, tax goals, reinvestment plans, and long-term growth strategy.
  • Filing Form 2553 is essential to elect S corp status, and maintaining compliance is crucial to avoid losing this tax designation.

A subchapter S LLC is a business formation that combines elements of an S corporation with those of a limited liability company, or LLC.

LLC Electing S Corp Status -- The Best of Both Worlds

For new business owners or those who are considering changing the structure of their business, one of the most common first steps is comparing S corporations to LLCs.

Many entrepreneurs, accountants, and attorneys will debate over which business formation is best between the S corporation and the LLC. However, business owners don't necessarily have to choose between the two. A subchapter S LLC is a business that has been formed as an LLC and elected for taxation and treatment as an S corporation.

An LLC is a unique type of business formation that is governed by state laws. Each state has its own set of statutes that outline the rules of creating and operating an LLC. An S corporation, also called an S corp, is a corporation that is formed under state laws and files taxes under the United States IRS code, Subchapter S. An S corp isn't a specific business entity, but a tax filing status with the IRS.

If an LLC has high SECA or payroll taxes on the owner(s) and operates an active business or trade, electing for taxation as an S corporation may be beneficial. Both LLCs and S corps are pass-through organizations, which means the profits and losses are passed through the business to the owner(s). Another similarity is that both are formalities mandated by state laws and requirements, including paying any required fees and filing reports every year. Both offer limited liability protection to the business owner(s).

New business owners should look at the differences between LLCs and S corps to determine which formation is the best option.

  • An LLC is easier to form and operate than an S corporation.
  • An LLC is more flexible than an S corporation for allocating losses and profits between the owners.
  • An S corporation makes it easier to plan for taxes than an LLC.
  • An S corporation is more flexible in how the allocations to owners can be made, such as in the form of distributions or as earned income as wages or salaries.

You might choose one or the other, or you might elect for elements of both, but you should start by deciding which features are most critical to your business and its owners.

Understanding Subchapter S Election: Pros and Cons for LLCs

Electing S corporation status for your LLC can be a strategic decision — but it’s not always the right choice for every business. The main advantage is often tax efficiency. By default, LLC profits are subject to self-employment taxes, which include both the employer and employee portions of Social Security and Medicare. Once an LLC elects Subchapter S status, only the owner’s salary is subject to employment tax, while remaining profits distributed as dividends avoid self-employment tax. This can lead to significant savings for businesses with higher net income.

However, these savings come with additional responsibilities and limitations. S corps must adhere to stricter operational requirements — such as issuing stock, holding board meetings, and maintaining corporate minutes — to remain compliant. Additionally, they must have 100 or fewer shareholders, all of whom must be U.S. citizens or residents. They also cannot issue multiple classes of stock, which limits flexibility in profit distribution compared to an LLC.

When evaluating whether an S election makes sense, business owners should weigh factors such as:

  • Projected profits: Businesses expecting substantial profits often benefit most from S corp tax treatment.
  • Reinvestment strategy: S corps are better suited for businesses distributing profits rather than reinvesting them heavily.
  • Ownership plans: If you anticipate foreign investors or complex ownership structures, a traditional LLC may offer more flexibility.
  • Administrative capacity: S corps require more ongoing documentation and regulatory compliance.

How to File a Subchapter S Election Form (Form 2553)

To convert an LLC into a Subchapter S LLC for tax purposes, you must file IRS Form 2553, Election by a Small Business Corporation. This form officially notifies the IRS that your LLC will be taxed as an S corporation.

Steps to File Form 2553:

  1. Verify Eligibility:
    • Must be a domestic entity.
    • Have no more than 100 shareholders/members.
    • All owners must be U.S. citizens or resident aliens.
    • Can have only one class of ownership interest.
  2. Complete the Form Accurately:
    • Include the LLC’s name, address, and EIN.
    • Indicate the tax year.
    • Provide each owner’s name, address, and Social Security number.
    • Obtain signatures from all owners consenting to the election.
  3. Meet Filing Deadlines:
    • File within 75 days of formation or the beginning of the tax year the election will take effect.
    • If missed, consider late election relief by showing reasonable cause for the delay.
  4. Submit to the IRS:
    • Mail or fax the completed Form 2553 to the correct IRS service center (listed in the form’s instructions).

Filing on time is crucial. If the IRS rejects your election due to errors or missed deadlines, your LLC will be taxed under its default classification (usually a partnership for multi-member LLCs or sole proprietorship for single-member LLCs).

Differences in Ownership and Formalities

One of the main differences between S corporations and LLCs is restricted ownership. An LLC can have any number of owners, called members, while an S corporation is limited to a maximum of 100 owners, called shareholders. S corporation shareholders must be United States citizens and/or residents, while LLC members don't have to be citizens or residents. An S corporation can't be owned by a C corporation, partnership, another S corporation, or most types of trusts, but an LLC can be owned by another business, regardless of the formation.

An LLC can have subsidiary LLCs without any restrictions. An S corporation is subject to additional formalities, while an LLC doesn't have those same requirements. Some of these S corporation formalities include:

  • Holding an initial director and shareholder meeting
  • Holding annual shareholder and director meetings
  • Issuing stock
  • Maintaining minutes at all required meetings in the corporate records
  • Adopting bylaws

Although these formalities aren't required, they are recommended for LLCs:

  • Documenting any major business decisions
  • Adopting an operating agreement
  • Holding annual member and manager meetings
  • Documenting the annual meetings
  • Issuing shares of membership to each member

LLC members can choose between a member-managed and manager-managed organizational structure. If the members of an LLC choose to manage the day-to-day operations, it will operate similarly to a partnership. A manager-managed LLC is more similar to a corporation in terms of daily operations since the members aren't involved in small decisions. An S corporation must have a board of directors, which is responsible for overseeing all corporate affairs and handling crucial decisions, as well as officers.

The existence of an S corp is perpetual while an LLC, in some states, may be required to include a date of dissolution on its formation documents.

Subchapter S vs LLC: Taxation and Compliance Differences

One of the most critical distinctions in the subchapter S vs LLC decision is how each entity is taxed. Both offer pass-through taxation, but the mechanics differ significantly.

  • Default LLC Taxation: Profits “pass through” directly to the members, who report them on their personal tax returns. These profits are subject to income tax and self-employment tax.
  • S Corporation Taxation: An S corp also passes income to shareholders, but only the salaries paid to owner-employees are subject to employment taxes. Additional distributions are taxed as regular income but are not subject to payroll taxes, offering potential tax savings.

Another difference is how losses and deductions are handled. LLC members can generally deduct losses up to their investment in the company, while S corp shareholders’ deductions are often limited to their basis in the stock and any direct loans they make to the company.

Compliance requirements also vary:

  • LLC: Minimal compliance — typically just an annual report and state filing fees.
  • S Corp: Annual meetings, board resolutions, stock issuance, and IRS Form 1120-S filing are required.

For businesses seeking simplicity, the LLC structure is often more attractive. But for those prioritizing tax savings and predictable payroll planning, S corp status can be worth the extra effort.

Maintaining S Corp Status for Your LLC

Once your LLC is taxed as an S corporation, you must follow certain operational and compliance rules to preserve the election:

  • Ongoing Eligibility: Continue meeting ownership restrictions, including the 100-owner cap and U.S. residency rules.
  • Consistent Tax Reporting: File Form 1120-S annually and issue Schedule K-1s to members.
  • Reasonable Compensation: Pay owner-employees a fair salary before taking additional profits as distributions to avoid IRS scrutiny.
  • Corporate Records: Maintain meeting minutes, ownership records, and any required state filings.
  • Avoid Disqualifying Transactions: Certain ownership transfers or creating multiple classes of equity can terminate S corp status.

Failure to meet these requirements can result in the IRS revoking your S corporation election, forcing a reversion to C corporation taxation.

Best Practices to Maximize S Corp Benefits

Once your LLC has elected Subchapter S status, maximizing its advantages requires proactive management. Consider these best practices to preserve and optimize your S corp election:

  1. Set a Reasonable Salary: Owner-employees should receive a salary comparable to industry standards. Underpaying can trigger IRS audits, while overpaying eliminates the tax savings advantage.
  2. Plan for Distributions: Regularly scheduled profit distributions — beyond your salary — can significantly reduce self-employment tax obligations.
  3. Track Shareholder Basis: Maintain accurate records of each shareholder’s investment and loans to properly calculate tax deductions and avoid issues with loss limitations.
  4. Document Corporate Actions: Record major decisions in meeting minutes and keep your corporate records updated. This helps avoid “piercing the corporate veil” and potential liability exposure.
  5. Consult a Tax Professional: Tax laws governing S corporations evolve frequently. Annual consultations can ensure compliance and optimize tax strategies.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What’s the main difference between a Subchapter S corporation and an LLC?
    An LLC is a flexible business structure governed by state law, while an S corporation is a tax election under the Internal Revenue Code. LLCs can choose to be taxed as S corps for potential tax savings.
  2. Is an S corp always more tax-efficient than an LLC?
    Not always. S corps can reduce self-employment taxes, but they require more compliance and have ownership restrictions. For smaller or simpler businesses, a default LLC structure may be more cost-effective.
  3. Can a single-member LLC elect S corporation status?
    Yes. Single-member LLCs can file Form 2553 to be taxed as an S corp if they meet IRS eligibility criteria.
  4. What happens if my LLC loses S corp eligibility?
    If you violate S corp requirements (e.g., by adding a foreign shareholder or issuing multiple stock classes), the IRS may revoke your election, and your business will revert to C corporation or default LLC taxation.
  5. Should I hire a lawyer or CPA to file Form 2553?
    While not required, consulting a professional ensures your election is filed correctly and helps you develop a tax strategy that maximizes benefits.

If you need help with a subchapter S LLC, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.