Key Takeaways

  • An LLC partner buyout agreement outlines the process for handling ownership changes when a member leaves, retires, dies, divorces, or files for bankruptcy.
  • The agreement should specify triggering events, valuation methods, rights of first refusal, and payment terms.
  • Including a buyout provision in the operating agreement helps avoid costly disputes and ensures business continuity.
  • Valuation methods can include book value, fair market value, or liquidation value, often determined by independent appraisal.
  • Payment terms may be structured as lump sums or installment payments, easing financial strain on remaining members.
  • Rights of first refusal allow remaining members the option to purchase the departing member’s interest before outsiders can.
  • Tax implications must be considered, including proper filing of IRS forms like the K-1 and final capital account adjustments.

An LLC member buyout agreement is the process of a member or owner leaving a Limited Liability Company.

How to Release a Member From an LLC

LLCs and corporations are similar in a lot of ways, but it is much easier for a shareholder to leave a corporation than it is for a member to leave an LLC. LLCs are completely owned by the members of the company, so it can be very hard to accurately assess the worth of any member's shares should they wish to leave. Because LLCs have a pass-through entity structure, each member of an LLC reports the company's profits on their personal income tax returns, which makes for complicated tax issues when a member wants to be bought out. 

Follow these steps for releasing a member from an LLC.

  1. Take a look at the operating agreement for the LLC. This is a document that would have been created and agreed upon by the business's founding members. It should stipulate how the business is meant to handle the buyout of a member along with other information regarding potential issues within the LLC.
  2. Balance the capital account of the member who wishes to leave. This account should have been tracking all contributions and loans made to the company throughout the individual's membership. It should also have tracked any profit distributions and loans given to the member by the company. Any and all outstanding debts between the member and the LLC should be settled before the buyout takes place.
  3. The interest that the member still has in the LLC should be appraised by following the instructions in the operating agreement. If the agreement does not spell out how this should be done, an outside party can be brought it to complete the assessment in order to avoid disputes.
  4. Once the departing member's interest has been valued, you'll need to write a purchase agreement. This document will lay out the terms of the buyout and act as a legally-binding agreement. This document should line up with any specifications detailed in the LLC's operating agreement. It's always a good idea to protect your company by adding non-compete or confidentiality clauses to these contracts.
  5. Have the exiting member and an authorized member of the LLC read and sign the document. This authorized member might be any member of the company or someone who has been elected to represent the business in these types of situations.
  6. Once the member has undergone the buyout, all capital accounts will need to be adjusted in order to spread out the departing member's interest to the remaining members. This process should also be detailed in the operating agreement, but if it isn't the interest percentage should be equally divided among the accounts of all remaining members of the LLC.
  7. Finally, the K-1 report, created by the company, should be given to the departing member. This will detail any of the LLC's profits or losses that should be included on their personal income tax return for the year. This will be this member's final K-1 form and should be noted as such at the top of the sheet. 

What to Include in an LLC Partner Buyout Agreement

A well-drafted LLC partner buyout agreement should clearly outline the procedures and terms for buying out a member’s ownership interest. Common provisions include:

  • Triggering Events: Define the circumstances that initiate a buyout, such as voluntary withdrawal, retirement, death, disability, bankruptcy, divorce, or expulsion for cause.
  • Valuation of Membership Interest: Specify how the departing member’s ownership interest will be valued. Common approaches include:
    • Book value
    • Fair market value determined by independent appraiser
    • Agreed-upon formula or capitalization of earnings
    • Liquidation value
  • Payment Terms: Detail how the buyout will be funded, whether through a lump-sum payment or installment plan. Many agreements allow installment payments over several months or years to ease financial strain on the business.
  • Right of First Refusal (ROFR): Require the departing member to offer their interest first to the remaining members or the LLC before selling to an outsider.
  • Dispute Resolution: Include mechanisms such as mediation, arbitration, or court litigation if disagreements arise during the buyout process.
  • Confidentiality and Non-Compete Clauses: Protect the LLC’s sensitive information and prevent the departing member from directly competing with the business post-exit.

Changing LLC Ownership

Multi-member LLCs do carry extra risk with their structure because of the potential difficulties if one member decides to leave or dies. 

The following events can lead to a change in LLC membership or ownership:

  • Divorce
  • Bankruptcy
  • Illness
  • Death

No matter the reason for the change, the members must create and sign a written document that displays the terms and agreement of all LLC members, including the departing member. 

Also known as a buy-sell agreement or business continuity agreement, an LLC member buyout agreement outlines the handling of member departure and is agreed upon at the start of an LLC. This document should determine the handling of member interest and prices for those interests. Buy-sell agreements are actually written documents that detail exactly how a company should handle the leaving or adding of any members, and they have nothing to do with buying or selling businesses as many think they do. 

The following information should be outlined in a buyout agreement:

  • Rights of a departing member and other members in the case of a buyout
  • Persons allowed to buy the interest of the departing member, and whether outsiders are allowed this purchase
  • Interest prices
  • Any events that may cause a buyout to take place

Valuing an LLC Partner's Interest

Accurately valuing a departing LLC partner’s ownership interest is one of the most critical and challenging parts of a buyout agreement. Several valuation methods may be used:

  • Book Value: The value of the company’s assets minus liabilities as recorded on the balance sheet.
  • Fair Market Value: The price at which the membership interest would sell in an open market, typically determined by an independent third-party appraiser.
  • Capitalization of Earnings: A formula based on projected future earnings and risk factors.
  • Agreed-Upon Value: Pre-determined amount agreed upon annually by members.

Selecting the right valuation method should reflect the nature of the business, its growth stage, and member expectations. To avoid disputes, it is advisable to include clear instructions on selecting appraisers and handling potential valuation disagreements.

Funding the Buyout: Payment Options and Considerations

Funding a buyout requires careful planning to prevent financial strain on the LLC or remaining members. Common payment structures include:

  • Lump-Sum Payment: Immediate full payment to the departing member.
  • Installment Payments: Payments made over time, often with interest. The agreement should outline the frequency, duration, and interest rate.
  • Insurance Proceeds: Some LLCs use life insurance policies on members to fund buyouts in the event of death or disability.
  • Company Reserve Funds: Accumulated retained earnings set aside for potential buyouts.

The agreement should also specify the timeline for payment and any penalties for late payments.

Tax Implications of an LLC Partner Buyout

The tax consequences of a partner buyout can be complex, affecting both the departing member and the remaining LLC owners. Key considerations include:

  • Final K-1 Statement: The LLC must issue a final Schedule K-1 to the departing member, reflecting their share of profits or losses up to the date of exit.
  • Capital Account Adjustments: The departing member’s capital account should be properly reconciled and closed out.
  • Reporting the Transaction: The LLC and the departing member may need to report the transaction on their respective tax filings. Depending on the structure of the payment (lump sum or installments), certain IRS forms may be required.
  • Potential Gain or Loss: If the buyout amount differs from the member’s adjusted basis in the LLC, capital gains or losses may apply.

Due to these complexities, consulting a tax advisor or accountant is highly recommended during the buyout process.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is an LLC partner buyout agreement?
    An LLC partner buyout agreement is a legal document that outlines the process and terms for buying out a member's ownership interest in the event they leave the company, retire, become disabled, pass away, or face other triggering events.
  2. What should be included in an LLC partner buyout agreement?
    It should include triggering events, valuation methods, payment terms, rights of first refusal, dispute resolution procedures, and any confidentiality or non-compete clauses.
  3. How is the value of a member's interest determined in a buyout?
    Common valuation methods include book value, fair market value by an independent appraiser, capitalization of earnings, or a pre-agreed formula set in the agreement.
  4. Can an LLC require the departing member to sell only to other members?
    Yes, many LLC partner buyout agreements include a right of first refusal clause that gives remaining members or the LLC itself the first opportunity to purchase the departing member's interest.
  5. Are there tax implications for LLC partner buyouts?
    Yes, buyouts can trigger tax consequences for both the departing member and the LLC, including capital gains, final K-1 statements, and reporting requirements. Consult a tax professional to ensure compliance.

If you need help with an LLC member buyout agreement, you can post your job on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.