Can an Independent Contractor Be an LLC? Legal and Tax Insights

Key Takeaways

• Independent contractors are not employees and have control over their work, but they must manage their own taxes and liabilities.
• An independent contractor can operate under different business structures, including sole proprietorships and LLCs.
• Forming an LLC as an independent contractor provides limited liability protection, tax advantages, and increased credibility.
• LLCs offer flexibility in taxation, allowing independent contractors to be taxed as a sole proprietor, S corporation, or C corporation.
• There are key differences between an LLC, a sole proprietorship, and an independent contractor designation in terms of legal structure and financial responsibilities.
• Some industries and clients prefer to work with LLCs over sole proprietors due to liability and tax benefits.
• Independent contractors forming an LLC must comply with state-specific regulations, licensing, and registration requirements.

An LLC independent contractor, also known as a 1099 employee, is someone who completes work for a limited liability company but does not meet the definition of an employee. Independent contractors may want to consider forming their own LLCs to give themselves some added protection.

Independent Contractors for an LLC

Independent contractors can decide where and when they want to work and can negotiate their own payment for the work they perform. Unlike an employee, an independent contractor treats their employer more as a client than as an employer.

An independent contractor is, in essence, his own small business, and his work should be treated the same as any other entrepreneur. Therefore, independent contractors should consider forming their company as a separate business entity. Whether or not a 1099 contractor should form his company as an LLC will depend largely on his personal situation, but there are many benefits that come with forming a limited liability company.

Why Independent Contractors Consider an LLC

Independent contractors may consider forming an LLC for several reasons:

1. Limited Liability Protection – Without an LLC, independent contractors are personally liable for business debts and legal claims. An LLC creates a legal separation between personal and business assets.
2. Tax Benefits and Flexibility – LLCs can be taxed as sole proprietorships, S corporations, or C corporations, offering flexibility in tax planning.
3. Credibility and Professionalism – Clients often prefer to work with LLCs because they project a more established business presence.
4. Access to Business Benefits – LLCs may qualify for small business loans, business insurance, and tax deductions that are not available to sole proprietors.
5. Simplified Business Operations – Compared to corporations, LLCs require less paperwork and regulatory compliance.

Independent Contractors

By definition, any individual who works for a company but not under the capacity and definition of an employee will be considered an independent contractor. Often a contractor will be a technical or creative professional bringing in such skills as design, web expertise, or IT service. These professionals will receive a 1099-MISC at the end of the year instead of a W2 to file the income they earned with your company through the IRS.

An independent contractor can file under business entity types such as:

• Corporations
• LLCs
• Sole proprietor
• Partnerships

Most contractors will file as a sole proprietor, though. As an independent contractor is not, in fact, a direct employee of the company, his pay will not have any payroll taxes withheld from it. Therefore, independent contractors must file and pay these taxes at the end of the year or through estimated quarterly tax payments.

The primary difference that separates an employee from a contractor is the fact that the company is not obligated to withhold and make tax payments based on the money the contractor earned. The contractor is then responsible for all of his own tax payments and well as tax reporting.

Tax Implications for Independent Contractors and LLCs

Independent contractors who operate as sole proprietors must report their earnings using Schedule C on their tax returns. However, LLCs offer additional tax options, including:

• Pass-Through Taxation: LLC income passes directly to the owner’s tax return, avoiding double taxation.
• S Corporation Election: An LLC owner can choose to be taxed as an S corporation, reducing self-employment taxes by splitting income into salary and distributions.
• C Corporation Election: Some independent contractors choose C corporation taxation to benefit from the 21% corporate tax rate, though this may result in double taxation.
• Deductions and Write-Offs: LLCs can deduct business expenses, including health insurance, retirement contributions, and home office expenses.

Understanding these tax structures is crucial for optimizing tax savings as an independent contractor operating an LLC. Consulting a tax professional can help determine the best option.

Sole Proprietors

An independent contractor is considered a sole proprietor if he is not registered as any type of business entity with the IRS, such as an LLC or partnership. If you do not choose a business entity, you will become a sole proprietorship by default. 

Your business will be classified under sole proprietorship if your business expenses and income are listed separately, and you have not registered your business with the state. While this is the initial classification, you will have the further option to decide which legal structure you will want to provide your services.

Being a sole proprietor will mean that an independent contractor will provide all of his services under his own name, be required to keep track of his business expenses and income, and file a Schedule C with his personal tax return. When making contracts with companies that will become clients, the company does business directly with you as a contractor and not with your business.

Risks of Operating as a Sole Proprietor

While sole proprietorships are the default structure for independent contractors, they come with inherent risks, including:

• Unlimited Personal Liability: If a sole proprietor is sued or incurs business debts, their personal assets (home, car, savings) are at risk.
• Limited Tax Flexibility: Sole proprietors must pay self-employment taxes on all income, whereas LLCs can reduce this burden by electing S corporation status.
• Lower Business Credibility: Some clients prefer working with LLCs over sole proprietors due to liability protections and business formalities.
• Challenges in Securing Business Loans: Financial institutions and investors may be less willing to lend to a sole proprietor compared to an LLC.

Given these risks, independent contractors handling high-value contracts or working in industries with liability concerns may benefit from forming an LLC.

Limited Liability Companies (LLC)

Even if you have been operating as an independent contractor, you have the option of forming a company through which you can provide your services. One commonly chosen type of business structure is a limited liability corporation or LLC. An LLC will provide the owner with more protection than a sole proprietorship.

By forming an LLC, you will do business under the company name instead of the contractor name. Additionally, by forming an LLC, you will provide some protection of your personal assets and liability against business debts.

Steps to Form an LLC as an Independent Contractor

Forming an LLC involves several steps that vary by state but generally include:

1. Choose a Business Name: Ensure your LLC name complies with state rules and is distinguishable from existing entities.
2. File Articles of Organization: Submit the required registration documents to the Secretary of State or relevant agency.
3. Designate a Registered Agent: Select an individual or service to receive legal documents on behalf of your LLC.
4. Obtain an EIN (Employer Identification Number): Required for tax purposes and opening a business bank account.
5. Create an Operating Agreement: Although not always required, this document outlines ownership and operational procedures.
6. Register for State and Local Taxes: Depending on your location, you may need to register for sales tax, payroll tax, or other business taxes.
7. Open a Business Bank Account: Keeping personal and business finances separate is crucial for liability protection.

Following these steps ensures compliance and helps independent contractors establish a legally recognized business entity.

Differences: LLC, Sole Proprietorship, and Independent Contractor

The primary difference between independent contractors, LLCs, and sole proprietorships is that the term "independent contractor" is a tax designation, while "sole proprietorship" and "LLC" also refer to the way in which the business is run. Another difference is that a sole proprietorship opens up the owner's personal assets to a business creditor, while an LLC provides some protection.

A person can act as both an independent contractor and sole proprietor and will be required to report business income and expenses on their personal tax return and file a Schedule C.

Choosing Between an LLC and Sole Proprietorship

When deciding between operating as a sole proprietor or forming an LLC, independent contractors should consider:

For independent contractors looking to scale their business, reduce liability, and optimize taxes, an LLC is often the better choice.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can an independent contractor be an LLC?
   Yes, an independent contractor can form an LLC to gain liability protection, tax advantages, and greater business credibility.
2. Do independent contractors pay less in taxes with an LLC?
   It depends on the tax election chosen. An LLC taxed as an S corporation can help reduce self-employment taxes compared to a sole proprietorship.
3. What are the biggest risks of not forming an LLC as an independent contractor?
   Without an LLC, an independent contractor is personally liable for business debts and lawsuits, and they have fewer tax-saving options.
4. How does an independent contractor set up an LLC?
   The process involves registering the LLC with the state, obtaining an EIN, creating an operating agreement, and complying with tax and licensing requirements.
5. Is an LLC required for independent contractors?
   No, but forming an LLC can provide significant legal and financial benefits compared to operating as a sole proprietor.

If you need help understanding the relationship between LLCs and independent contractors, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.