Key Takeaways

  • A lien agreement gives a lender legal rights to a borrower's asset until a debt is paid.
  • Liens can be voluntary (consensual) or involuntary (statutory).
  • Different types of liens include mechanic’s liens, tax liens, and blanket liens.
  • Proper execution and release of lien forms are crucial to protect legal rights.
  • State laws govern lien filing procedures and deadlines; compliance is essential for enforcement.
  • A lien can hinder property transfers and can lead to foreclosure or repossession if unpaid.

Lien Agreements: How They Work

The most commonly used type of lien agreement occurs when buying an automobile, so we will use that example to properly define and explain how the lien works.

When you decide to buy a car you visit a dealership. When purchasing the car, you also work with a bank that provides you the necessary loan, while a lien agreement is placed by the bank on the vehicle. They will also hold onto the automobile's title. The lien is recorded with the help of a UCC-1 form and then the payments start. From this moment, the situation can go on one of three separate ways:

  • You make all your payments on time until the vehicle is paid in full, and at that moment the bank gives you the car's title
  • You stop making payments at a specific time. In this situation the bank will use the lien agreement to take the automobile from you, while continuing to own the title, therefore having full possession.
  • You still have outstanding payments on the car, but you decide to try and sell it. You can't sell a vehicle without its title, so with the bank holding the title it is impossible to sell until you've paid off all debt to the bank.

Understanding Lien Priorities and Their Impact

Lien priority determines the order in which creditors are paid if a debtor defaults or if the asset is liquidated. Generally, liens are prioritized by the date they were recorded. First-position liens, like mortgages, are paid before subordinate liens such as second mortgages or judgment liens.

A lien agreement may also include subordination clauses, allowing a new lien to take precedence over an older one. This affects both the lender’s risk and the borrower's refinancing options.

Failing to properly record a lien or file within the required time frame may result in loss of lien rights. It's crucial to follow state-specific procedures to ensure enforceability.

Types of Liens

  • Consensual liens – A lien that you voluntarily agree to when buying a product or a service.
  • Statutory liens – Also known as non-consensual liens, they are issued by a court and their purpose is to enforce overdue payment. There are two types of consensual liens:
    • Tax liens – Liens placed by local authorities to recover unpaid taxes owed by people or companies
    • Contractor's or mechanic's liens – When performing a service, if the customer fails to fully reward the contractor, the court issues a lien on the property being worked on. As in all liens agreements, if the customer who fails to pay tries to sell the asset, they're legally unable to do so before paying the contractor in full.

Contractual vs. Statutory Liens

There are two primary categories of liens based on how they arise:

  • Contractual (Consensual) Liens: Created through an agreement between the parties, such as mortgage liens or car loans.
  • Statutory (Non-Consensual) Liens: Arise by law and do not require the debtor’s agreement. Examples include tax liens, mechanic’s liens, and judgment liens.

Each type has specific legal requirements for filing and enforcement, especially in construction and real estate transactions.

Ending a Lien

When the property that the lien agreement is made for is fully paid for, a written document called the release of lien is signed by both parties, fully releasing the property from any outstanding lien issued by the contractor.

How to File and Enforce a Lien

The process of filing and enforcing a lien varies by jurisdiction but generally involves the following steps:

  1. Preliminary Notice: Some states require a notice to the property owner before filing a lien (especially in construction).
  2. File the Lien: Submit a lien form with the county recorder or relevant agency within statutory deadlines.
  3. Serve Notice: Notify the property owner of the filed lien.
  4. Enforce the Lien: If unpaid, the lienholder may initiate foreclosure proceedings or sue to collect the debt within a limited period.

Failure to comply with procedural requirements—such as filing deadlines or proper documentation—can render the lien invalid.

Blanket Lien

The type of lien that allows the lender not only to seize one specific property in the event of non-payment, but all properties under the borrower's name, is called a blanket lien. It is very advantageous for the person or institution issuing the loan, but it severely limits the options of whoever is benefiting from the loan.

In the interest of all parties, the lien agreements must be as specific as possible, as it's in no one's interest for any disputes to occur after its signing. As the business world revolves around debt and credit, lien agreements are a crucial part of the whole business process.

Risks and Limitations of Lien Agreements

While lien agreements offer creditor protection, they also carry risks:

  • For Lenders: If improperly filed or unenforceable, the lien may be invalid. In bankruptcy, some liens can be stripped.
  • For Borrowers: Liens can severely impact credit, restrict asset sales, or lead to foreclosure.
  • Legal Disputes: Ambiguous lien terms or disputes over lien priority can result in costly litigation.

To mitigate these risks, lien forms must be accurate and comply with applicable law. Working with an experienced attorney ensures legal and procedural compliance.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a lien agreement used for?
    A lien agreement secures a lender’s interest in a borrower's asset, ensuring the debt is repaid. It allows legal claim over the asset if the borrower defaults.
  2. Can you sell a property with a lien on it?
    Generally, no. A lien must be satisfied (paid off) before the property can be transferred to a new owner.
  3. What happens if a lien isn’t paid?
    The lienholder can initiate legal action, such as foreclosure or repossession, depending on the type of lien and asset involved.
  4. How do I remove a lien from my property?
    Once the debt is paid, the lienholder must file a release of lien. This clears the title and removes the encumbrance.
  5. Are lien laws the same in every state?
    No. Each state has its own deadlines, procedures, and requirements for filing, serving, and enforcing liens. It’s important to consult local regulations or legal counsel.

If you need help with lien agreement, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.