Key Takeaways:

  • A contractor can sometimes sue without a written contract, depending on state laws and the type of agreement.
  • Contractors may still have lien rights if they can prove an oral or implied contract.
  • The Economic Loss Rule (ELR) can prevent lawsuits in some states when damages are purely financial.
  • Quantum meruit claims allow contractors to recover payment for work performed, even without a formal agreement.
  • Small claims court may be an option for contractors pursuing unpaid work under an oral contract.
  • State-specific statutes of limitations apply to oral contracts, usually shorter than those for written contracts.
  • The best practice for both contractors and clients is to always have a clear written agreement.

Can a contractor sue without a contract? The answer varies depending on the situation. In some cases, contractors may sue without a formal contract, while in others, a lawsuit may not be possible.

Filing a Lien without a Written Contract

It's common for contractors to wonder if they can file a lien without a written contract in place. In the construction industry, verbal contracts are much more common than they are in other fields. Despite this fact, it can be hard to determine if verbal contracts provide the right to file a lien.

There is great variance between the states when it comes to lien laws, so you'll need to research the rules in your state to decide if you can file a lien without a written contract. In some states, a claimant cannot file a lien without a signed contract. In other states, lien rights are granted more flexibly.

Generally, there are four groups that states can fall into related to lien rights:

  • Locations where a written contract must be in place.
  • Locations where lien rights can be granted without a written contract.
  • Locations that base contracts on the amount of work completed.
  • Locations with no specific rules for acceptable contracts.

Understanding Lien Rights for Contractors Without a Contract

Many contractors rely on lien rights to recover unpaid fees, but these rights can vary depending on whether a written contract exists. While some states require a formal agreement, others allow lien claims based on verbal contracts or partially completed work. Contractors should consider the following factors:

  • Proof of Work: Receipts, emails, text messages, or witness testimonies can help establish the existence of an agreement.
  • State-Specific Lien Laws: Some states allow liens based on an oral agreement, while others strictly require written contracts.
  • Timing of the Lien Filing: Many states enforce strict deadlines for filing liens, and missing the deadline can forfeit the contractor's rights.

Contractors should check state laws before assuming they can file a lien without a contract.

Suing without a Contract in Maryland

Some states have decided there are circumstances where a contractor should be able to file a negligence lawsuit against a design professional even without a contract in place. Other states, such as Maryland, use something known as the Economic Loss Rule (ELR) to prevent these lawsuits. The ELR applies to lawsuits where one person is suing another only for a financial loss.

In the construction industry, the ELR is of the utmost importance. This rule is so important because it's possible for contractors to experience a financial loss because of a flaw in the design documents, and to get back this money, the contractor may want to sue the designer.

In a lawsuit in this state, the court upheld the use of the ELR and did not accept numerous claims that a contractor had made against a designer.

The Role of Quantum Meruit in Contractor Claims

When a contractor completes work without a signed contract, they may still have legal recourse through a legal principle called quantum meruit, which means "as much as he deserves." This doctrine allows a contractor to claim compensation for work performed, even if no formal agreement was in place.

Key considerations for quantum meruit claims:

  • The contractor must prove that work was performed and that the client benefited.
  • Courts will determine a fair payment based on industry rates or past agreements.
  • This claim is most effective when there is evidence of mutual understanding, such as invoices or email exchanges.

Quantum meruit is commonly used when the parties expected a contract but never finalized one.

Different Forms of Construction Contracts

Like many types of contracts, construction contracts can either be verbal or written. In the modern world, written contracts can also be in electronic form. Many construction contracts are in the form of oral agreements. For instance, a contractor could request that a subcontractor perform a task in exchange for money. If the subcontractor verbally agrees to the arrangement, a verbal contract is now in place.

While they can be harder to enforce than written contracts, oral contracts are legal agreements. When a verbal contract winds up in court, proving the agreement can be difficult if there were no witnesses to the contract other than the contracted parties. Whenever it's possible, you should use a written contract. If there is no written contract in place, however, a contractor will retain lien rights if they can demonstrate that a verbal contract exists and that other requirements have been met.

An idea that you should understand is that there can be an "implied in law" contract. Essentially, this concept allows courts to determine that an agreement was in place, even if the parties never reached a formal contract. This allows the court to protect one party from being harmed by the actions of the other. This ruling, however, can only be used to stop one party from being enriched unjustly. In Florida, when a contract is implied in law, the contractor does not have lien rights.

Implied Contracts and Their Enforceability

In certain cases, a court may recognize an implied contract even if no written or verbal agreement exists. This can happen in two ways:

  • Implied-in-Fact Contract: Formed through actions, such as a contractor performing work with the client's knowledge.
  • Implied-in-Law Contract: Also called a quasi-contract, this applies when a court determines that one party unfairly benefited from another’s work and should compensate them.

For example, if a contractor begins a job with the client’s implicit approval, a court may rule that an implied contract exists, requiring the client to pay for the services rendered.

Tips for Suing without a Contract

When doing any kind of business, it's important to have a written contract in place. If there is a problem later on, and there is no contract, resolving the dispute can be nearly impossible, as the case will boil down to one party's word against the other. If you don't have a contract in place, you could still file a breach of contract lawsuit against the contractor, and they will also have the ability to file a suit against you.

Under the statute of frauds, certain contracts must be in writing to be enforceable. This rule, however, does not apply to contracts related to services, such as installing an appliance. Basically, this means you and your contractor may have agreed to an oral contract without realizing this fact, meaning you could sue for a breach.

State Laws and the Statute of Limitations for Oral Contracts

One of the biggest challenges in suing without a contract is the statute of limitations. Most states enforce shorter filing deadlines for oral contracts than for written ones. For example:

  • California: 2 years for oral contracts, 4 years for written contracts.
  • New York: 6 years for both written and oral contracts.
  • Texas: 4 years for written contracts, 2 years for oral contracts.

Additionally, certain states place restrictions on verbal agreements over a specific dollar amount. Contractors should check local laws before pursuing legal action.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can a contractor sue for non-payment if there was only a verbal agreement?
    Yes, but proving the agreement exists can be difficult. Contractors can use receipts, messages, or witness testimonies to support their claim.
  2. What is the easiest way for a contractor to recover unpaid fees without a contract?
    Filing a lien (if permitted by state law) or pursuing a quantum meruit claim are common options.
  3. What are the risks of working without a written contract?
    Contractors may struggle to enforce payment, encounter disputes over project scope, or be limited by state laws on oral agreements.
  4. How long does a contractor have to sue for unpaid work without a contract?
    It depends on state laws, but oral contracts typically have shorter statutes of limitations than written ones.
  5. Can a contractor sue if the client refuses to pay but benefited from the work?
    Yes, courts may enforce payment under quantum meruit or an implied contract theory.

If you need help deciding can a contractor sue without a contract, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.