Key Takeaways

  • Intellectual property licensing involves legal agreements allowing one party to use another's IP in exchange for compensation.
  • IP licenses can be exclusive, non-exclusive, territorial, or field-specific.
  • Key clauses include grant scope, duration, royalty terms, quality control, and termination rights.
  • Due diligence and valuation of IP are essential before licensing.
  • Common pitfalls include unclear rights, lack of enforcement mechanisms, and inadequate due diligence.

An IP licensing agreement is a partnership between an intellectual property rights owner and another party who is authorized to use those rights in exchange for an agreed upon payment.

What Is a License?

A license is an agreement to not sue the other party. For example, in the Hollywood movie "007," British spy James Bond was given a "license to kill." In effect, the British government promised not to prosecute him for any murders he may commit in the process of saving the world.

A license fundamentally requires the licensor to provide assurance that they will not sue the licensee. In return for the assurance, the licensor usually receives a royalty payment, and the licensee is allowed some sort of intellectual property (IP).

What Is an IP Licensing Agreement?

Intellectual property licensing agreements materialize from the need of one party (the licensee) to use the IP of another party (the licensor). In exchange for the IP, the licensee will pay the licensor a fee or a royalty. The parties involved in the agreement will usually be able to negotiate the conditions and terms of use.

The licensor is the owner/holder of the licensed IP. One license may cover:

  • Design and patent rights
  • Trademark(s)
  • Know-how

The licensor may be allowed to monitor the actions of the licensee while they use their IP. Monitoring a client's actions may help to continually build the overall knowledge of the IP.

Purchasing an IP license has many benefits, including:

  • Increasing the capability of getting services or products faster to market
  • Allowing shared risk
  • Increasing revenue
  • Increasing market penetration
  • Reducing costs and time
  • Accessing specialized knowledge or expertise
  • Providing a competitive advantage
  • Opportunities to collaborate
  • Minimizing capital investment

A vast array of IP licenses are available. The following are the three main groups:

  1. Technology
  2. Trademark and franchising
  3. Copyright

Generally, in these types of agreements, more than one type of IP is transferred between parties. Therefore, one single contract may contain the transfer of many different rights of use. Licensing agreements may also be used during mergers and acquisitions, or during the negotiation of a joint venture.

What Can Be Subject to an IP Licensing Agreement?

Intellectual property that may qualify to be licensed includes:

  • Trademarks
  • Patents
  • Product designs
  • Copyright
  • Confidential knowledge protecting the IP

The ABCs of Licensing Intellectual Property: Introduction

At a bare minimum, the various types of IP rights include:

  • Trade secrets
  • Patents
  • Know-how
  • Registered designs
  • Proprietary data
  • Trademarks
  • Copyrights

Intellectual property rights usually originate with the owner or creator of the technology. Most of the time, the owner will keep the rights of the IP as a competitive advantage against their competitors. Occasionally, the owner or creator will want to sell a part or all of the IP outright, but they may have put themselves in a peculiar situation.

For example, if the owner or creator is part of a non-practicing entity (NPE), a term that is made up of:

  • Any inventor who's not able to market their IP
  • Research institutions or universities that plan on transferring their knowledge
  • Businesses who accidentally find themselves with too much IP
  • Middle-men who accumulate IP with the intention of selling it at a later date

There are occasions when it makes sense to share IP, such as during a litigation, a settlement, or to resolve a stalemate during a negotiation process.

Licensing provides the licensor with a number of advantages including:

  • Retaining title or ownership over the IP
  • Reversing the transfer of IP if the licensee doesn't live up to their end of the bargain
  • Bringing in a steady stream of income
  • Creating a partnership where both parties share in the upside
  • Controlling how the IP can be used
  • Increasing flexibility while also reducing risk that IP will be undervalued

The ABCs of Licensing Intellectual Property: What Are the Components of a License?

The components of a license include:

  • Specification regarding all rights granted
  • Terms of the license
  • Financial consideration exchanged
  • Reporting and records
  • Warranties and representations
  • Infringement process
  • Liability disclosure

The ABCs of Licensing Intellectual Property: Grant Clause

The grant clause explicitly states which patent rights will be granted to the licensor. The rights granted to the licensee can be exclusive or non-exclusive, or limited by a geographic area. The licensor needs to make sure not to grant "all right, title and interest in and to the intellectual property" to the licensee. Such a clause would constitute an "assignment" of the intellectual property, possibly making the licensee the new owner of the IP.

Risks and Pitfalls in IP Licensing

While IP licensing presents opportunities, it also comes with risks. Common pitfalls include:

  • Ambiguous Language: Vague terms in the license can lead to disputes over scope or duration.
  • Failure to Register the License: For patents or trademarks, failing to register can impact enforceability.
  • Inadequate Enforcement Rights: If enforcement responsibilities are not clearly assigned, infringers may go unchallenged.
  • Lack of Monitoring Mechanisms: Without oversight, licensees may misuse or underreport use of IP.
  • Underestimating Foreign Jurisdictions: Cross-border licenses require an understanding of local IP laws and enforcement limitations.

IP Valuation and Due Diligence

Before entering an intellectual property licensing deal, both parties should conduct thorough due diligence and IP valuation. Key steps include:

  • Ownership Verification: Ensure the licensor legally owns the IP and that it is not subject to liens or disputes.
  • Scope of Protection: Assess the breadth and validity of the IP (e.g., patent claims, trademark classes, copyright duration).
  • Commercial Viability: Evaluate the IP’s market potential and how it fits into the licensee’s strategy.
  • Freedom to Operate (FTO): Analyze if using the licensed IP could infringe on third-party rights.
  • IP Valuation Methods: Common approaches include the income method (projected cash flows), market comparables, or cost-to-create analysis.

Key Clauses in an IP Licensing Agreement

A robust intellectual property licensing agreement should include the following clauses:

  • Scope of License: Defines whether the license is exclusive, non-exclusive, or sole.
  • Term and Termination: Specifies the duration and conditions under which the license can be terminated.
  • Payment Terms: Outlines royalties, lump-sum payments, milestones, and audit rights.
  • Quality Control: Especially critical in trademark licensing, this ensures brand integrity.
  • Confidentiality: Protects sensitive technical or commercial information exchanged under the agreement.
  • Infringement and Enforcement: States which party can pursue legal action and who bears the cost.
  • Improvement Rights: Clarifies ownership of any enhancements made to the IP during the license term.
  • Dispute Resolution: Designates the method (e.g., arbitration or court) and venue for resolving conflicts.

Types of Intellectual Property Licenses

There are several categories of intellectual property licenses, each serving different business strategies:

  • Exclusive License: Grants the licensee sole rights to use the IP, even excluding the licensor. This is common when a licensee invests heavily in product development.
  • Non-Exclusive License: Allows multiple licensees to use the IP. It’s often used to maximize revenue.
  • Sole License: A hybrid model in which the licensor and licensee both can use the IP, but no third party can.
  • Field-of-Use License: Limits IP usage to specific industries or applications (e.g., medical vs. consumer use).
  • Territorial License: Restricts IP usage to a defined geographic area.
  • Cross-License: Involves mutual licensing between two parties, often used in high-tech sectors to reduce litigation risks.
  • Sub-license: Allows the licensee to grant further rights to third parties, typically subject to approval by the licensor.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the difference between exclusive and non-exclusive IP licenses? An exclusive license gives rights to only one licensee, while a non-exclusive license allows multiple licensees to use the same IP.

2. Why is due diligence important before licensing IP? Due diligence ensures the IP is valid, owned by the licensor, and commercially viable, reducing legal and financial risks.

3. How are royalties typically calculated in IP licenses? Royalties may be fixed fees, percentage of sales, milestone payments, or a combination, depending on the industry and IP type.

4. Can a license be terminated early? Yes, termination clauses allow licenses to end due to breach, mutual consent, or specified conditions.

5. Do I need to register an IP license? While not always required, registering can provide public notice and strengthen enforceability, especially for patents and trademarks.

If you need help with IP licensing, you can post your job on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.