Key Takeaways

  • An investor rights agreement (IRA) grants specific rights and protections to investors, especially minority investors, in a company.
  • Common provisions in IRAs include registration rights, information rights, participation and pre-emptive rights, board and observer rights, inspection rights, and indemnification.
  • IRAs are distinct from shareholder agreements, with IRAs typically focusing on protecting investors' interests and outlining company obligations.
  • These agreements are customizable and can address unique concerns of both the company and investors, including exit strategies and future fundraising.
  • Having a well-drafted IRA can prevent disputes and foster transparency between founders and investors.

An investor rights agreement (IRA) is a typical document negotiated between a venture capitalist (VC) and other concerns providing capital financing to a startup company. It provides the rights and privileges afforded these new stockholders in the company. They typically cover subjects such as stock registration rights, “rights of first refusal” or “pre-emptive rights” when additional shares are offered to the public, and other rights that sweeten the deal for the VC.

Investors obtaining only a minority interest in a closely held corporation desire this form of agreement to protect their interest. Corporations grant these rights because they receive a capital investment that might otherwise not materialize and want the deal as attractive as possible to the investors.

Features of an Investor Rights Agreement

The most common rights usually granted to investors by a company are:

  • Liquidity of stock: The VC requires that the stock be registered with the SEC as part of an initial public offering, which means the stock can be traded on the stock market (usually after what is called a lock-up period).
  • Right to receive corporate reports: These reports include financial and management reports, and other periodic updates from the company.
  • Participation rights: Typical examples of these rights include rights of first refusal and pre-emptive rights that protect the investor’s percentage of ownership of the company.

Other rights can be negotiated, and usually reflect the amount of control the startup is willing to grant in return for the investment. These include:

  • Board membership: Startups can agree to allow the VC to be represented on the board of directors or to serve on board committees with the authority to approve extra-budgetary financial expenditures.
  • Dividend rights and calculations: VCs are allotted preferred stock as part of their investment, and a feature of these stocks is the priority the holder receives in terms of dividend payments and anti-dilution protection.
  • Indemnification and expenses: An indemnification clause provides VCs additional protection from liability due to board decisions, and expenses are often paid because VCs may have to travel to attend meetings in the location of the startup.
  • Observer rights:  The startup provides the VC with notice of and the opportunity to attend all board and committee meetings.
  • Inspection rights: The investor is given the authority to inspect the startup’s corporate record books, and discuss finances and accounts with the officers.
  • Provisions to address unique concerns: In the event unexpected expenditures or board action is required, the VC is accorded a wide range of rights to influence or offer consent in these situations.

Common Types of Investor Rights Included in an IRA

Investor rights agreements often cover a range of rights that help protect investors' interests and maintain a fair relationship between the company and its investors. These typically include:

  • Information Rights: The right to receive financial statements, budgets, cap tables, and management updates on a regular basis.
  • Voting Rights: Investors may be granted specific voting rights or the right to vote on certain major decisions, such as mergers, sales, or additional fundraising.
  • Rights of First Refusal and Co-Sale Rights: These provisions allow investors the first opportunity to purchase new shares before others or to participate in sales by founders or other shareholders to prevent unwanted dilution or control changes.
  • Pre-emptive Rights: Investors may have the ability to maintain their ownership percentage by participating in future stock issuances.
  • Observer Rights: Investors can designate an individual to attend board meetings and receive board materials, even if they do not have formal voting power on the board.
  • Indemnification Rights: The company may agree to reimburse or protect investors against certain legal liabilities related to their involvement with the company.
  • Exit Rights: Terms addressing how and when investors can exit their investment, including tag-along and drag-along rights.
  • Special Approval Rights: For significant decisions, such as issuing new securities, amending governing documents, or selling substantial assets, some IRAs require investor approval.

These rights are not one-size-fits-all; their scope and strength are typically the subject of negotiation and can be customized based on the stage of the company, investor leverage, and unique concerns of both parties.

Differences Between Investor Rights Agreements and Shareholder Agreements

While often confused, investor rights agreements and shareholder agreements serve different purposes:

  • Investor Rights Agreements (IRA): Primarily designed to protect investors, especially venture capitalists or minority investors, by outlining specific rights, reporting obligations, and protections regarding their investment.
  • Shareholder Agreements: Broader in scope, these regulate the relationship among all shareholders, covering company governance, share transfers, and dispute resolution. Shareholder agreements may address matters like voting arrangements, management roles, and how shares can be bought or sold.
  • Key Difference: An IRA focuses on obligations owed to outside investors, while a shareholder agreement governs the conduct and rights of all shareholders, often including founders and employees.

A company may have both agreements in place, with each serving distinct but complementary functions.

Registration Right

The registration right provision is often one of the most important components in an investor rights agreement to investors. It gives the investor the authority to require the startup to list the shares publicly on the stock market. This allows the investor to capitalize on the investment by selling the shares to other parties.

It is an issue that a privately held company should not approach lightly if it wants to retain complete ownership of the company. Granting a registration right may be necessary to raise capital, but a registration right forces the company to become a publicly traded corporation.

In most cases, it is the majority block of shareholders that make the determination of if and when the company will go public, and the minority block has no say in the matter. However, even a minority shareholder can force this action if they have been granted registration rights.

There are reasons the startup should guard against granting these rights.

  • The IPO filing process can be expensive and drain funds that would be better allocated to operations and research and development.
  • Employees must devote time to collecting and preparing documents that are required by the SEC for IPOs rather than running the business.
  • Market conditions may not be optimal and the startup may not get an adequate price for each share.

Even if an investor demands that a registration be included in the investor rights agreement, there are steps a startup can take to limit the impact they may have on the company. It is possible to prevent a registration right from being exercised before a negotiated future date when the company may be in better financial shape. The company can insist that the registration right be piggybacked onto existing plans for a future IPO at the company’s convenience.

While an investor rights letter is a typical component of the early capitalization of a young company, care should be taken that the startup does not relinquish important facets of control.

Best Practices for Drafting an Investor Rights Agreement

When drafting an investor rights agreement, consider these best practices to ensure the document is robust and meets the needs of both the company and its investors:

  1. Be Specific and Clear: Clearly define each right and obligation to minimize ambiguity and reduce future disputes.
  2. Update as Needed: Revisit and update the agreement as the company grows or as new investment rounds are completed.
  3. Balance Interests: Structure the agreement to protect investors without overly restricting the company's ability to operate or raise additional funds.
  4. Consult Legal Counsel: Both companies and investors should work with experienced attorneys to ensure the IRA complies with applicable laws and reflects their intentions.
  5. Align with Company Bylaws and Other Agreements: Ensure consistency with existing bylaws, shareholder agreements, and articles of incorporation.

By focusing on these elements, companies and investors can foster a transparent and mutually beneficial relationship that supports the company's growth and protects the investment.

When and Why Are Investor Rights Agreements Used?

Investor rights agreements are commonly used in the following situations:

  • Venture Capital Financings: IRAs are a standard part of startup and growth-stage financings, especially when professional investors are involved.
  • Angel Investments: Early-stage angel investors may request an IRA to formalize their rights.
  • Minority Protections: When investors take a minority stake and seek to safeguard their investment against majority decisions.
  • Follow-on Rounds: New or existing investors may seek updated rights in subsequent fundraising rounds.

Companies agree to IRAs to secure needed capital and to make their investment opportunity attractive and competitive, while investors use IRAs to ensure transparency, maintain a voice in company operations, and protect against dilution and unfavorable company actions.

Potential Pitfalls and Considerations

While investor rights agreements provide significant benefits, there are potential pitfalls to consider:

  • Overly Restrictive Provisions: Too many investor protections can hinder a company's flexibility and future fundraising ability.
  • Conflict with Other Agreements: Conflicting terms between an IRA and other agreements (like bylaws or shareholder agreements) can create confusion.
  • Unclear Terms: Vague or poorly drafted terms can lead to disputes.
  • Compliance and Regulatory Issues: Some rights, like registration rights, can trigger complex securities law obligations.
  • Administrative Burdens: Information and inspection rights can place ongoing reporting and compliance requirements on the company.

To avoid these pitfalls, both sides should thoroughly review and negotiate the IRA, focusing on clarity and alignment with their goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the purpose of an investor rights agreement?

An investor rights agreement outlines the rights and protections for investors, ensuring transparency, board access, and the ability to protect their investment.

2. How does an IRA differ from a shareholder agreement?

An IRA focuses on investor-specific rights, while a shareholder agreement governs the broader relationship among all company shareholders.

3. What are registration rights in an investor rights agreement?

Registration rights allow investors to require the company to register their shares for sale to the public, often in connection with an IPO.

4. Who typically negotiates an investor rights agreement?

Professional investors, such as venture capitalists or angel investors, commonly negotiate IRAs when investing in startups or growth companies.

5. Can an investor rights agreement be customized?

Yes, IRAs are highly customizable and should be tailored to the unique needs and concerns of both the company and its investors.

To learn more investment rights agreements, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.