Key Takeaways

  • The insuring clause is the core provision in an insurance contract, outlining the insurer’s promise to cover specific risks, pay for losses, or provide defense against claims.
  • It defines what is covered, under what circumstances, and to what extent, making it essential for understanding an insurance policy’s scope.
  • Most insuring clauses include covered risks, policy limits, conditions, and exclusions — all of which determine when and how claims will be honored.
  • There are different types of insuring clauses, including property, liability, life, and specialized clauses tailored for unique risks.
  • Careful review of exclusions and conditions is crucial, as they often limit or define the insurer’s obligations.

An insuring clause is a part of insurance policies that defines how much risk will be taken on by the insurance company.

Basics of an Insuring Clause

Insurers take on a certain amount of risk when providing an insurance policy, and the risk the company assumes is stipulated in an insuring clause. These clauses are usually included in liability insurance policies and property insurance policies. Their main purpose is dictating how losses will be divided when there are multiple policies in place.

These provisions vary from case to case, and the amount of loss that is apportioned depends on the language of the policy. In some cases, no coverage is provided, and in others, the different insurance companies share the loss evenly. Insuring clauses are used to prevent a profit from a loss that is insured, which is required by the indemnity principle. In simpler terms, these provisions describe the liability of an insurer and outline how much coverage they are required to provide.

Insuring clauses are one of the building blocks of an effective insurance contract. When this provision is inserted into an insurance contract, the insurer is agreeing to fulfill their duties as described in the contract, including:

  • Offering lawsuit defenses
  • Covering risks by paying for any losses that occur
  • Providing any and all services that are outlined

In life insurance policies, for example, the insuring clause will state that the insurer is required to pay a certain amount to the listed beneficiary upon the death of the policyholder.

In these circumstances, the clause would include the name of the insurer, the name of the insured, and the amount that is payable to the beneficiary.

Types and Functions of Insuring Clauses

The insuring clause is not a one-size-fits-all provision — its language and function vary depending on the type of insurance policy. Broadly, insuring clauses fall into several categories:

  • Property Insurance Clauses: Define the insurer’s obligation to reimburse the policyholder for loss or damage to property caused by covered perils, such as fire, theft, or natural disasters.
  • Liability Insurance Clauses: Promise to pay damages the insured becomes legally obligated to pay due to bodily injury, property damage, or personal injury caused to others.
  • Life and Health Insurance Clauses: Specify payment amounts to beneficiaries in the event of the insured’s death or illness.
  • Specialized Insuring Clauses: Found in niche policies such as cyber liability, directors’ and officers’ (D&O) insurance, or professional indemnity coverage, detailing risks unique to those contexts.

Each type of insuring clause reflects the principle of indemnity: the insured is compensated for losses but cannot profit from them. By clearly defining what is covered, these clauses serve as the foundation for risk allocation between insurer and insured.

What's Involved in an Insuring Clause Agreement?

There are several issues included in an insuring clause, including a description of legal liability, meaning the amount that the insured will need to pay if a claim is made against the insured. These claims can include:

  • Acts of negligence, including omissions and errors
  • Slander or libel
  • A breach of confidentiality that is unintended
  • Acts that are considered criminal, dishonest, fraudulent, or malicious

Insuring clause agreements also describe the legal expenses and costs that will be covered by the insurer to defend the insured against a claim. These expenses can include damages awarded after the policyholder loses a lawsuit. These clauses also include a provision for loss of documents, whether they have been destroyed, misplaced, or simply cannot be obtained by the insured.

Key Elements of an Effective Insuring Clause

To ensure clarity and enforceability, most insuring clauses include several critical components beyond a basic promise of coverage:

  1. Scope of Coverage: A detailed description of the events, losses, or liabilities the insurer agrees to cover. This is often expressed in broad terms (“all sums the insured is legally obligated to pay”) but may also include specific scenarios.
  2. Policy Limits: The maximum amount the insurer will pay for a covered claim or within a policy period.
  3. Triggering Events: Circumstances under which coverage is activated — for example, a “claims-made” policy responds to claims made during the policy period, while an “occurrence-based” policy covers incidents that happen during the policy term, regardless of when claims are filed.
  4. Defense Obligations: Many insuring clauses require the insurer to defend the insured in lawsuits, even if allegations are groundless, provided they fall within the policy’s scope.
  5. Supplementary Payments: Some clauses include provisions for additional costs, such as legal fees, investigative costs, or post-judgment interest.

Together, these elements establish the breadth and depth of coverage, ensuring both parties understand their rights and obligations under the contract.

Insuring Clause Exclusion

To protect the insurance company, insuring clauses almost always include exclusions. It's important for the person purchasing the policy to understand these exclusions before entering into the contract. For example, most insuring clauses exclude coverage for issues that were known at the time the contract was agreed upon. There may also be exclusions when the policy holder has another policy that entitles them to indemnity.

Virtually every insuring clause includes an exclusion for acts by the insured that are considered malicious or dishonest. This exclusion can also apply when there is reasonable suspicion that fraud or some other crime has been committed. If the insured is fined or penalized or is required to pay non-compensatory damages after a lawsuit, these issues will also be excluded.

Common Scenarios Where Coverage Is Denied

While exclusions are integral to managing the insurer’s risk, they often catch policyholders off guard. Common situations where an insuring clause may not provide coverage include:

  • Known Circumstances: Events or risks the policyholder was aware of before the policy’s inception.
  • Intentional Acts: Fraudulent, malicious, or intentional acts by the insured.
  • Contractual Liability: Liabilities assumed under a separate contract, unless specifically covered.
  • Pollution and Environmental Hazards: Often excluded unless explicitly added through an endorsement.
  • War, Terrorism, and Nuclear Events: Typically excluded due to catastrophic risk potential.

Understanding these limitations is critical. Policyholders should carefully read the insuring clause and associated exclusions to avoid gaps in coverage or unexpected claim denials.

Conditions of an Insuring Cause

For an insurance policy to be valid, there are conditions that must be met that are listed in the insuring clause. For example, when the policyholder intends to file a claim, they are required to immediately notify the insurer. The policyholder must also alert the insurer to any circumstance that could possibly lead to a claim.

When notifying an insurance company of a possible claim, the policyholder must provide the insurer with several important pieces of information:

  • The name of the person that may file the claim
  • Details about the circumstance that may result in the claim
  • An act or omission that the policyholder believes will result in legal liability

Another common condition in an insuring clause is that the insured should not admit responsibility or attempt to settle claims on their own with the express permission of the insurer. Insurers have the right to take over the settlement of a claim on behalf of the policyholder, although this is not required.

Practical Tips for Negotiating an Insuring Clause

When reviewing or negotiating an insurance policy, both businesses and individuals should pay close attention to the insuring clause. Consider the following strategies:

  • Customize Coverage: Tailor the clause to reflect the specific risks associated with your industry or operations.
  • Seek Clear Definitions: Ambiguities often lead to disputes. Ensure key terms like “occurrence,” “claim,” and “loss” are defined.
  • Review Exclusions Carefully: Some exclusions may be negotiable or replaceable with endorsements for broader protection.
  • Coordinate Multiple Policies: If you have more than one policy (e.g., umbrella coverage), ensure the insuring clauses complement each other rather than create coverage gaps.
  • Consult Legal Counsel: Insurance contracts can be complex. Legal professionals can help you interpret the language and negotiate more favorable terms.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the purpose of an insuring clause?
    It defines the insurer’s core obligation — specifying what risks are covered, under what conditions, and how compensation will be provided.
  2. Are insuring clauses the same across all policies?
    No. They vary widely depending on the type of insurance (e.g., property, liability, life) and the risks being covered.
  3. Can an insuring clause be negotiated?
    Yes. Especially in commercial policies, policyholders can negotiate definitions, exclusions, and coverage terms.
  4. What’s the difference between an insuring clause and exclusions?
    The insuring clause states what is covered, while exclusions specify what is not — both must be read together to understand the policy.
  5. Why are defense obligations important in an insuring clause?
    They require the insurer to provide legal defense for the insured in covered claims, which can significantly reduce the insured’s financial burden.

If you need help understanding insuring clause, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.