Key Takeaways

  • Incentive stock options (ISOs) offer potential tax advantages, including eligibility for long-term capital gains if specific holding periods and conditions are met.
  • Non qualified stock options (NQSOs or NQOs) are more flexible, available to employees, contractors, and board members, but lack favorable tax treatment.
  • Tax treatment is the key differentiator: ISOs are taxed when shares are sold, while NQSOs are taxed at exercise as ordinary income.
  • Vesting schedules, eligibility, and transferability rules differ significantly between ISOs and NQSOs.
  • Understanding the financial and tax implications of each option type helps maximize compensation benefits and minimize tax liability.

In discussing incentive stock options vs non qualified stock options, it's important to weigh the differences between them. Incentive stock options are also called ISOs or statutory stock options. Nonqualified stock options are also known as NQOs or non-statutory stock options. While there are key differences between the two, they also have a lot in common.

Incentive Stock Options and Non-Qualified Stock Options

Stock options offer rewards as well as risks for employees. Restricted stock units are awarded to employees, but they must buy ISOs and NQOs. In general, it's riskier to exercise stock options at private companies vs public ones.

In a private company, employees may have fewer options in recouping their investment because the company can restrict when (or even if) shares can be sold.

You should understand how various stock options work and how your choice will impact your particular tax situation before you exercise the options available to you.

After vesting is complete, individuals can purchase a set number of shares of the company's stock at a predetermined price, known as the strike or exercise price.  Stock options grant employees the right to purchase shares, but it's not an obligation for them to do so.

ISOs have the potential for favorable tax treatment. If a stock option isn't an ISO, it's typically referred to as a nonqualified stock option. NQOs don't qualify for special tax treatment. The favorable tax treatment is the main advantage of ISOs for employees, and this includes long-term capital gains and no recognition of income when they exercise their options.

In the usual exit by acquisition situation, employees exercise their stock options and cash out. Their stock options are automatically defaulted to NQOs and they receive no special tax rates.

In practice, there's no material difference between ISOs and NQOs. However, ISOs may have the advantage in situations where employees should reasonably exercise and hold (for instance, the company goes public).

The tax regulations for option grants and exercises are very complicated and can change at any time. Any company which is thinking about option grants or individuals who are eligible to receive grants should consider consulting with their tax advisors and/or attorneys before making any decisions.

Understanding Vesting, Strike Price, and Exercise Timing

Both incentive stock options and non qualified stock options typically follow a vesting schedule, which dictates when the recipient gains the right to exercise the options. Vesting can be time-based (e.g., monthly or yearly over four years) or performance-based (tied to specific company milestones). Once vested, the employee has the right to purchase shares at the “strike price” (or exercise price), which is set when the options are granted.

Timing the exercise of stock options is a crucial strategic decision. Exercising too early can tie up capital and create tax liabilities without guaranteed liquidity, while exercising too late could mean missing out on significant growth potential. For ISOs, holding the stock for at least two years from the grant date and one year from exercise is necessary to qualify for favorable long-term capital gains tax treatment. With NQSOs, the taxable event occurs immediately upon exercise, regardless of how long the shares are held thereafter.

About Incentive Stock Options

When the current stock value is less than the strike price, incentive stock options are said to be  "underwater." ISOs are only for employees, so a member of the company's board of directors who is not a company employee isn't eligible to receive an ISO.

ISOs are issued according to a stock option plan that's been approved by shareholders and the board of directors. The option cannot be transferred. From the date the option is granted, the exercise period can't be longer than 10 years.

At the time the option is granted, the exercise price can't be less than the fair market value. Individuals must exercise their options within three months of leaving the company. This can be extended to twelve months for disability. There's no time limit in the event of death.

ISOs tend to be more complicated and harder to understand for a number of reasons, including the following:

  • The annual limitation
  • The two holding periods
  • The restrictions on eligibility
  • The rule about being more than a 10 percent shareholder

Advantages and Disadvantages of Incentive Stock Options

Advantages:

  • Tax efficiency: ISOs allow employees to defer taxes until shares are sold and potentially pay long-term capital gains rather than ordinary income tax rates.
  • Ownership incentive: They align employee interests with company growth, often resulting in greater wealth if the company’s valuation increases.
  • No income tax at exercise: Unlike NQSOs, exercising ISOs does not trigger immediate income tax if holding period requirements are met.

Disadvantages:

  • Eligibility restrictions: Only employees (not contractors or board members) can receive ISOs.
  • Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT): Exercising ISOs may trigger AMT, a parallel tax system that can increase overall tax liability.
  • Holding requirements: To benefit from favorable tax treatment, employees must meet strict holding periods, which may expose them to market risk if the stock price falls.

Because ISOs are tied to long-term company performance, they are often part of compensation packages in startups or high-growth companies, where the potential upside is significant.

About Non-Qualified Stock Options

NQOs are also considered "underwater" when the current stock value is lower than the strike price. NQOs are open for anyone, so independent contractors as well as employees are eligible. The board of directors must approve NQOs in a written agreement.

When an individual exercises his or her options, this income is subject to employment taxes and tax withholding. NQOs are easier for companies to have just one type of award. They're also more transparent than ISOs because it's easier to calculate the amount of tax withholding on excess.

While special tax treatment is an attractive incentive, it shouldn't be the only factor someone considers in stock options. Due to the complexity of tax law and how quickly laws can change, it's always a good idea to get the most up-to-date information from experts in the tax and financial fields. This is one of the best ways to protect your valuable investments.

Tax Implications and Strategic Considerations for NQSOs

Non qualified stock options are the more flexible and widely used type of equity compensation. Because they are not subject to the strict IRS rules that govern ISOs, companies can issue NQSOs to employees, board members, advisors, and independent contractors.

Key tax implications:

  • Ordinary income tax at exercise: The difference between the market price and the exercise price (the "spread") is taxed as ordinary income.
  • Payroll taxes apply: NQSOs are subject to Social Security and Medicare withholding, which do not apply to ISOs.
  • Capital gains tax on appreciation: Any additional gain after exercise is subject to capital gains tax when the shares are sold.

Strategic tips for employees:

  • Consider exercising in a year when your income is lower to reduce the tax impact.
  • Plan for liquidity: exercising requires cash upfront for both the strike price and taxes.
  • Understand company policies on secondary sales or buybacks before exercising, especially in private companies where shares are illiquid.

Common Use Cases for Non Qualified Stock Options

Because of their flexibility, NQSOs are particularly common in the following scenarios:

  • Compensating contractors and advisors: Since NQSOs are not limited to employees, companies often use them to reward non-employee contributors.
  • Attracting executive talent: Executives often receive a combination of ISOs and NQSOs to balance tax advantages with immediate compensation benefits.
  • Rewarding short-term performance: NQSOs can incentivize near-term company milestones without requiring the lengthy holding periods of ISOs.

While NQSOs may result in higher immediate tax liabilities, they can still offer significant wealth-building opportunities, especially in companies with strong growth prospects.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the main difference between ISOs and NQSOs?
    The main difference is tax treatment. ISOs can qualify for long-term capital gains tax if certain conditions are met, while NQSOs are taxed as ordinary income when exercised.
  2. Who is eligible to receive ISOs?
    Only employees are eligible to receive incentive stock options. NQSOs, on the other hand, can be granted to employees, contractors, advisors, and board members.
  3. Do I have to pay taxes when I exercise stock options?
    For ISOs, taxes are typically due when shares are sold. For NQSOs, taxes are due at the time of exercise based on the difference between the exercise price and the market value.
  4. Can NQSOs be transferred or sold before exercise?
    NQSOs are generally non-transferable, though some plans allow transfer to family trusts or estates. They cannot be sold before they are exercised.
  5. Which type of stock option is better for me?
    It depends on your financial situation, tax strategy, and risk tolerance. ISOs may offer better tax treatment, while NQSOs offer more flexibility and broader eligibility.

If you need help understanding non qualified stock options, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.