Key Takeaways

  • Qualified stock options (ISOs) offer favorable tax treatment but come with stricter eligibility and holding period requirements.
  • Non-qualified stock options (NSOs) are more flexible and can be issued to a wider range of recipients but are taxed as ordinary income.
  • ISOs must meet specific IRS requirements to retain tax advantages, including holding shares for at least one year after exercise and two years after grant.
  • NSOs are often used to attract advisors, consultants, or non-employee directors due to fewer restrictions.
  • Both types carry risks, including potential loss of value and tax consequences, especially in private companies or during liquidity events.

Qualified vs. non-qualified stock options -- the difference centers on tax treatment. Qualified stock options are generally treated very favorably in terms of federal taxes.

Qualified vs. Non-Qualified Stock Options

When an individual has a stock option, it means that they have the ability to purchase a set number of company stock shares at a price that has been predetermined. These purchases can only take place after the completion of the vesting period. A type of stock option exists known as an incentive stock option. The benefit of this option is that it can provide beneficial federal tax treatment. 

When a stock option does not qualify as an incentive stock option, it is called a non-qualified stock option (NQO). NQOs does not offer beneficial tax treatment that is available with incentive stock options.

Incentive stock options are preferred because of their tax treatment. When these options are used, there is no acknowledgment of income. However, if the stocks are sold immediately after the option is exercised, they do not receive special taxation, putting them on equal footing with NQOs. 

To receive the tax benefits of incentive stock options, the company employee would need to hold on to the stocks after exercising their options. This is a common practice when a company is preparing to go public. Qualified stock options is another name for incentive stock options.

When a qualified stock option is exercised and results in a profit, this profit will be taxed at 15 percent, which is the standard rate for the capital gains tax. This is also considerably lower than the income tax rate. Profits made from NQOs are taxed as normal income, which is a definite drawback. However, these stock options are much more flexible in who they can be provided to, which is a distinct benefit. They also have more exercising options than qualified stock options.

While employees may prefer qualified stock options, non-qualified stock options are more beneficial to the company, as there is a shorter waiting period before they can be deducted. Several commonalities between qualified vs. non-qualified stock options can be found.

Employees should be careful about weighing the benefits and drawbacks of stock options. For instance, employees need to purchase both NQO and qualified stock options. This is different than restricted stock units, which can be awarded. If you are interested in exercising your stock options, it's important to understand the tax implications and the function of these options.

If your stock options are in a private company, then you will be exposed to much more risk when exercising your options than you would with a publicly listed company. Some risks associated with stock options include:

  • The ability of a private company to limit when it's possible to sell stock shares, possibly making it difficult for you to receive a return on investment.
  • Keeping hold of too much stock, which can make you vulnerable to volatility if the stock rapidly loses value.
  • Not knowing if your stock will retain its value after a company acquisition or merger.

However, if you have pre-IPO stock options, you may be able to make a great deal of money once vesting has occurred.

Strategic Considerations for Startups and Employees

Choosing between qualified stock options and non-qualified stock options depends on the company’s goals, size, and growth trajectory, as well as the individual’s risk tolerance and financial planning needs.

  • For startups: ISOs are often used to attract early employees and key talent by offering favorable long-term tax treatment, encouraging them to stay until a liquidity event. NSOs, however, offer greater flexibility in rewarding advisors, board members, or non-employee contributors.
  • For employees: ISOs can maximize post-tax returns if you plan to hold the stock for the required periods and believe in the company’s growth potential. NSOs might be preferable if liquidity is needed sooner, as they allow for more flexible exercise and sale timing.

It’s common for companies to offer both types of options as part of a broader equity compensation strategy. Understanding how each works can help employees make informed decisions about when and how to exercise their options.

Key Tax and Eligibility Differences Between ISOs and NSOs

While both qualified stock options (also called incentive stock options or ISOs) and non-qualified stock options (NSOs) give employees the right to purchase company shares at a set price, the two differ significantly in tax treatment, eligibility, and long-term financial impact.

1. Taxation Timing and Rates

  • Qualified Stock Options (ISOs): No income tax is due when the option is granted or exercised, provided you meet the IRS’s holding requirements. Gains are taxed at the long-term capital gains rate (often 15% or 20%) if you hold the stock for at least one year after exercise and two years after grant.
  • Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs): Tax is due when the options are exercised. The difference between the strike price and the market value is taxed as ordinary income, often at a higher rate than capital gains.

2. Eligibility Requirements

  • ISOs can only be granted to employees of the company, and the total value of ISOs that can first become exercisable in any calendar year is capped at $100,000 per individual.
  • NSOs are more flexible and can be issued to employees, independent contractors, directors, advisors, and others.

3. Holding Period and AMT Considerations

  • ISOs require a longer holding period to qualify for favorable tax treatment. Selling earlier results in a disqualifying disposition, causing the gain to be taxed as ordinary income.
  • Exercising ISOs may trigger the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) if the “bargain element” (the difference between exercise price and fair market value) is substantial.

4. Reporting and Deductibility

  • Companies issuing ISOs cannot claim a tax deduction unless the employee makes a disqualifying disposition.
  • Companies issuing NSOs can deduct the compensation element at exercise, providing a financial benefit to the employer.

How to Use Non-Qualified Stock Options

When employees hold non-qualified stock options, they would need to pay the standard income tax rate on the difference between what they paid for the stock and what the stock was worth after being sold. If a company grants its employees non-qualified stock options, the employees are able to purchase a certain number of shares at a fixed price during a time period chosen by the company. 

A company might choose to offer its employees non-qualified stock options for several reasons. First, NQOs could be offered instead of traditional compensation. Second, the company may want to inspire a feeling of loyalty in their employees.

When pricing non-qualified stock options for employees, companies will almost always use what those shares' market value would be if they were publicly available. Once the options have been granted, employees must exercise them before the designated expiration date. Failing to do so will result in the employees losing their options. 

Tips for Exercising Stock Options Wisely

Exercising stock options—whether qualified or non-qualified—requires careful planning to minimize tax burdens and maximize returns. Here are some best practices:

  1. Understand the Vesting Schedule: Options typically vest over several years. Exercising before they vest is generally not allowed.
  2. Consider Timing for ISOs: Holding shares for the required period can significantly reduce your tax liability.
  3. Plan for AMT Exposure: If exercising ISOs with a large spread between exercise and market price, consult a tax advisor about potential AMT impacts.
  4. Watch Liquidity Events: For private companies, it’s often best to wait for a funding round, acquisition, or IPO to ensure a clear exit path.
  5. Diversify Your Portfolio: Avoid over-concentration in your company’s stock, especially if your financial future is tied to its success.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What qualifies a stock option as “qualified”?
    A qualified stock option (ISO) meets specific IRS requirements, including being granted to employees only and held for minimum periods before sale, to qualify for favorable capital gains tax treatment.
  2. What is the biggest tax advantage of qualified stock options?
    If holding requirements are met, gains on ISOs are taxed at the lower long-term capital gains rate rather than ordinary income tax rates.
  3. Can non-employees receive qualified stock options?
    No. Only employees are eligible for ISOs. Non-employees, such as contractors and advisors, can only receive NSOs.
  4. Why would a company choose NSOs over ISOs?
    NSOs offer flexibility, can be granted to a wider range of recipients, and allow companies to deduct the compensation expense at exercise.
  5. What happens if I sell ISO shares early?
    Selling ISO shares before meeting the required holding period results in a disqualifying disposition, causing the gain to be taxed as ordinary income instead of capital gains.

If you need help understanding qualified vs. non-qualified stock options, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.