Key Takeaways

  • The 3 types of incapacity in contract law are status-based, mental or cognitive, and situational (e.g., intoxication or duress).
  • Status-based incapacity can apply to minors, prisoners, or aliens during wartime.
  • Mental incapacity includes permanent conditions (e.g., intellectual disabilities) and temporary ones (e.g., psychotic episodes).
  • Situational incapacity includes conditions that impair decision-making like intoxication or undue influence.
  • Courts assess capacity based on the ability to understand the nature and consequences of a contract.
  • Contracts entered into by legally incapacitated individuals may be void or voidable depending on the circumstances.

Incapacity contract law is used when there is a question of the mental capacity of a party to a contract. When incapacity exists, the party is not eligible to enter into the contract.

Incapacity Due to Status

Incapacity can occur due to the status of the parties involved. For example:

  • Aliens, defined as people who have gained citizenship in a country other than their own, can enter into contracts. However, if war breaks out between their new country and their country of origin, the contract is then void.
  • During imprisonment, convicts or prisoners are not allowed to enter into a contract.
  • An insolvent person who is unable to pay debts cannot enter into a contract.
  • Physicians from the Royal Medical College cannot enter into contracts with their patients.
  • Barristers cannot enter into contracts with their clients.

Incapacity can also occur in relation to the mental status of the person. For example:

  • Mental deficiency can refer to persons under the age of 18 in Indian law and 21 in British law. At these ages, they are seen as lacking mental maturity and considered minors.
  • Idiots in medical terms suffer deficiencies from birth and are listed as having a permanent incapacity.
  • Persons determined to be insane have two states: state of sanity and state of insanity. Contracts may be entered into during a state of sanity. Otherwise, their status is listed as temporary incapacity.

Incapacity and Illegality

Contract obligations can be avoided by three types of people. They are:

  1. Minors. Until the age of maturity, minors cannot enter into contracts. If they do, the contracts will be voidable. If the minor reaches the age of consent, they can then agree to the terms of the contract.
  2. Vulnerable parties. A vulnerable party is one who has difficulty understanding the content of the contract and the consequences of not meeting the terms of the contract. If the person is lacking mental capacity, a minor, or has an illness, they may not be able to complete the tasks expected of the contract.
  3. Intoxicated people. People who are intoxicated have the potential to negate the contract formation if the other party is aware that the intoxicated person cannot fully comprehend the contract.

Contracts may also be voided if the content of the contract contains illegal products or expects illegal actions to be taken by the parties involved. Contracts related to any criminal activity, whether drugs or murder, are illegal and therefore unenforceable.

Understanding the 3 Types of Incapacity

In contract law, incapacity refers to a person's legal or mental inability to enter into a binding agreement. The three primary types of incapacity include:

  1. Status-Based Incapacity:
    This includes individuals who are legally restricted from contracting due to their status:
    • Minors: Often defined as individuals under 18 (or under 21 in some jurisdictions).
    • Prisoners or Convicts: May have limited contractual rights depending on the nature of incarceration.
    • Aliens: Foreign nationals may lose the right to contract with citizens during wartime or due to national security laws.
  2. Mental or Cognitive Incapacity:
    Individuals may be incapacitated if they cannot understand the nature and consequences of the agreement due to:
    • Intellectual disabilities or birth conditions (e.g., being legally classified as an “idiot” in older statutes).
    • Mental illness: Includes temporary or permanent psychiatric disorders that impair understanding.
    • Senility or degenerative conditions: Such as dementia or Alzheimer's, which affect decision-making capacity.
  3. Situational or Contextual Incapacity:
    Even individuals who are otherwise capable may experience temporary incapacity, such as:
    • Intoxication: Courts may void contracts if the other party was aware of the intoxication.
    • Duress or Undue Influence: When a party is coerced or manipulated into agreement.
    • Severe emotional distress or temporary mental breakdowns during contract formation.

Courts determine incapacity by evaluating whether the individual could reasonably understand the contract’s terms and implications at the time it was signed.

Defenses to Breach of Contract

If a breach of contract occurs due to incapacity, the party who breached the contract can be removed from any liability if they can properly defend the breach. Some defenses that are valid include:

  • Repudiation, where one party of the contract will not complete the contractual obligations. This must be proven to be abandonment, renouncement, and refusal of the contract.
  • Revocation, where one party rescinds an offer prior to the offer being accepted. The revocation is valid as long as it was communicated to the other party.
  • Lack of capacity, which shows that the party entering the contract was not allowed to do so. This could be in the case of a minor or a person lacking mental capacity.

Conversely, if a minor commits fraud by misrepresenting their age to the other party, the contract cannot be voided. The minor must then uphold their end of the contract. A minor cannot void a contract related to items considered to be necessities such as:

  • Food.
  • Lodging.
  • Clothing.
  • Medicine.
  • Medical care.
  • Education.
  • Legal services.

Legally Incapacitated vs. Legally Incompetent

Legally incapacitated in most states is described as a person who cannot meet the basic requirements needed to maintain physical health and safety. To be considered legally incapacitated, a guardianship proceeding may be necessary, but more often evidence must be used to show the inability to meet the basic requirements of physical health, safety, or property management. This will vary by state.

Legally incompetent is a legal term applied to a person who is part of legal action and is either physically or mentally incapable of understanding the charges against them. They also cannot take part in their defense. Legally incompetent can also refer to a professional who is unable to perform their duties, such as a doctor.

Legal Tests for Determining Incapacity

Judges and legal professionals often apply the following tests to assess contractual capacity:

  • Cognitive Test: Evaluates whether the person could understand the nature and consequences of the transaction.
  • Volitional Test: Looks at whether the person could act voluntarily and reasonably in their own interest.
  • Modern Functional Test: Considers how the individual’s condition affects their ability to carry out specific legal functions.

Evidence may include medical evaluations, witness testimony, or guardianship findings. In some states, an official adjudication of incapacity is required before a contract can be declared void.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the 3 types of incapacity in contract law? The three types are status-based (e.g., minors), mental or cognitive incapacity (e.g., mental illness), and situational incapacity (e.g., intoxication).

2. Can a minor legally enter into a contract? Generally, no. Contracts with minors are usually voidable, but minors can be held to contracts for necessities like food and shelter.

3. Is intoxication a valid defense to void a contract? Yes, but only if the intoxication was severe enough to prevent understanding and the other party was aware of it.

4. What’s the difference between legally incapacitated and legally incompetent? Legal incapacity relates to the inability to manage one's affairs, while incompetence often refers to the inability to participate in legal proceedings.

5. How does a court decide if someone was mentally incapacitated? Courts consider medical records, witness accounts, and whether the individual understood the contract at the time of signing.

Let me know if you'd like help integrating this into your existing article draft or optimizing other related content.

If you need help with understanding incapacity contract law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.