Key Takeaways

  • A contract entered into by a mentally incompetent person may be void, voidable, or enforceable, depending on the circumstances.
  • Mental incompetence is legally defined and must be proven in court for a contract to be automatically void.
  • Minors and individuals with temporary mental incapacity also fall under special contractual rules.
  • Some contracts made by mentally incapacitated individuals may be upheld if they involve necessities or are entered into during lucid moments.
  • Courts use different legal tests to assess mental capacity, including the “appreciate effects” and “control” tests.
  • If a mentally incompetent person enters into a contract, their guardian or legal representative may act on their behalf.
  • Fraud, undue influence, and coercion can further impact the validity of a contract involving a mentally incapacitated individual.
  • Individuals needing legal assistance with contract disputes related to mental incompetence can find expert attorneys on UpCounsel.

The mental capacity to contract is one of the most crucial elements of a contract. All parties to a contract have to be mentally capable of entering into a contract, otherwise, the contract can be considered void and canceled. It is important that all parties to a contract be mentally capable.

Mental Capacity and Contracts

One may wonder if just anyone can get into a contract. There are two basic principles for those entering contracts. They have to have:

  • Mental capacity
  • Maturity

There are tests that determine mental capacity for those over age 18. They are complex and will vary in all states. Some states opt for the “appreciate effects” test. It asks if a person is capable of understanding what they are involved in and if they appreciate the effects. The “control test” asks if someone can control themselves whether or not they understand.

These requirements are necessary so that one party does not try to take advantage of another. Contracts are a major commitment and some people will not have the legal ability or the capacity to enter into them.

The law provides who can and cannot enter into a contract when it comes to capacity. This includes legal minors, the mentally ill, or the elderly with symptoms of dementia.

The contract is considered voidable if anyone in this category enters into an agreement with another party. Voidable refers to the person lacking capacity to enter the contract and may end the contract or allow it to move forward. It protects those who lack capacity from forcefully going through with a contract that could potentially take advantage of them.

Business contract law states that people who have been declared mentally incompetent in court can find any contract they enter void, voidable, or enforceable.

Legal Tests for Determining Mental Capacity

Courts apply different legal tests to determine whether an individual has the mental capacity to enter into a contract:

  • The Cognitive Test: This assesses whether the person understands the nature and consequences of the contract.
  • The Affective Test: This evaluates whether a person can make rational decisions free from delusions or severe emotional impairments.
  • The Motivational Test: Courts consider whether the individual can act in their own best interest when making decisions.
  • The "Appreciate Effects" Test: Determines if the person understands what they are involved in and can appreciate the contract's consequences.
  • The "Control Test": Measures whether a person can control their behavior, regardless of their understanding of the contract.

If an individual fails any of these tests, the contract may be voidable or, in some cases, completely void.

Mental Incompetence: Overview

Mental incompetence with regard to contracts is in effect only if the person has been officially declared incompetent by a court. This incompetence has to be so severe that a guardian has to be assigned. The guardian is the only one who may go into a contract on that person’s behalf.

If someone that has been declared mentally incompetent tries to go into a contract on his or her own, the contract is considered void. If a person was not aware that they were entering into a contract and he or she is mentally incapacitated, the law provides that it is a voidable case.

It is possible for a person who was declared mentally incompetent before to have times where they are lucid. If a contract is entered into during a lucid time, they may be fully liable for the contract if it can be proven that he or she was cognizant of the deal, the consequences, and the reason the contract was created.

Legal Consequences of Contracts Signed by Mentally Incompetent Individuals

A contract signed by a mentally incompetent person may be classified into one of three categories:

  1. Void Contract: If a court has already declared an individual incompetent before they sign a contract, the contract is automatically void. No legal obligation exists.
  2. Voidable Contract: If the person was not declared incompetent before signing but later proves they lacked capacity at the time, the contract can be invalidated at their request.
  3. Enforceable Contract: In cases where the individual signed during a lucid interval and understood the contract’s implications, the contract may remain valid and enforceable.

Courts consider medical records, witness testimony, and expert evaluations when determining if a contract should be voided due to mental incapacity.

Mental Incompetence: Minors

Minors do not have the capacity to make contracts. In general, no one under age 18 can enter a contract. Any contract signed by a minor is void.

From a business point of view, there are some exceptions to the law. A minor can enter a contract to purchase items for necessities, like food, housing, and clothing. Some states also let minors get credit cards and bank accounts. The minors are responsible for these contracts because they are legally binding. A minor may also void a contract for no capacity while they are underage. If the minor turns 18 and has not voided the contract, it may no longer be voided.

Exceptions to Contracts Signed by Minors

While contracts signed by minors are generally voidable, there are some key exceptions:

  • Necessities: Minors may be held accountable for contracts involving essential items like food, shelter, and medical care.
  • Employment Contracts: Some states allow minors to enter employment agreements, although they may still have limited rights to void these contracts.
  • Educational Loans: Many jurisdictions permit minors to take out student loans, which are legally binding.
  • Entertainment and Sports Contracts: Special laws apply to minors in industries such as entertainment and professional sports, often requiring court approval.

If a minor does not void a contract upon reaching adulthood, it may become legally binding.

Mental Incompetence: Mental Incapacity

Mental incapacitation is legalease for those who are unable to enter a contract because of their psychological disability. In most jurisdictions, mental capacity is the level of ability to fully understand the meaning and effects of a contract. If a person is not able to fully understand and comprehend his or her legal rights and responsibilities in a contract, he or she is not legally capable of entering into a contract. Courts in some states will measure capacity using the person’s ability to judge if they should or should not enter the agreement.

The Role of Guardians and Legal Representatives in Contractual Agreements

If an individual has been legally declared mentally incompetent, a court may appoint a guardian or legal representative to manage their financial and contractual decisions. The guardian:

  • Can enter contracts on behalf of the individual.
  • Can seek to void contracts signed by the individual while they were incapacitated.
  • Must act in the best interest of the individual under legal and fiduciary duty.

Courts may also require a legal review of contracts entered into by mentally incapacitated individuals to ensure fairness and prevent exploitation.

Fraud, Coercion, and Undue Influence in Contracts with Mentally Incompetent Individuals

In some cases, individuals with diminished mental capacity are manipulated into signing contracts. If fraud, coercion, or undue influence is present, courts may declare the contract void. Common scenarios include:

  • Undue Influence: A caregiver or close relative exerts excessive pressure to persuade the person to sign a contract.
  • Fraudulent Misrepresentation: Providing false information to deceive a mentally incapacitated individual into agreeing to a contract.
  • Coercion: Forcing or threatening an individual into signing an agreement against their will.

If any of these factors are present, legal intervention may be necessary to invalidate the contract and protect the vulnerable party.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What happens if a mentally incompetent person signs a contract? If a mentally incompetent person signs a contract, it may be voidable or void depending on their legal status. If a court has declared them incompetent, the contract is void. If not, they may have the option to void it later.

2. Can a person with dementia enter into a contract? A person with dementia can enter into a contract if they are in a lucid state and fully understand the agreement. However, if they lack comprehension, the contract may be voidable.

3. Who decides if someone is mentally incompetent to sign a contract? A court of law determines mental incompetence, often based on medical evaluations, expert testimony, and legal standards for capacity.

4. Are contracts with mentally incompetent individuals automatically null and void? Not necessarily. Some contracts, such as those for necessities, may still be valid. Others may be voidable rather than automatically void.

5. How can someone challenge a contract signed by a mentally incompetent person? A legal guardian, family member, or attorney can petition the court to void the contract, providing medical evidence and witness testimony to support the claim.

If you need help with understanding mental capacity to contract, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law, and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.