Key Takeaways:

  • Founder vesting ensures that equity is earned over time, reducing risks for all stakeholders.
  • Standard vesting schedules commonly span 4 years, often with a 1-year cliff.
  • Vesting provides founders with voting rights on both vested and unvested shares.
  • Investors prefer companies with vesting agreements to safeguard equity commitments.
  • Founders can negotiate upfront equity for their initial contributions.
  • Custom vesting agreements may include milestone-based schedules or accelerated vesting.

Founder shares vesting means that after a specified time period or event, a company founder may keep all or a certain percentage of his or her stock shares even after leaving the company. Shares that are not vested may be repurchased by the corporation, often at a lower value than would be commanded on the open market. Vesting is designed to capitalize on the sweat equity of founders and determine that they are committed to the business for at least a few years.

When Does Vesting Occur?

Vesting clauses typically establish either a date or a specific event that triggers termination of the company's right of repurchase, which means that after this occurs the founder in question fully owns his or her stock shares.

Most commonly, after a full year of service to the company, 25 percent of the founder's equity is considered vested. Over the next three years, the remaining shares are vested monthly until all the holdings are vested. If the founder leaves the business during this time period, he or she receives only the vested percentage of shares. This four-year structure is standard, but companies can establish a range of structures in their founders' agreements.

In some cases, founders are vested right away for a portion of equity in exchange for the upfront work they did to establish the company. This percentage is typically 10 to 25 percent and is determined by the amount of sweat equity, the person's negotiations, and the current progress and status of the business.

Companies that are expected to grow quickly may establish a three-year vesting structure.

Understanding Vesting Cliffs

A vesting cliff represents a minimum time period a founder must remain with the company before any shares become vested. For example, under a 4-year schedule with a 1-year cliff, a founder gains no equity if they leave before the first anniversary. This mechanism protects companies from early departures while incentivizing founders to stay committed. Post-cliff, shares typically vest monthly or quarterly.

Milestone-Based Vesting Schedules

Beyond time-based vesting, some companies implement milestone-based schedules. These vesting terms tie equity grants to specific achievements, such as revenue targets, product launches, or market entry. Milestone vesting ensures alignment between founder contributions and company success, particularly in dynamic or early-stage ventures.

What Is the Purpose of Vesting?

This type of agreement reduces the risk for all founders by preventing one person from owning a large portion of the company and leaving after a year with his or her stock. In effect, the founder earns the right to keep his or her shares by committing to the company for at least three or four years. The corporation's right to repurchase the stock lapses gradually over time.

Establishing a vesting schedule can also be helpful with investor negotiations. Investors may be turned off by large portions of unvested stock and may insist on a vesting schedule before providing funds. You can head this issue off at the pass by having a reasonable vesting schedule in place before you court investors.

Benefits of Vesting for Startups

  • Prevents Founder Disputes: Vesting ensures that no founder can disproportionately claim equity without sustained contributions.
  • Attracts Investors: Well-structured vesting agreements appeal to investors, providing confidence in founder commitment.
  • Encourages Longevity: By linking equity to tenure or milestones, vesting promotes ongoing involvement.
  • Protects the Company: Vesting prevents founders who leave early from retaining excessive ownership, stabilizing ownership dynamics.

How Does Vesting Work?

The one-year cliff prevents a founder from keeping any of his or her stock if the business relationship ends before the corporation's first anniversary. If this occurs, the business can buy back all the founders' shares at the original price. For example:

  • Bob gets 100,000 stock shares as co-founder of a business. He leaves right at the one-year mark.
  • Because Bob's agreement establishes the standard vesting schedule, he gets to keep 25,000 of these shares.
  • These shares are considered earned because of his 12 months of service.
  • The company has the right to repurchase the remaining 75,000 shares at the pre-agreed price.

If a founder has to be terminated, he or she may be eligible to receive the vested shares he or she has earned thus far.

Accelerated Vesting Explained

Accelerated vesting enables founders to acquire equity faster under specific conditions, such as company acquisition or termination without cause. This provision is attractive in startup acquisitions, where founders may negotiate to retain more ownership immediately. There are two types:

  • Single Trigger: Shares vest fully upon meeting one condition, such as acquisition.
  • Double Trigger: Two conditions are required, such as acquisition followed by employment termination.

How Does Vesting Affect Voting?

Even though you don't own all your shares on day one as a co-founder, you are still entitled to voting rights for the unvested shares. The stock is considered payment for work you have yet to complete. Although you own it and can exercise its rights, it can be repossessed if you leave the business in the lurch.

Restrictions on Unvested Shares

While unvested shares grant voting rights, they often come with restrictions. These include limits on transferring, selling, or using shares as collateral. Such restrictions ensure the equity remains tied to the founder’s continued involvement in the company.

What Factors Are Considered When Allocating Stock?

When determining the stock allocation and vesting schedule for a company's founders, the team will consider these questions:

  • How much time did each person spend developing the business plan? Did one individual spend significantly more time than others?
  • Has one or more individuals made a significant gift of intellectual property, such as a pending or issued patent or substantial work toward a patentable innovation?
  • How many work hours will each founder regularly be devoting to the business? Is everyone full-time, or are some founders committed only part-time?
  • Will founders be paid for their work and how soon will this occur?

Tax Implications of Vesting

Founders must understand the tax implications of vesting agreements. For instance, filing an 83(b) election within 30 days of the grant allows founders to pay taxes on the shares' value at the time of issuance rather than when they vest. This can significantly reduce taxable income, particularly if the company grows rapidly in value.

FAQ Section

  1. What is the meaning of founder vesting?
    Founder vesting refers to a process where founders earn their equity over time or based on milestones, ensuring long-term commitment to the company.
  2. What is a vesting cliff?
    A vesting cliff is a set period during which no shares vest. After this period, a significant portion of shares vests at once, such as 25% after one year.
  3. How does vesting affect startup investments?
    Vesting agreements appeal to investors by ensuring founders cannot prematurely claim large equity stakes without sustained contributions.
  4. What are the tax implications of founder vesting?
    Filing an 83(b) election can help founders minimize tax liabilities by paying taxes on the equity's initial value rather than its appreciated value.
  5. Can vesting schedules be customized?
    Yes, founders and companies can agree to custom vesting terms, such as milestone-based or accelerated vesting, based on unique business needs.

If you need help with founder shares vesting, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.