Fixed Fee Agreement: Benefits, Types & Legal Considerations

Key Takeaways

• A fixed fee agreement provides clarity, cost predictability, and simplicity for clients and attorneys.
• These agreements can improve efficiency, incentivize streamlined services, and reduce administrative burdens.
• Common types include milestone-based and deliverable-based fixed fee contracts.
• Risks include potential underestimation of scope and reduced flexibility for unforeseen work.
• Best practices include clear definitions of scope, deliverables, and exclusions in the agreement.

A fixed fee agreement is used to provide legal services for those who do not have the funds to afford an attorney. This type of agreement cannot be used to avoid the basic relationship between clients and attorneys. To avoid any issues, fixed fee agreements should be labeled with either earned on receipt or nonrefundable, or both.

If these terms are used, the agreement must meet the ethics rules at the time the agreement is being drafted and when selecting the account where funds will be deposited. If fixed fee agreements already exist, they should be reviewed at the beginning of the year to confirm they meet the newest rules.

A required written fee agreement must include:

• The rate or basis of the fee. This is used to establish the cost that will be incurred by the client and to avoid misunderstandings.
• A list of services that will be given as part of the agreement.
• Additional services that are outside the scope of the agreement may be listed with an associated hourly rate.

It is expected that lawyers using a fixed fee agreement will provide competent representation, possess the skills needed for the case presented, be thorough in their work and be fully prepared. It is also expected that the client complies with the agreement including the use of time for calls and meetings.

Oregon Rule of Professional Conduct

Under the Oregon Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5(c)(3), lawyers are not allowed to enter into an earned on receipt fee or nonrefundable agreement unless the following is listed:

• Funds won't be placed in a lawyer trust account.
• Clients, at any point, are allowed to end the relationship and agreement with the lawyer. At this time, they may be eligible for a total or partial refund of the amount paid, as long as the services have not been completed.

Oregon rule also prohibits any dishonest conduct or misrepresentation by the lawyers. Also, the word refundable, while allowed, should be used with caution to avoid misunderstandings. If a fixed fee is charged, but not labeled as nonrefundable or earned on receipt, the fee is seen as client property. As client property, the payment must be put in a lawyer trust account. It can only be withdrawn when the case is complete according to Oregon RPC 1.15-1(c). The fixed fee agreement amount must not be seen as excessive. The fee must be in line with the amount of time, number of employees and skills required to complete the case.

The agreement should not include any clauses that allude to the fee changing without any notice. If any modifications are in the agreement that shows a benefit to the lawyer, a detailed explanation must be included and it is expected to be seen as fair.

Types of Fixed Fee Agreements

There are several variations of fixed fee agreements, each designed to fit different client needs and legal practice areas. Common types include:

• Single Fixed Fee Agreement: A set fee covers all services for a specific matter or case.
• Milestone-Based Fixed Fee Agreement: Payment is structured in stages based on achieving specific milestones.
• Deliverable-Based Fixed Fee Agreement: Fees are tied to the completion of specific deliverables, such as drafting a contract or filing a legal document.
• Capped Fee Agreement: Similar to an hourly agreement but with a maximum fee limit to protect clients from unexpected overages.

Each type offers flexibility in managing both client expectations and the attorney’s workload while still providing fee certainty.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Fixed Fee Agreements

Advantages of agreements with fixed fees include:

• The attorney can set the value associated with the service.
• The client can limit the cost of legal services at the beginning of the case.
• Fee disputes are minimized by being set upfront.
• The expectations associated with the representation is documented upfront which limits future issues.
• Fees may be collected at the time the agreement is put in place.
• Fixed fee agreements can be a good way of obtaining new clients.

Disadvantages of agreements with fixed fees include:

• If the case is more complex and takes more time than expected because the details of the case were not fully reviewed at the beginning.
• The client adds important facts to the case that are pertinent after they have signed and paid the retainer.
• The client abuses the agreement by expecting services at all times.
• The client expects legal counsel to be provided on multiple legal situations, not just on the case that is detailed under the agreement.

To avoid the disadvantages, expectations should be set in the agreement and with the client directly. This can include when they are permitted to call for updates, how many and when meetings will take place and that any additional facts submitted by the client will create additional hours and payment.

Key Features of Fixed Fee Agreements

A well-drafted fixed fee agreement should include the following essential features to ensure clarity and avoid disputes:

• Defined Scope of Work: Clearly outlines the legal services included (and excluded).
• Payment Terms: Specifies when payments are due—whether upfront, in installments, or at milestones.
• Deliverables and Deadlines: Lists expected deliverables and associated timelines.
• Exclusions and Additional Fees: Clarifies what services will incur additional charges outside the fixed fee.
• Dispute Resolution Clause: Provides a process for resolving disagreements over scope or performance.
• Termination Rights: States conditions under which either party may terminate the agreement.

By including these elements, both attorneys and clients can establish shared expectations and minimize conflicts during the engagement.

Common Challenges and How to Avoid Them

While fixed fee agreements offer predictability, they also pose challenges. Common pitfalls include:

• Scope Creep: Clients may request services beyond the original agreement.
• Underestimating Workload: Attorneys may underestimate the complexity or time required.
• Rigid Terms: Less flexibility to adapt to unforeseen legal developments.
• Potential Profit Margin Compression: Fixed fees may lead to lower profitability on more complex cases.

Strategies to avoid these challenges:

• Set firm boundaries and clearly define the scope of services in writing.
• Include a provision that additional services or work beyond the agreed scope will incur hourly or separate fixed fees.
• Use regular check-ins to ensure client expectations align with the agreement.
• Conduct a thorough initial case evaluation before proposing a fixed fee.

Comparing Fixed Fee Agreements with Retainers

Many clients confuse fixed fee agreements with retainers, but they serve different purposes:

Understanding these differences is crucial for compliance with ethical rules, especially regarding trust account management and unearned fees.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a fixed fee agreement?
   A fixed fee agreement is a contract where an attorney provides specific legal services for a predetermined fee, offering cost certainty to the client.
2. What services are typically covered by a fixed fee agreement?
   Services like drafting contracts, uncontested divorces, or simple wills are often covered under fixed fee agreements.
3. Can additional fees be charged under a fixed fee agreement?
   Yes, if work outside the defined scope arises, additional fees may be charged, typically outlined in the agreement.
4. Is a fixed fee agreement refundable?
   It depends on the jurisdiction and whether it’s labeled “earned on receipt” or “nonrefundable.” Rules may vary under professional conduct guidelines.
5. How does a fixed fee agreement differ from a retainer?
   A retainer is an advance payment for future work, while a fixed fee agreement is a set price for defined services, regardless of time spent.

If you need help with fixed fee agreements, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.