Key Takeaways

  • A contract is a legal agreement with specific enforceable terms; a covenant is a promise, often moral or spiritual, that may or may not be legally binding.
  • Covenants often exist within contracts, especially in property, employment, and corporate governance contexts.
  • Breaching a contract typically leads to termination or legal remedies; breaking a covenant may have different consequences depending on whether it is legal, moral, or religious in nature.
  • Conditions are distinct from covenants; conditions must be met for obligations to be triggered, while covenants represent promises of performance regardless of conditions.
  • Courts interpret covenants and contracts differently depending on context—real estate, religious, corporate, or family law.

The difference between covenant and contract is evident when someone breaks either one of the agreements. A contract is invalid when one of the involved parties violates it. On the other hand, a covenant remains intact even if one of the parties breaches it. While covenants are a type of contract, they are not treated the same nor are they built on the same premise. Here are the differences between contracts and covenants.

Contracts: Introduction

Contracts are agreements enforceable by law. There are critical components to a valid agreement.

  • It must have an offer and the offer accepted.
  • It must have valuable consideration. Meaning the parties are exchanging something that is equally valuable to the other.
  • Both parties must have the legal and mental capacity to enter into a contract.
  • One party cannot force the other party to sign a contract.
  • The consideration offered is legal.

While it is easier to prove a written contract, oral contracts are valid as well. A contract says, "Do this for me, and I'll do that for you." Verbal agreements are a part of everyone's day-to-day life. Here are some examples:

  • You ask an employee to work on a holiday, and in exchange, you give the employee two extra vacation days.
  • You give your teenager extra allowance for vacuuming your car.
  • You give your wife some jewelry if she lets you go out-of-town with your friends.

When Contracts Contain Covenants

While contracts and covenants are distinct concepts, they frequently intersect. Many contracts include covenants as provisions that define ongoing obligations. For example, in loan agreements, borrowers often agree to affirmative covenants (such as maintaining insurance) and negative covenants (such as not incurring additional debt without consent). These covenants ensure compliance and manage risk over the contract's duration.

Failing to comply with such covenants may not automatically void the contract but could trigger remedies such as penalties, renegotiation, or acceleration of obligations. Understanding the role of covenants within contracts is essential in business, real estate, and financial transactions.

Covenants: Introduction

A covenant is a written promise between two or more parties where the party either pledges to do something (called an affirmative covenant) or refrains from doing something (call a negative covenant). A covenant is a type of contract. In a covenant, the person making the promise is the covenantor, and the person who is benefiting from the promise is a covenantee.

Covenants are often included in contracts when that happens it becomes part of the agreement. Usually, real property contracts cover covenants. Covenants attached to real property are real covenants. Primarily, they protect people's right to enjoy their property, disruption-free. A covenant defines a relationship by setting rules for the engagement.

Types of Covenants

Covenants can take many forms depending on the context. The most common types include:

  • Affirmative Covenants: Require a party to perform an action (e.g., maintain the property, provide insurance).
  • Negative Covenants: Prevent a party from taking a specific action (e.g., not to sell to third parties, not to build above a certain height).
  • Restrictive Covenants: Common in real estate, these limit land use to preserve neighborhood aesthetics or values (e.g., no commercial activity in residential zones).
  • Religious or Spiritual Covenants: These are moral or spiritual commitments, such as vows in marriage or religious obligations, and are not typically enforceable in a court of law but hold deep personal significance.

The type of covenant influences its enforceability, remedies for breach, and practical consequences.

Covenant and the Law: Background

Many business people fail to understand the differences between covenants, representations, and warranties.

  • A covenant is a promise made by two or more people (a party) vowing to do or not to do something.
  • A representation is a factual statement that entices a party to enter into an agreement.
  • A warranty is a statement certifying certain things about the contract's subject holds true, and should it become untrue, the affected party has protection from the loss.

Covenants vs. Conditions in Contracts

It's crucial to distinguish between covenants and conditions in legal agreements:

  • A covenant is a promise to do or refrain from doing something, regardless of whether other events occur.
  • A condition is an event or state that must happen before a party is obligated to perform a duty.

For example, in a real estate deal:

  • A condition might state that the buyer must obtain financing by a certain date.
  • A covenant might require the seller to maintain the property until closing.

If a condition is unmet, performance may be excused. If a covenant is breached, the non-breaching party may seek remedies like damages but typically must still perform their own obligations unless the breach is material.

Contracts vs. Covenants: Comparison

Contracts and covenants are not the same things. Here are some fundamental differences:

  • While a contract is legally binding, a covenant is a spiritual agreement.
  • A contract is an agreement between parties while a covenant is a pledge.
  • A contract is an agreement you can break while a covenant is a perpetual promise.
  • You seal a covenant while you sign a contract.
  • A contract is a mutually beneficial relationship while a covenant is something you fulfill.
  • A contract exchanges one good for another, while a covenant is giving oneself to the other.
  • You can opt out of a contract while a covenant is about having the strengths to hold up your part of the promise.
  • One can stop paying in a contract when one party is not fulling their part in a deal. However, in a covenant, the party not getting their needs me supports the failing party so that they can meet their obligations.

Overall a covenant is a better way to build relationships both in business and in life. In a contract, if a person does not fulfill his obligation, then it gives the other party to back out as well. The same is not true in a covenant. You must hold up your promise even if others do not hold up their pledge.

Covenants are a type of contract, but they do not work like a contract. They are a trust-based promise that relies on your integrity and discipline. While contracts are enforceable by the courts, covenants depend on your values.

Practical and Legal Implications of Covenant vs Contract

Understanding the covenant vs contract distinction has real-world legal implications:

  • Enforceability: Contracts are enforced based on mutual consideration and the intention to be legally bound. Covenants, especially spiritual ones, may not have enforceable legal standing.
  • Remedies: Breach of contract typically results in damages, rescission, or specific performance. Breach of a covenant may involve equitable remedies or moral/social consequences.
  • Intent: Contracts reflect mutual obligations often with exit clauses. Covenants often signal a deeper commitment and may lack escape routes.
  • Examples in Practice:
    • In corporate law, covenants may restrict how a business operates to protect lenders or investors.
    • In family law, prenuptial agreements may include moral or behavioral covenants.
    • In real estate, covenants run with the land and bind future owners, influencing long-term use.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Can a covenant exist without a contract?
    Yes, especially in religious, moral, or social contexts. However, in legal settings, covenants often exist within contracts.
  2. Are covenants legally enforceable?
    It depends. Covenants in legal documents, such as real estate deeds or loan agreements, are enforceable. Moral or spiritual covenants generally are not.
  3. What happens if a covenant in a contract is breached?
    Consequences may include penalties, termination rights, or litigation, depending on the severity of the breach and the terms of the contract.
  4. How do courts interpret covenants vs contracts?
    Courts interpret contracts based on legal standards like offer, acceptance, and consideration. Covenants are evaluated based on their placement in the contract and the context of the agreement.
  5. Can a covenant be both moral and legal?
    Yes. Some covenants—like those in marriage or real estate—can carry both spiritual or ethical weight and legal enforceability.

If you need help with writing a covenant, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.