Key Takeaways

  • A convertible preferred note is a hybrid investment combining debt and equity features, commonly used in early-stage startup financing.
  • It converts into equity—often preferred stock—upon a trigger event like a priced funding round or acquisition.
  • Compared to SAFEs and traditional preferred stock, convertible preferred notes offer investors downside protection and potential upside with discounts and valuation caps.
  • LLCs rarely use convertible notes due to structural limitations and investor preferences for corporate equity.
  • Convertible preferred notes often include terms like valuation caps, discount rates, and interest accrual.
  • Investors using convertible notes may lack control or immediate valuation but benefit from simplicity and speed.
  • Understanding liquidation preferences, board rights, and anti-dilution protections is critical in distinguishing convertible preferred notes from other equity instruments.

A convertible preferred note is a type of short-term debt that is typically loaned by investors of start-up businesses. Upon later valuation and funding, the note can be converted into equity.

Defining a Convertible Note

As a form of short-term debt that can convert into equity, a convertible note can also include protection from contingencies such as:

  • Failure to meet the investment by the loan's maturity date
  • Selling of the business before conversion

Convertible notes and SAFE are both tools that are often used for early investments of new companies with strong potential.

How a Convertible Preferred Note Works

A convertible preferred note is a type of short-term debt that converts into equity, typically preferred stock, upon the occurrence of a predefined event such as a Series A funding round. This hybrid instrument gives investors downside protection through debt treatment, while preserving the upside potential of equity ownership once converted.

Key components of a convertible preferred note typically include:

  • Maturity Date: The note is repayable at this point if not converted.
  • Conversion Trigger: Usually a qualified financing round or acquisition.
  • Discount Rate: Investors receive a discount on the share price when converting.
  • Valuation Cap: Sets the maximum company valuation at which the note converts.
  • Interest Rate: Accrues over time and is often added to the principal before conversion.

This structure benefits both parties—founders avoid early valuation discussions, and investors receive equity on favorable terms if the company succeeds.

LLCs and Convertible Notes

Although LLCs can use convertible notes, it is not common practice because most venture capitalists prefer to invest in a corporation. This preference is due to the following:

  • Corporations provide equity through their shares while LLCs offer ownership interests.
  • Corporations have a more extensive case law history concerning legal matters.
  • LLCs are subject to pass-through taxes so their funding could affect the investors' firms.

There are two circumstances that can prompt a note conversion:

For an LLC to prompt a funding round, it will likely need to terminate its LLC status and begin a C corporation. Furthermore, the operating agreement of the LLC must discuss the transfer of the title from investors to owners.

Convertible Preferred Note vs SAFE Agreement

Convertible preferred notes and SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity) agreements are popular early-stage financing tools. While both delay valuation until a future equity round, they have key differences:

  • Debt vs. Equity: A convertible preferred note is a debt instrument, meaning it may accrue interest and have a maturity date, whereas a SAFE is an equity contract with no maturity or repayment obligation.
  • Investor Protection: Notes offer more protection in liquidation and include creditor rights; SAFEs provide fewer investor rights and are considered riskier.
  • Complexity: SAFEs are simpler and shorter in structure; convertible notes often require more detailed terms such as interest, maturity, and repayment provisions.

Startups might prefer SAFEs for simplicity and speed, while investors may lean toward notes for added security.

The Difference Between Convertible Notes and Preferred Stock

The two most common types of investment vehicles used during the start of a business are convertible debt and preferred stock.

Preferred stock is a type of stock that is sold to venture capitalists. Typically, preferred stock offers the following benefits to its holders:

  • A seat above common shareholders in the event of liquidation
  • Protection from anti-dilution
  • Priority in the order dividends are distributed
  • Board assignment
  • Application of certain contractual benefits

Convertible notes are a successful form of debt for companies when they meet the following standards:

  • The company has a sizable valuation at the time of the conversion trigger.
  • The valuation can be achieved quickly so as to be complete before the maturity date.
  • The company can deliver either no price cap or a steep price cap.

Preferred stock is successful for companies that can establish a decent valuation upon triggering and accept additional legal costs.

Understanding Convertible Preferred Stock

Convertible preferred stock is an equity security that holds preferential rights over common stock—such as dividend priority and liquidation preference—while also offering the option to convert into common shares under certain conditions.

Key attributes include:

  • Fixed Dividends: Typically pays set dividends before common shareholders receive any.
  • Conversion Ratio: Determines how many common shares the preferred converts into.
  • Conversion Trigger: May be voluntary (at the holder’s discretion) or mandatory (e.g., upon IPO or acquisition).
  • Liquidation Preference: Prioritized payout over common shares in the event of company liquidation.

Convertible preferred notes typically convert into this type of stock, offering early investors similar privileges as institutional investors in future rounds.

Advantages and Disadvantages of a Convertible Note

There are many advantages and disadvantages of convertible notes. Some advantages include:

  • They have a simplistic arrangement with less complications.
  • They offer pre-valuation investment.

The main advantage that convertible notes hold is their simple form. Oftentimes, beginning financial rounds can become difficult, time consuming, and expensive. Convertible notes offer a fast, easy, and inexpensive form of financing.

Equity-based investments actually sell shares of the company while convertible notes are a type of debt. This means that the company does not need to issue more stock or establish a new form of shares. Furthermore, it avoids problems caused by following scenarios:

  • Company valuations
  • Stock option grants
  • Tax involvement

The valuation of a company prior to investment is considered the most important and frustrating aspect of an equity-based investment. It is important because it is used to determine the value of the company that will be offered. However, this value is not easy to come by, making it a frustrating process.

Convertible notes provide investors with the ability to hold off on valuing the company until a later financing round. This gives the companies time to establish measurements that can be used to calculate a valuation.

Some additional advantages that convertible notes offer to investors include:

  • Protection from dilution
  • The conversion of a note into equity at a discount rate
  • A more favorable price share based on the maximum valuation cap

Some disadvantages of convertible notes include:

  • Certain investors are opposed to convertible notes.
  • They lack control.

While it can be considered an advantage that convertible notes do not require an immediate valuation, this lack of valuation can make it challenging for investors to determine if the offer of the note is trustworthy. Because of this, some investors, knowing their increased cost, still prefer equity-based investments.

Furthermore, investors using convertible notes do not have the ability to influence the result of their investment the way they would using an equity-based investment.

Convertible Preferred Note: Key Considerations for Investors and Founders

Before issuing or investing in a convertible preferred note, both parties should evaluate several strategic factors:

For Founders:

  • Dilution: Future conversion can dilute ownership significantly.
  • Control: Investors may gain board seats or veto rights after conversion.
  • Valuation Cap Pressure: Caps can anchor future valuations lower than expected.

For Investors:

  • Exit Potential: If the company is acquired before a priced round, terms should specify how notes convert or repay.
  • Ranking: Notes are often junior to other debt but senior to equity until conversion.
  • Tax Treatment: Interest may be taxable, and conversion events can trigger tax obligations.

Well-drafted convertible preferred notes should outline these scenarios clearly to minimize disputes.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the difference between a convertible preferred note and a SAFE? A convertible preferred note is a debt instrument with interest and maturity, while a SAFE is a contract to receive equity in the future without those features.

2. Why do startups use convertible preferred notes? They allow startups to raise capital quickly without setting a valuation and offer investors upside through discounted equity upon conversion.

3. What triggers the conversion of a convertible preferred note? Common triggers include a priced equity financing round, company acquisition, or the note's maturity date.

4. How does a valuation cap affect conversion? It sets a maximum company valuation for conversion, ensuring investors receive more equity if the company performs well.

5. Are convertible preferred notes risky for investors? They carry moderate risk—safer than common stock due to debt features, but still dependent on the startup’s future success.

If you need help with a convertible preferred note, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top five percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.