Lease to Own Commercial Property: Agreements & Benefits

Key Takeaways:

• A commercial lease agreement with an option to purchase, also called lease-to-own, allows tenants to buy property at the end of a rental period.
• Purchase price terms can vary: some agreements set a fixed price, while others depend on market value at purchase time.
• Tax implications for lease-to-own contracts differ for both tenant-buyers and landlords, influencing deductions and income classification.
• Tenants benefit by saving for a down payment, maintaining property continuity, and addressing credit issues.
• Landlords gain from higher monthly payments, non-refundable fees, and tenant accountability for maintenance.

A commercial lease agreement with an option to purchase, also known as a lease option, is a form of commercial real estate contract in which the tenant and the property owner agree that there is an option for the tenant to buy said property at the end of a stipulated rental period. The agreement usually specifies the period within which the tenant has an opportunity to purchase the rented property. The parties agree on the following:

• Sale price and the contract period.
• The amount of the monthly rent to be credited toward the eventual purchase.
• Who will be responsible for day-to-day property maintenance issues.

Purchase Price

Depending on the circumstances, the legal agreement or contract may or may not include a set price. When it does, however, the price might be a value agreed upon or the value appraised at the time of purchase. During lease option contracts, the intention of the parties plays a significant role. In several court rulings, the judges have always relied on the parties' intentions in determining whether a lease option transaction can be treated as a sale rather than relying on the economic tests.

The lease option is usually upheld if, at the point of entering the deal, the parties believed that the rent charged reflected fair market rates and the option price took into consideration the future value estimate. Two elaborate factors manifest a tenant's acquisition of equity interest in a property. The first is that the sum of the option price and the rent payments must approximate the property's fair market value. Secondly, there must be evidence of rent payment in excess of the current property's fair market rental value.

Types of Lease-to-Own Agreements

Lease-to-own agreements primarily fall into two categories:

1. Lease Option Agreements: The tenant has the right but not the obligation to purchase the property.
2. Lease Purchase Agreements: The tenant commits to buying the property at the lease's end, creating a binding obligation.

Each type has specific benefits and risks, and understanding the distinctions is crucial for both parties.

Tax Implications When the Lease Option Is Treated as a Sale

There are two significant tax implications whenever a lease option is treated as a sale:

• The nature of rent payment and option payment during the lease period are changed.
• The timing of the property's ownership transfer is changed.

Key Considerations for Lease-to-Own Contracts

When negotiating a lease-to-own commercial property agreement, both tenants and landlords should keep the following considerations in mind:

1. Contract Clarity: Clearly outline the purchase option terms, including purchase price determination and payment credits.
2. Legal Counsel: Both parties should seek legal advice to ensure terms are fair and enforceable.
3. Market Trends: Anticipate market changes that could impact the property's value at the purchase point.
4. Financial Preparedness: Tenants must prepare for financing to exercise the purchase option.

Tax Consequences on Tenant-Buyer

• No tenant is allowed to deduct his rental payments as such.
• Given the depreciable improvements' presumed purchase price allocated, the tenant is allowed to deduct such depreciation.
• Income tax deduction of a fraction of the rental payments the tenant makes. This deduction is calculated under the imputed interest rules.

Tax Consequences on the Landlord as a Seller

The following are the lease-option tax consequences on the landlord as a seller:

• The option payment is considered a down-payment.
• The rental payments made to the landlord in the lease option are considered to be part of the selling price.
• The re-characterized rental payments result either in ordinary loss or ordinary long-term gain.
• The rental income, also known as ordinary income, results in sale proceeds, also known as a capital gain.
• Since the landlord is presumed to have disposed of the property, he is not allowed to deduct any depreciation or rental expenses allowance.

Benefits of Lease Option to Tenants

As a tenant with a lease option, there are numerous benefits that you get once you enter into a commercial lease agreement with your landlord. First, the property will require repairs from time to time. In such cases, you may strike some creative deals and, subsequently, apply the value of the work against the purchase price. Secondly, the lease option gives you time to save up a down payment without losing the property. Thirdly, your lease agreement is valid as long as it is agreeable to the landlord and, as such, you don't have to move out of the property. Finally, the lease option allows you to resolve your credit problems to qualify for a traditional mortgage.

Potential Risks for Tenants in Lease-to-Own Agreements

Although lease-to-own agreements offer significant benefits, tenants must also weigh potential risks:

• Market Volatility: If property values decline, tenants may pay more than market price for the property.
• Non-Refundable Payments: Option fees and credited rent payments are often non-refundable if the purchase isn't completed.
• Financing Challenges: Securing funding at the end of the lease can be challenging if financial conditions change.

Benefits of Lease Option to the Landlord

Lease option presents significant benefits to any landlord. These advantages are as follows:

• Since the tenant hopes to own the property someday, he will take good care of it
• The landlord receives a non-refundable lease option fee from the tenant-buyer, whether or not the tenant ends up exercising the option.
• Considering that a portion of the tenant's payments goes to the eventual purchase, the landlord receives higher monthly payments from the tenant-buyer.
• The tenant-buyer takes full responsibility for repair and maintenance.
• Should the tenant be able to exercise the option, thus purchasing the property, the sales contract will already be in place, and the sales fee would be lower.

Risks for Landlords in Lease-to-Own Contracts

Landlords should also consider risks associated with lease-to-own arrangements:

• Delayed Payment: The final sale is postponed, potentially impacting cash flow.
• Market Value Increase: If the market value rises significantly, landlords may lose out if a fixed price was agreed upon.
• Tenant Default: A tenant failing to meet obligations during the lease can lead to disputes or property devaluation.

FAQ Section

1. What is a lease-to-own commercial property agreement?
   It’s an agreement where tenants rent a property with the option or obligation to purchase it after a specified period.
2. How is the purchase price determined in a lease-to-own agreement?
   It can be fixed upfront or determined based on market value at the time of purchase.
3. What are the tax implications for lease-to-own agreements?
   Tenants may deduct depreciation on improvements, and landlords classify payments as income or sale proceeds depending on the contract terms.
4. What are the benefits for tenants in a lease-to-own agreement?
   Tenants can save for a down payment, resolve credit issues, and secure a property without immediate purchase.
5. What are common risks for landlords in lease-to-own contracts?
   Risks include delayed final payment, market fluctuations, and potential tenant defaults.

You could be a newbie in the real estate industry or a seasoned commercial real estate mogul in need of a business lawyer to handle your legal issues. If you need help with issues to do with a commercial lease agreement with an option to buy, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of the lawyers on its site. The lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Yale Law and Harvard Law and have practiced law for about 14 years, including work with/or on behalf of companies like Menlo Ventures, Airbnb, and Google.