Collective Bargaining: Process and Benefits

Key Takeaways

• Collective bargaining allows employees and employers to negotiate employment terms like wages, benefits, and working conditions.
• The resulting collective bargaining agreement (CBA) is legally binding and includes procedures for dispute resolution.
• The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) and the Railway Labor Act (RLA) protect the right to collective bargaining in the U.S.
• The process typically involves five stages: preparation, discussion, proposal, bargaining, and ratification.
• Effective collective bargaining can reduce workplace conflict, promote fair labor practices, and strengthen employer-employee relations.

What Is Collective Bargaining?

Collective bargaining is when a group of working people, assisted by their unions, negotiate their employment contracts with their employer. Terms discussed include salary, perks, working hours, vacation time, health and safety, and work-life balance.

The general aim of collective bargaining is to make a bargain or a deal with a company's managerial department that discusses a number of problems in a specific workplace. This deal is a form of labor contract and is also known as a "collective bargaining agreement" (CBA).

Understanding the Purpose and Scope of Collective Bargaining

Collective bargaining serves as a cornerstone of labor relations, fostering collaboration between employees and management. Its purpose extends beyond simply setting pay rates—it aims to establish fair workplace policies, ensure job security, and promote mutual respect between the workforce and the employer.

This process provides employees with a collective voice, empowering them to address concerns such as working hours, health benefits, job safety, and promotion criteria. For employers, collective bargaining can help maintain operational stability by reducing turnover, enhancing morale, and minimizing the risk of strikes or labor unrest.

What Is a CBA?

A CBA is the result of collective bargaining and it is a legal agreement that specifies the policies that both parties have agreed to. This document usually contains a grievance procedure that details the steps aggrieved parties need to follow to resolve disputes over the contract, and in any event of employee discipline or termination.

Common Elements in a Collective Bargaining Agreement

A collective bargaining agreement (CBA) is more than just a list of negotiated benefits—it is a comprehensive document outlining the rights and responsibilities of both parties. Typical components include:

• Compensation and Wages: Details on salary scales, overtime rates, and pay increases.
• Work Hours and Scheduling: Provisions for shift lengths, rest periods, and flexible scheduling options.
• Health and Safety Provisions: Guidelines to ensure a safe working environment, often referencing OSHA standards.
• Employee Benefits: Healthcare plans, retirement contributions, and paid leave policies.
• Grievance Procedures: Steps for resolving workplace disputes internally before escalating to arbitration or litigation.
• Union Rights: Rules on union representation, dues collection, and communication with members.

Each CBA is enforceable under labor law, meaning both the employer and union are legally bound to uphold its terms.

Why Collective Bargaining?

Collective bargaining is widely-considered as being the best means for negotiating better wages in the USA. Through this method, union members have negotiated higher wages, improved benefits, and safer workplaces.

Benefits of Collective Bargaining for Employers and Employees

While collective bargaining is often viewed as an employee advocacy mechanism, it also benefits employers by establishing consistency and predictability in labor relations. Key advantages include:

• For Employees:
  • Stronger negotiating power for fair wages and benefits.
  • Increased workplace safety and job security.
  • Clear procedures for addressing grievances or discrimination.
• For Employers:
  • Reduced turnover and absenteeism through improved employee satisfaction.
  • Greater productivity resulting from clear policies and stable labor relations.
  • Lower risk of strikes when agreements are reached collaboratively.

Employers that approach collective bargaining proactively—by preparing data, understanding union priorities, and maintaining open communication—can achieve agreements that benefit both parties.

The Laws That Cover Collective Bargaining

Employees in various industries are entitled the right to collective bargaining under various laws:

• The Railway Labor Act of 1926 (RLA) grants collective bargaining to railroad workers, airline workers, and many other transportation workers.
• The National Labor Relations Act of 1935 grants rights of most other private-sector employees. It considers collective bargaining as the "policy of the United States."
• The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) states that employees have the right to join unions and collectively bargain. This act prevents employers from interfering with or preventing employees that want to form a union.
  • National Labor Relations Board supplements and enforces the NLRA.
• Other state and federal law, administrative agency regulations, and judiciary decisions.

Legal Framework and Employee Rights

The foundation of collective bargaining in the United States lies in several federal and state laws. The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) guarantees private-sector employees the right to unionize and bargain collectively. The Railway Labor Act (RLA) protects workers in the railroad and airline industries.

Public-sector employees’ rights to bargain collectively vary by state, as federal law does not fully cover government workers. Additionally, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) enforces the NLRA, ensuring fair bargaining practices and protecting employees from retaliation.

Certain groups—such as agricultural laborers, domestic workers, and independent contractors—are excluded from NLRA protections, though some states extend similar rights through local legislation.

Collective Bargaining: Resolving Disputes

If there is a dispute between the employee and the employer, then arbitration is a common method used to resolve the problem. State and federal law governs the use of arbitration.

Although the Federal Arbitration Act does not apply to employment contracts, it is being increasingly applied to labor disputes by federal courts. Forty-nine U.S. states have set the Uniform Arbitration Act (1956) as state law. If labor disputes become legal battles, the National Labor Relations Board is the federal agency that deals with them. The board also takes enforcement action when violations occur.

Mediation, Arbitration, and Enforcement

Disputes arising during or after collective bargaining are typically resolved through mediation or arbitration.

• Mediation: A neutral third party facilitates discussion to help both sides reach an agreement voluntarily.
• Arbitration: An impartial arbitrator issues a binding decision based on evidence and contract terms.
• Enforcement: The NLRB can intervene when one party fails to comply with the CBA or violates the NLRA.

Effective dispute resolution helps preserve industrial peace and ensures continuity of operations. Many CBAs include “no-strike” clauses, which commit unions to avoid work stoppages while a dispute is under arbitration.

When Does Collective Bargaining Occur?

Collective bargaining occurs when a group of employees enter a negotiation with their employer to negotiate the details of a new or existing employment contract.

Who Can Collectively Bargain?

Not all industry sector employees are entitled to collectively bargain.

Entitled to Collectively Bargain:

• Private Sector Employees: According to the NLRA, the majority of private sector employees can organize unions and participate in collective bargaining. Railway and airline employees are also entitled, under the RLA.
• Federal Employees: Many federal employees can collectively bargain over a limited set of concerns under federal law.
• Government Employees: Entitled under state law.

Human Rights Watch considers collectively bargain to be a right and preventing bargaining would be a violation of international human rights law.

Not Entitled to Collectively Bargain:

Some people working in the private sector are not able to participate in collective bargaining. These include farm workers, domestic workers, independent contractors, supervisors, and individuals working for very small businesses

What Topics Can Employees Bargain Over?

Employees are entitled to bargain over subjects that are considered mandatory to their employment contract. These generally relate to salary, working hours, pension schemes, healthcare, and workplace conditions. Employees are not entitled to bargain over things that are not considered mandatory to their contract, or illegal subjects which violate the NLRA.

The Collective Bargaining Process

The collective bargaining process usually starts when employees meet as a union and make a list of demands. In the USA, this generally takes place between one employer and its employees.

If the bargaining is happening in an industry such as hospitality or trucking, then sometimes an industry-wide or regional negotiation is necessary. For example, the collective bargaining agreement may affect employers who are in a certain city or across a whole industry.

In the construction industry, collective bargaining shouldn't need to happen because a project labor agreement (PLA) is in place before hiring workers, which sets the terms and conditions of employment for the project.

The Five Stages of Collective Bargaining

According to the National Education Association (NEA), the collective bargaining process generally unfolds in five stages:

1. Preparation: Both sides gather data, review previous agreements, and identify priorities.
2. Discussion: Representatives meet to establish negotiation ground rules and clarify objectives.
3. Proposal: Initial offers and counteroffers are exchanged to frame the core issues.
4. Bargaining: Negotiation intensifies as parties seek compromises on key demands.
5. Ratification: Once consensus is achieved, the agreement is ratified by union members and management, becoming legally binding.

Each stage requires transparency and mutual respect to ensure a fair outcome that strengthens the employer-employee relationship.

What Happens When Management and Labor Don't Agree?

If the two parties cannot come to an agreement, they can participate in a mediation process where a federal or private mediator helps them. Economic pressure in the private sector usually results in a strike or a lockout, but in the public sector, workers can only strike if the relevant law says that they can do so.

Impasse and the Role of Strikes

If negotiations reach a deadlock, known as an impasse, the union may vote to strike, or the employer may implement a lockout. Strikes remain a powerful but last-resort tool for employees to pressure employers to return to the table.

In essential public services—such as healthcare or law enforcement—strikes may be prohibited or restricted by state law. When impasses occur, the NLRB or state labor boards can assist by recommending further mediation or arbitration.

Employers who respond constructively to strikes—by reopening negotiations or addressing key grievances—often restore productivity and morale more quickly than those relying on punitive measures.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the main goals of collective bargaining?
   The primary goals are to secure fair wages, ensure safe working conditions, protect job security, and promote open communication between workers and employers.
2. Who enforces collective bargaining laws in the U.S.?
   The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) enforces collective bargaining rights and addresses unfair labor practices.
3. Can non-union employees participate in collective bargaining?
   Generally, no. Collective bargaining typically occurs between unionized employees and management, though some states allow non-union employee representation in limited cases.
4. How long does the collective bargaining process take?
   It can range from a few weeks to several months depending on the complexity of the issues, number of participants, and level of agreement between parties.
5. What happens after a CBA is ratified?
   Once ratified, both the union and employer must adhere to the agreement’s terms until it expires or is renegotiated. Violations can result in legal action through the NLRB or arbitration.

If you are currently dealing with a situation that may result in collective bargaining, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.