Key Takeaways:

  • Changing from a sole proprietorship to a corporation helps separate personal and business assets, reducing personal liability.
  • Corporations offer potential tax advantages and better funding opportunities compared to sole proprietorships.
  • The incorporation process involves legal paperwork, transferring assets, and obtaining new tax identification numbers.
  • Choosing between an S corporation, C corporation, or LLC depends on business goals, tax preferences, and ownership structure.
  • Keeping proper records, notifying clients, and updating contracts are essential when making the transition.

Incorporating a Sole Proprietorship

Changing from a sole proprietorship to a corporation helps protect the business owner's personal assets by separating them from those of the business. The level of protection varies depending on the type of corporation you select.

  • S corporations are often used for small businesses and aren't usually taxed at the corporate level but rather on dividends.
  • C corporations require you to pay corporate taxes, but you can also appoint a board of directors and issue company stock.
  • Limited liability companies (LLC) provide similar protection of personal assets, but owners (called members in an LLC) can receive their company profits without paying corporate taxes in some states. An LLC also allows for greater flexibility for profit distribution.

Understanding Business Structure Options

When transitioning from a sole proprietorship to a corporation, selecting the right business entity is crucial. Each structure offers unique benefits:

  • S Corporation (S Corp): Pass-through taxation prevents double taxation, but there are restrictions on the number of shareholders.
  • C Corporation (C Corp): Allows unlimited shareholders and different stock classes but requires corporate tax payments.
  • Limited Liability Company (LLC): Offers liability protection with fewer restrictions than an S Corp, and profits are taxed on the owner's return.

Understanding your long-term business goals will help determine the best entity type.

Pros and Cons of Incorporating a Sole Proprietorship

In a sole proprietorship, only one person owns the company. The owner doesn't pay corporate taxes on any profit but instead reports it on their personal income tax return. Some advantages of this business type include fewer regulations, less paperwork, simpler tax returns, and one profit beneficiary.

There are many advantages of incorporating a sole proprietorship besides separating your personal assets from your business, including:

  • Your personal assets are not at risk if there is a company lawsuit or bankruptcy. Note that you may want to consider business liability insurance because there are some cases in which you might be liable.
  • Corporations offer tax savings, which varies depending on the profits your corporation is realizing.

Tax Implications of Incorporating

Switching to a corporation has significant tax implications:

  • Tax Benefits: S Corps and LLCs allow pass-through taxation, meaning profits are taxed only at the individual level. C Corps, on the other hand, pay corporate tax but allow tax-deductible expenses.
  • Salary vs. Dividends: Business owners of corporations can receive income as a salary (subject to payroll taxes) or dividends (which may be taxed at a lower rate).
  • State Tax Considerations: Some states impose franchise or excise taxes on corporations, making it essential to research local tax laws.

Consulting a tax professional can help determine the most advantageous structure for your financial situation.

When Should You Incorporate a Sole Proprietorship

You can incorporate a sole proprietorship at any time of the year, but it is best to do it close to the beginning of the year because you must file a different tax return for each business type you operate during the year.

Legal and Compliance Considerations

To legally transition from a sole proprietorship to a corporation, you must complete several legal steps:

  1. Choose a Business Name: Ensure your corporation’s name complies with state regulations and isn’t already in use.
  2. Register with the State: File Articles of Incorporation (for corporations) or Articles of Organization (for LLCs) with your state’s business registration office.
  3. Obtain an EIN: The IRS requires corporations to have a new Employer Identification Number (EIN), even if the owner remains the same.
  4. Draft Corporate Bylaws: These internal rules govern how the corporation will operate.
  5. Comply with Licensing & Permits: Renew or update business licenses, state permits, and zoning clearances.

Failure to meet these legal requirements can result in penalties or delays in your business transition.

Transfer of Assets

Once you have created your corporation, you must transfer assets from your sole proprietorship to the corporation. It is important to remember to make transfers at a fair market value. Some assets might need a reputable valuation company to evaluate them. Doing this involves transferring shares of the new corporation to yourself, the owner of the sole proprietorship, to cover the amount of the assets being transferred.

Assets that are transferable include physical assets, such as property, equipment, computers, vehicles, and furniture, and also intangible assets and intellectual properties, such as the company's brand names, reputation, royalty agreements, trade secrets, trademarks, copyrights, patents, and long-term relationships.

Steps to Transfer Business Assets

Transferring assets from a sole proprietorship to a corporation requires careful documentation to avoid tax complications.

  • Physical Assets: Business equipment, inventory, and real estate should be transferred at fair market value.
  • Intangible Assets: Trademarks, patents, and goodwill must be legally reassigned to the corporation.
  • Financial Accounts: Open a new corporate bank account and transfer funds from the sole proprietorship.
  • Contracts & Agreements: Vendor agreements, client contracts, and leases should be reassigned under the corporation's name.

Proper valuation and legal documentation ensure compliance with tax laws and minimize liabilities.

Other Points to Remember

Incorporating your business is an exciting step, but the process can become complicated. It is particularly important that you properly document each phase of the process. Therefore, it's recommended that you consult an attorney to help you with closing the sole proprietorship and creating the corporation.

Some other points to remember for your new corporation include:

  • Employees transfer into the new corporation by “firing” and hiring each employee.
  • Close business accounts owned by your sole proprietorship and open new accounts for the new corporation.
  • Obtain a new federal tax identification number (FEIN) from the IRS. Depending on which state you incorporate your company in, you may also need to apply for a state tax identification number.
  • Cancel any insurance policies owned by your sole proprietorship and open new policies for the new corporation.
  • Notify clients of the change to your business, and update any existing contracts to match the name of the new corporation.
  • File articles of incorporation (for corporations) or articles of organization (for LLCs) for the state where you incorporate your company.
  • Dissolve the "doing business as" (DBA) in the state, city, or county where originally filed.
  • File a final tax return under the old DBA and request that the IRS close out the account and tax ID for the sole proprietorship. Do this after obtaining a new FEIN for the new corporation.
  • Update corporate documents, including letterheads, websites, business cards, telephone listings, and other contact information to reflect your new corporate information.

Ongoing Compliance and Record-Keeping

After incorporation, businesses must maintain certain compliance records to retain corporate status and benefits.

  • Annual Reports: Many states require corporations to file annual reports outlining their financial activities.
  • Board Meetings & Minutes: Regular board meetings with documented minutes help maintain corporate structure.
  • Separate Finances: Keeping personal and corporate finances separate prevents legal disputes over liability.
  • Payroll & Benefits: If the corporation has employees, it must comply with payroll tax requirements and provide proper benefits.

Maintaining compliance helps avoid penalties and ensures the corporation operates smoothly.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. How long does it take to change from a sole proprietorship to a corporation?
    The process can take a few weeks to several months, depending on the state requirements and the complexity of the transition.
  2. Do I need a new EIN after incorporating?
    Yes, the IRS requires a new Employer Identification Number (EIN) when forming a corporation.
  3. Can I transfer my existing business debts to the new corporation?
    Generally, debts remain with the original sole proprietorship unless creditors agree to transfer them to the corporation.
  4. Will incorporating my business reduce my personal tax liability?
    Possibly. While corporations provide liability protection, they have different tax structures. Consulting a tax expert is recommended.
  5. Do I need an attorney to incorporate my business?
    While not required, an attorney can help ensure compliance with state laws, draft necessary documents, and handle asset transfers.

If you need help with changing from a sole proprietorship to a corporation, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.