Key Takeaways:

  • A foreigner can own or be a partner in an LLC, benefiting from limited liability protection and pass-through taxation.
  • Ownership stakes in an LLC, called membership interests, are documented in the operating agreement, which specifies the percentage of ownership.
  • Foreign LLC members have specific tax reporting and withholding requirements in the U.S., including filing an individual tax return and securing a Tax Identification Number (TIN).
  • LLC formation requires filing Articles of Organization, which detail ownership and management information.
  • Certain states have unique requirements for LLC formation, such as publishing information or notarizing documents.
  • Complexities like double taxation and varying home country tax treatments can arise for foreign members, potentially mitigated by structuring through a C corporation.

Can a foreigner be a partner in an LLC? Yes, they can. A small business owner, also known as a member, can operate under the structure of a limited liability company, LLC, and reap the same tax benefits as a sole proprietorship. This includes the benefit provided by limited liability protection, which is designed to separate and protect the member's assets from the debts and losses of the LLC. Any ownership stakes a member invests within an LLC is called membership interest.

An LLC's operating agreement will specify the percentage each member owns. This is unlike corporations, which most states require identifying a par value of the issued stock when incorporating the company. LLC owners do not have the freedom of transferring the ownership interest, although some states allow ownership interest to be transferred with the unanimous consent of all other owners/members.

Who Can Own an LLC?

Within the United States, the following can own an LLC:

  • Residents.
  • Non-resident aliens.
  • Foreign persons and entities.

Arizona and most other states do not limit the number of members or place restrictions on who can take ownership of an LLC. When an LLC has a sole owner, it is considered a single-member LLC, and if it has more than one member, it is referred to as a multi-member LLC. For instance, an LLC could operate with 30 foreign members or just one member.

Advantages for Foreign Partners in an LLC

Foreign partners in LLCs enjoy several advantages, including:

  • Limited Liability Protection: Safeguards personal assets against business liabilities.
  • Tax Flexibility: Pass-through taxation eliminates double taxation at the entity level.
  • Ownership Freedom: Many states, such as Delaware and Nevada, have no residency requirements for LLC owners.
  • Business Expansion: Facilitates non-resident entrepreneurs in accessing the U.S. market.

LLCs also allow for customized agreements between members, enabling foreign investors to negotiate roles, profit-sharing, and responsibilities tailored to their business goals.

Does an LLC Have to File an Articles of Organization?

At formation, the owner(s) or a registered agent is responsible for filing the Articles of Organization in the state where the LLC will be located. The Articles of Organization is filed with the Secretary of State and requires that certain information is included, but owners may provide as many additional details as they wish to include in the articles. The names of all owners/members and their startup contributions are to be included, along with the LLC business address, statement of liability, and management information.

Key Steps to Establish a Foreign-Owned LLC

To form an LLC with foreign members, follow these steps:

  1. Select a State: States like Wyoming and Delaware are popular for their business-friendly laws.
  2. Choose a Registered Agent: A local agent is required to accept legal documents on behalf of the LLC.
  3. File Articles of Organization: Submit to the Secretary of State with:
    • LLC name.
    • Business purpose.
    • Names of members (optional in some states).
    • Registered agent details.
  4. Obtain an EIN: An Employer Identification Number (EIN) is necessary for tax purposes.
  5. Create an Operating Agreement: Define ownership percentages, voting rights, and profit-sharing among members.
  6. Open a U.S. Bank Account: Establish a U.S.-based account to simplify transactions and tax reporting.

What Is Required to Open a Startup?

States will vary in what is required in the process of a startup. For example, New York requires all new LLCs to publish their information in local newspapers, and Louisiana law requires signatures on startup forms to be notarized. An LLC operating with a foreign partner has certain reporting requirements for tax purposes. The LLC will withhold taxes on the distributive income of the foreign partner since the income is connected with a US trade or business.

An individual 1040 Non Resident tax return will then be filed by the tax partner. The withheld tax is used as an offset for any further payment after computing the tax due. In the event that the partnership held out more than owed, the foreign partner will then receive a refund for overpayment. Taxes paid in can often offset any taxes due in the individual's home country.

The foreign partner's home country will determine how the individual is taxed in relation to the LLC. Foreign countries will vary in if they see the LLC as the tax-paying entry or the individual as the tax-paying entity. This can lead to double taxation if the home country doesn't recognize the money from the 1040 Non Resident tax return as an offset for taxes owed in the home country.

By having the foreign partner invest in a corporation, called a C corporation, in a particular state in the US, the issue can be offset as the C corporation can then hold the foreign partnership's interest.

The foreign partner must file an income tax return in order to claim the refund and must have a valid tax identification number, TIN. Without a TIN, the foreign partner risks losing out on a tax refund, and the LLC partnership must still pay the withholding tax for that foreign partner.

A partner's TIN could possibly be the US employer identification number, EIN, or could also be the individual's social security number, SSN. The individual taxpayer identification number will always start with the number nine, and include two middle digits that range from 70 to 80.

Tax Considerations for Foreign LLC Partners

Foreign LLC partners must comply with these U.S. tax requirements:

  • Withholding Tax: LLCs must withhold taxes on distributable income for foreign members at a default rate of 30%, unless reduced by a tax treaty.
  • Filing Obligations:
    • Form 8805: Details income effectively connected with a U.S. business.
    • Form 1040-NR: Filed by foreign members to report U.S.-sourced income.
  • Tax Treaties: Many countries have agreements with the U.S. to mitigate double taxation. Verify your eligibility for treaty benefits.
  • TIN Requirement: Foreign members need a TIN to claim refunds or credits on withheld taxes.

Failure to comply may result in penalties for the LLC and its members.

Are Withholding Rules Rigorous?

Withholding rules are very rigorous and will depend on the status of the partner and the type of income earned by the partnership. The foreign partner will receive an 8805 Form every year by the partnership. This form is going to reflect effectively connected income, ECI, and the total tax credit allocable to the foreign partner for the tax year.

Navigating Double Taxation Challenges

Foreign members face the risk of double taxation when their home country and the U.S. both tax their income. To address this:

  1. Tax Treaty Benefits: Apply treaty provisions to reduce U.S. tax obligations.
  2. Utilize a C Corporation: A C corporation can hold the foreign partner’s interest, ensuring dividends are taxed only at the corporate level.
  3. Professional Tax Guidance: Consult a tax expert to structure income reporting efficiently and leverage credits.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ):

  1. Can a foreigner own an LLC in the U.S.? Yes, foreigners can fully own or co-own LLCs without U.S. residency requirements.
  2. What documents do foreign LLC members need? Foreigners must have a Tax Identification Number (TIN) and may need a valid visa for physical presence in the U.S.
  3. How is a foreign-owned LLC taxed? LLC income is taxed based on U.S. and home-country rules. U.S.-sourced income is subject to withholding, and foreign members file Form 1040-NR.
  4. Can LLC membership be transferred? Transfer of membership interest often requires unanimous consent from other members.
  5. What are the best states for forming a foreign-owned LLC? Delaware, Wyoming, and Nevada are popular for their flexible laws and low fees.

If you need help with understanding can a foreigner be a partner in an LLC, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.