Key Takeaways

  • Oral contracts are generally enforceable if they meet the essential elements of a contract.
  • The statute of limitations for enforcing oral contracts is typically shorter than for written contracts and varies by state.
  • Certain types of agreements must be in writing under the statute of frauds to be enforceable.
  • Proving an oral contract can be challenging without supporting evidence such as witness testimony, partial performance, or documentation.
  • Mixed contracts (both oral and written elements) may fall under the statute of limitations for oral contracts depending on the jurisdiction.
  • Legal remedies for breach of an oral contract include compensatory damages and equitable relief.
  • Consulting a qualified attorney can help evaluate the enforceability of an oral agreement.

Are oral contracts binding? When two parties reach a verbal agreement without recording their duties and expectations in writing, can the courts enforce such an arrangement?

Are Oral Contracts Enforceable?

Most lawyers recommend written contracts. While writing down your contracts offers several practical benefits, an oral contract is no less legally binding. Before a party can sue over a breach of contract claim, these three elements must be present:

  • The existence of a valid contract between the parties.
  • It must be established that the defendant breached the contract.
  • Damages caused by the defendant's actions.

The validity of a contract is not dependent on whether it was written down or oral. It is only in situations where the statute of frauds is applicable that a contract must be in writing before it can be enforced. An oral contract which does not fall into this category is enforceable.

Statute of Limitations for Oral Contracts

The oral contract statute of limitations refers to the time limit within which a party must initiate legal action after a breach occurs. This period varies by state and is generally shorter for oral contracts compared to written ones.

Typical timelines include:

  • California: 2 years for oral contracts
  • Texas: 4 years
  • New York: 6 years (same for written contracts)
  • Illinois: 5 years, including some mixed oral/written contracts if the oral elements are substantial​​

It’s crucial to understand that the statute of limitations starts from the date the breach occurs—not when the contract was formed. If you wait too long, even a valid oral agreement may become unenforceable.

Mixed Contracts:Some contracts contain both written and oral components. In such cases, courts may apply the statute of limitations for oral contracts if key terms were agreed upon verbally, even if parts of the agreement are in writing.

Common Challenges in Enforcing Oral Contracts

Although oral contracts are legally binding in many circumstances, enforcing them in court can be difficult. Challenges often arise due to:

  • Lack of tangible evidence: Unlike written contracts, oral agreements rely heavily on memory, which can fade or be disputed over time.
  • Witness credibility: A third party may be called to support your claim, but courts will scrutinize their credibility and the consistency of their testimony.
  • Misunderstandings or differing interpretations: Each party may recall the terms differently, leading to conflicting statements about key elements such as consideration, obligations, or timelines.
  • Disputes over performance: Without documentation, it’s hard to prove that one party fulfilled their obligations or that another failed to do so.

To mitigate these issues, it’s advisable to maintain supporting documentation (e.g., emails, texts, invoices) and involve witnesses where possible.

The Statute of Frauds

The statute of frauds is a concept pioneered in Great Britain in the 17th Century. During that time, it was impossible for a contracting party or their spouse to testify during a lawsuit over disputes arising from the contract. This led to the use of witnesses to commit fraud by giving false testimonies of the contract provisions despite not being party to the terms of the agreement. In 1677, the British Parliament enacted the statute of frauds to eradicate this problem. To eliminate the fraud, the statute of frauds outlines six categories of oral contracts including:

  • Contracts with terms stating that the assets of a will's executor should be used to pay a debt of the estate.
  • Contracts for marriage purposes (like dowry)
  • Contracts which cannot be performed within one year after its formation.
  • Contracts for land sales
  • Contracts where a party serves as a guarantor for another party's debts.
  • Contracts for selling goods worth a minimum of ten pounds sterling.

From 1677 onwards, the courts stopped entertaining parties seeking enforcement of any contract that can be categorized as any of the six above. The functions of the statute include:

  • Reduce the incidence of fraud in the courts
  • Discourage contracting parties from entering into these types of agreements.
  • Enable contracting parties to choose wisely during negotiations.

The United States adopted English common law after it became an independent nation, although the law has been modified to meet the peculiarities of American life. The statute of frauds was one of the laws the new nation adopted from its former colonial master.

Meanwhile, the statute of frauds has almost been expunged from modern English law, save for a requirement which says that only written contracts can be used to guarantee the debt of another party. Except for this single scenario, English courts will enforce all other types of oral or written contracts. However, the United States judiciary takes a different approach. Almost every state in the country have variations of the statute of frauds.

Lawyers often advise their clients to have their contracts in writing as it makes it easier to prove the terms of the agreements in court. A written contract is its evidence if a dispute arises over its performance. However, it can be difficult or almost impossible to prove oral contracts due to different perceptions, memory issues and the integrity of witnesses. Also, the statute of limitations for oral contracts is four years as memories can become weak quickly compared to the six years statute of limitations for a written contract.

State-by-State Differences in Oral Contract Enforcement

The enforceability of oral contracts—and how the statute of frauds is applied—can vary significantly by state. For example:

  • California applies a two-year statute of limitations for oral contracts and requires written agreements for real estate and long-term contracts under the statute of frauds.
  • Illinois enforces a five-year limitation period and has recognized in court that contracts mixing oral and written elements may still be treated as oral for limitations purposes.
  • Florida similarly distinguishes between types of contracts and enforces a four-year statute of limitations for oral agreements.

Because of this variability, it is essential to consult a local attorney to determine your rights and the applicable statute of limitations for your specific jurisdiction.

When Is an Oral Contract a Legally Binding Agreement?

An oral contract is enforceable if it has the three elements below:

  • An offer
  • Acceptance of the offer
  • Consideration, i.e., the imposition of an obligation.

To illustrate this concept, here is an example. As a woodworker, you make an offer to help a homeowner build a new kitchen cabinet for $5,000. The homeowner accepts your $5,000 offer in exchange for a new kitchen cabinet. A contract is in place without the need for writing. So long as the three elements of a contract exist as in the case above, the contract is valid and enforceable.

However, one of the parties to an oral contract may forget or feign ignorance of having an agreement with you, making it difficult to prove and get your just compensation. To avoid such problems, you can get a third party to witness the conclusion of the original agreement or the execution of the contract. But the witness may not be available when disputes arise over the contract, or might not be credible.

Legal Remedies for Breach of an Oral Contract

If an oral contract is breached, you may pursue legal remedies similar to those available for written agreements:

  • Compensatory damages: These reimburse the injured party for direct financial losses.
  • Consequential damages: Courts may award these for indirect losses if they were foreseeable at the time of the agreement.
  • Equitable relief: In certain situations, courts may enforce the contract through specific performance (requiring a party to fulfill their obligations) or restitution.

However, the burden is on the claimant to prove the contract’s existence and breach, which makes preparation and supporting evidence critical.

If you're unsure how to proceed, you can find an experienced contract attorney through UpCounsel to guide you through your options.

How to Strengthen and Prove an Oral Contract

o increase the enforceability of an oral contract, consider these best practices:

  • Document communications: Emails, text messages, or invoices can support the existence and terms of the agreement.
  • Partial performance: Evidence that one party acted on the agreement (e.g., delivered goods or services) may support enforceability.
  • Third-party witnesses: A reliable individual who observed the agreement or its performance can bolster your claim.
  • Follow-up confirmation: Sending a written summary of the verbal agreement via email or message can act as quasi-documentation.

Courts may weigh these forms of evidence when determining whether a valid contract exists and what the agreed terms were.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the oral contract statute of limitations in California?
    Two years from the date the breach occurred.
  2. Can a verbal agreement be legally binding?
    Yes, if it includes offer, acceptance, and consideration—and does not fall under the statute of frauds.
  3. What if my contract is partly oral and partly written?
    It may still be treated as an oral contract for statute of limitations purposes, depending on how the court classifies it.
  4. How do I prove an oral contract in court?
    Through witness testimony, written follow-ups, partial performance, or other supporting documentation.
  5. What happens if the statute of limitations expires?
    You may lose the legal right to enforce the contract, even if it was valid initially.
     

If you need more information on how to enforce oral contracts, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.