Key Takeaways

  • Nonprofits can be classified as public charities or private foundations, based on their funding sources, control, and operations.
  • Public charities typically receive broad public support, while private foundations are funded by a small group or single donor.
  • IRS rules governing each type of nonprofit vary, especially regarding tax treatment, reporting obligations, and permissible activities.
  • Public charities generally offer direct services, while private foundations often focus on grantmaking.
  • Understanding the distinction is crucial for compliance, tax planning, and long-term sustainability.
  • Seeking legal guidance through a qualified attorney can help ensure proper nonprofit classification and operation.

Are non-profits private or public? This question depends on how the non-profit organization is set up and its function. According to IRS classifications, all 501(c)(3) non-profit organizations will either be set up as public charities or private foundations.

Definition of a Public Nonprofit Organization Vs. a Private Nonprofit Organization

The factors that determine whether the organization is public or private are dependent on the following:

  • The activities in which it participates and engages
  • Where it receives its funding

The classification of your organization determines how much IRS oversight it is subject to, along with the requirements for tax reporting that apply.

Understanding the IRS Classification Process

When determining whether a nonprofit is public or private, the IRS evaluates the organization's funding structure and operational model. All 501(c)(3) nonprofits are initially presumed to be private foundations unless they can demonstrate qualification as a public charity. This determination is often made using a mathematical "public support test" under IRS Sections 509(a)(1), (2), or (3).

Public charities must show that a significant portion of their financial support comes from a broad group of individuals, governmental units, or other public charities. Private foundations, on the other hand, generally rely on funding from a small number of sources and do not pass the public support test.

Private Foundations

Private foundations are non-profit organizations classified by the IRS as 501(c)(3) organizations. These companies typically have fewer sources of funding than public charities and tend to grant assistance to other charitable organizations rather than operating their own services.

A private foundation often receives it funding from the following:

  • Corporations
  • Families
  • Single individuals

The money for a private foundation is often held and controlled by its directors or trustees. These organizations tend to rely on investment funds to pay for activities and initiatives. By default, the IRS classification for a non-profit organization is as a private foundation unless the organization proves that it has met the requirements for classification as a public charity.

Types of Private Foundations

Private foundations typically fall into one of the following categories:

  1. Operating Foundations – These foundations actively conduct their own charitable activities and programs (e.g., running a museum or research center).
  2. Non-Operating Foundations – These primarily distribute grants to other organizations that conduct charitable work.
  3. Corporate Foundations – Created and funded by businesses, but legally separate entities, often supporting causes aligned with the company’s mission.
  4. Family Foundations – Funded and governed by family members, often with multi-generational involvement.

Each type has distinct legal and administrative requirements, but they are all governed by stricter IRS rules than public charities, including limitations on self-dealing and mandatory minimum distributions.

Public Charities

A public charity receives its funding from members of the public. The monetary support can come from several sources:

  • Grants from private foundations
  • Donations from individuals
  • Grants from the government

In order to be classified as a public charity, an organization must align with all requirements outlined in the Internal Revenue Code section 509(a). Some of the most common public charities include hospitals, schools, and churches, and these organizations typically provide services to their recipients directly. However, some charities also serve in supportive roles to other public charities, aiding in the operation of programs that offer services to members of the public.

Non-profit organizations previously had to go through a waiting period before they were designated as public charities by the IRS. A recent ruling allows the IRS to immediately classify an organization as a public charity if it can prove that it will be able to receive enough support from the public to operate and achieve its mission.

Governance and Community Involvement in Public Charities

Public charities are expected to demonstrate significant community involvement in both funding and governance. This often includes:

  • A diversified board of directors that reflects public representation
  • Transparent reporting of activities and finances
  • Broad donor base to meet the IRS public support test

These organizations are subject to ongoing evaluation to ensure they maintain their public charity status. If they fail to meet the support tests over a rolling five-year period, they risk reclassification as private foundations.

Restrictions

Private control and funding allow private foundations to participate in activities that may benefit those in leadership positions in the organization, rather than using the funds to engage in charitable activities. There are additional regulations and rules placed by the IRS on private foundations to prevent these types of activities from occurring.

One example of a rule placed on a private foundation is that the IRS requires it to pay at least five percent of the value of its investments every year. Certain risky investments are also prohibited, as is the option to take tax deductions on certain contributions to the private foundation.

Operational and Compliance Differences

The operational differences between public charities and private foundations have important legal implications:

Private Foundations:

  • Must pay an excise tax on net investment income
  • Are prohibited from engaging in self-dealing transactions
  • Must distribute at least 5% of their assets annually
  • Are subject to penalties for failure to comply with specific IRS rules

Public Charities:

  • Can engage more freely in fundraising and solicitation
  • Face fewer limitations on investments and grants
  • Are permitted limited lobbying activities (within IRS guidelines)
  • Benefit from higher individual donor tax deduction limits (up to 60% of AGI for cash contributions)

Considerations

The rules implemented by the IRS govern how non-profit organizations are classified, and those rules can be complicated and confusing. Failure to follow these rules could result in fines and penalties, so it's important to understand them fully before submitting any paperwork. You might want to meet with an experienced attorney to be sure everything is correct before you move forward in the classification process.

Strategic Considerations When Choosing a Structure

Founders and donors must carefully assess several strategic factors when deciding whether to establish a public charity or a private foundation:

  • Control: Private foundations offer greater control over operations, but with more scrutiny and restrictions.
  • Funding Strategy: Public charities require continuous public support, whereas foundations can operate on large initial endowments.
  • Mission Delivery: Public charities are more service-oriented, while foundations are suited to strategic grantmaking.
  • Long-Term Goals: Private foundations may better suit families or corporations seeking to create a legacy institution.

The decision carries long-term legal, financial, and operational consequences. Consulting a nonprofit attorney can help ensure the chosen structure aligns with your goals and complies with all legal requirements.

The Difference Between Public and Private Non-Profit Organizations

Both public and private non-profit organizations are critical to the economic and social well-being of any country or region. These organizations offer benefits to members of society in ways that businesses in the private sector often aren't able to provide, which is one of the main reasons that the Internal Revenue Code allows most non-profit organizations to be exempt from federal taxes. The level of public involvement of each organization will determine how the IRS distinguishes and classifies it.

Tax Deduction Rules for Donors

Donors receive different tax benefits depending on whether they contribute to a public charity or a private foundation:

  • Public Charities:
    • Donors can deduct up to 60% of their adjusted gross income (AGI) for cash donations.
    • Appreciated property contributions are deductible at fair market value, up to 30% of AGI.
  • Private Foundations:
    • Deductions are limited to 30% of AGI for cash and 20% for appreciated assets.
    • Only cost basis is deductible for certain asset types, such as closely held stock.

These distinctions can be significant for high-net-worth individuals seeking tax-efficient giving strategies.

Public Charities

Public non-profit organizations are more common than private organizations, according to the IRS classifications. When someone thinks of a traditional non-profit, they are likely thinking of one that is classified as public. Common examples include hospitals, homeless shelters, and churches, although medical research institutions and universities can also be classified as public organizations. These examples are considered to be statutory public charities.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. Are nonprofits considered public or private organizations by default?
    By default, the IRS classifies 501(c)(3) nonprofits as private foundations unless they qualify as public charities through the public support test.
  2. Can a nonprofit switch from private foundation to public charity status?
    Yes, but the organization must meet specific IRS requirements and demonstrate consistent public support over a defined period.
  3. What are the advantages of being a public charity?
    Public charities enjoy more favorable donor deduction limits, less regulatory oversight, and greater flexibility in operations and fundraising.
  4. How do private foundations fund their activities?
    Private foundations often rely on an endowment from a single donor or family, using investment income to make grants or run programs.
  5. Why does the IRS distinguish between public and private nonprofits?
    The distinction ensures transparency, appropriate oversight, and prevents abuse of tax-exempt status by aligning rules with funding and governance models.

If you need help understanding are non-profits private or public, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.