Key Takeaways:

  • A private nonprofit organization can be structured as a public charity or a private foundation, which includes both operating and non-operating types.
  • A private non-operating foundation primarily funds other charitable organizations rather than running its own programs.
  • Private operating foundations actively conduct their own charitable activities and must meet IRS “income,” “asset,” or “support” tests.
  • Tax treatment and IRS reporting obligations differ between public charities, private foundations, and private non-operating foundations.
  • Choosing the right structure impacts donor control, tax benefits, grantmaking flexibility, and long-term philanthropic goals.

A private nonprofit organization can be used to do a lot of good for a variety of causes. Whether it is used to help an educational institution, advance religion, assist the elderly, or provide improvements to medical facilities, money from private nonprofit organizations has the potential to make a large difference in many scopes of life.

What is the Definition of a Public Nonprofit Organization vs. a Private Nonprofit Organization?

A 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization is defined by the IRS as either a public charity or a private foundation. The difference is based on where the funding comes from as well as the type of activities it takes part in. The classification of your organization will determine how much oversight you receive from the IRS, along with the requirements of taxation.

Private Nonprofit Organization Law and Legal Definition

A private nonprofit organization takes no part of any net earnings for the benefit of any founder, contributor, individual, or member. It has a voluntary board and its own accounting system. It will also practice non-discrimination when providing assistance.

Tax and Compliance Considerations for Private Non-Operating Foundations

Forming a private non-operating foundation requires attention to IRS regulations to preserve tax-exempt status under IRC Section 501(c)(3). Critical requirements include:

  1. Minimum Annual Distributions:
    • Must distribute roughly 5% of net investment assets annually to qualified charitable organizations.
  2. Excise Taxes and Penalties:
    • Subject to excise taxes on investment income.
    • May face penalties for “self-dealing,” excess business holdings, or failure to distribute income.
  3. Donor Deduction Limits:
    • Cash donations are generally deductible up to 30% of the donor’s AGI, compared to 60% for public charities.
    • Non-cash contributions may be limited to 20% of AGI.
  4. IRS Filings:
    • Must file Form 990-PF annually, providing transparency on grants, investments, and distributions.

Understanding these compliance obligations is essential for long-term success and for maintaining the foundation’s favorable tax status.

What is a Public Charity?

A public charity is a type of charitable organization that receives public support and works actively to support other public charities. It can also be devoted to public safety testing. Almost all public charities will live on public contributions. To be deemed a public charity, a nonprofit organization has to meet requirements of section 509(a) of the Internal Revenue Code.

Any donations to a public charity are fully tax-deductible. The public charity is what many people think of when they hear the word charity. The mission for each charity can range from assisting the homeless, education, or advancing religion. A church, university, or a hospital are all examples of public charities.

A public charity can be publicly supported, may get a large amount of its money from the public, or it can function to support an organization that is a public charity.

Nonprofit organizations were once required to go through a waiting period before being designated as a public charity by the IRS. Now, the IRS has an updated ruling that allows for immediate classification as a public charity if it can prove to the IRS that it will have enough public support.

What is a Private Foundation?

A private foundation is a type of charitable organization that does not meet the requirements for a public charity. They are typically nonprofits that are established with money from a single source or from certain sources, such as family members, instead of getting money from the public.

The money raised and used in a private foundation is managed by its own board of directors or trustees. It will also rely on investments from outside resources. Over half of the board has to be unable to get paid as an employee of the institution. In other words, anyone working on the foundation may not be employed by the foundation itself and receive compensation. The IRS will classify all nonprofit organizations as private foundations unless they can prove  they meet the requirements to be considered public.

While the funds that are provided to a private foundation can be deducted from taxes, most will not accept donations. A private foundation will typically invest principal funding and then payout the income from those investments and use them for charity work.

Private foundations often have endowments. These funds are used to:

  • Make grants
  • Provide gifts to other nonprofits
  • Assist educational, religious, and charitable causes

While there is a number of different criteria to help distinguish between the different types of foundations, the IRS states that the main difference between them is how they distribute income.

A private foundation that is not operational will grant money to other charitable organizations. This is very common for a private foundation. They will not provide direct assistance for charitable programs.

A private foundation that is operational will distribute money to help pay for its own charitable programs that are used for different purposes and services.  Each private foundation will be subject to some specific requirements and restrictions.

Private Operating vs. Non-Operating Foundations

The IRS distinguishes between private operating and non-operating foundations based on how funds are used:

  • Private Operating Foundations
    • Conduct their own charitable programs or services.
    • Must pass one of three IRS tests: income test, asset test, or support test to prove active program use of funds.
    • Examples include museums, research institutions, or libraries that run their own programs.
  • Private Non-Operating Foundations
    • Primarily provide financial support to other charitable organizations.
    • Do not need to run their own programs, making them attractive for family philanthropies and long-term endowment strategies.
    • Must distribute a minimum percentage of assets each year to qualified charities.

This distinction affects compliance and planning. Non-operating foundations are often simpler to manage but come with excise tax rules and strict grantmaking requirements.

Understanding Private Non-Operating Foundations

A private non-operating foundation is a type of private foundation that primarily supports charitable work through grants rather than running its own programs. Unlike operating foundations, which use most of their resources to conduct their own charitable projects, non-operating foundations serve as funding vehicles to assist other organizations.

Key characteristics include:

  • Purpose: Grants or distributions to public charities or other qualified nonprofits.
  • No direct program operations: They typically do not operate their own charitable services.
  • IRS treatment: They must meet annual minimum distribution requirements, usually at least 5% of their net investment assets, to maintain tax-exempt status.
  • Tax deductions: Donors can deduct contributions, though with lower limits than contributions to public charities.

This structure provides donors with flexibility and long-term control over charitable assets while maintaining separation from day-to-day nonprofit operations.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is a private non-operating foundation? It is a type of private foundation that primarily funds other charitable organizations through grants rather than running its own programs.

2. How is a private non-operating foundation different from an operating foundation? Operating foundations conduct their own charitable programs, while non-operating foundations mainly provide funding to other nonprofits.

3. What are the tax benefits for donors? Donors can deduct contributions, though the limits are typically 30% of AGI for cash and 20% for non-cash contributions.

4. Are private non-operating foundations required to distribute funds annually? Yes, they must generally distribute at least 5% of net investment assets each year to qualified charities.

5. Do private non-operating foundations have to file tax forms? Yes, they must file Form 990-PF annually to report assets, distributions, and compliance with IRS rules.

If you need help with understanding private nonprofit organizations, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law, and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.