Key Takeaways

  • Actual possession refers to physically holding or having direct control over property or an object.
  • It is often contrasted with constructive possession, where a person may not physically possess the item but still has legal control over it.
  • In criminal law, actual possession can establish culpability in drug or weapon cases.
  • In real estate, actual possession is critical in adverse possession claims, where a claimant must show use and occupation of the land as an owner.
  • Evidence like use, fencing, or maintaining the property supports claims of actual possession.

Actual possession is a term that is used to define whether or not a person has direct, physical possession or control of an item.

Definition of Possession

Possession is established when a person controls, occupies, or owns something. In most cases, possession pertains to something like personal property or a plot of land. According to the United States Supreme Court, there is no word that has a more ambiguous meaning than the word possession. In fact, depending on the context in which the word is used, it can take on a number of potential meanings.

For this reason, whether or not somebody possesses something is usually at the center of controversy in many civil cases that involve real property and personal property, as well as criminal cases that involve weapons or drugs. Whether or not a tenant is able to claim possession or whether or not a defendant in a criminal case is considered to be in possession of property that has been stolen are some prime examples.

The concept of possession is as old as the ideas of ownership and private property. The laws pertaining to possession that are in place today are actually derived from ancient Rome's doctrines as they related to possession. In fact, English Natural Law borrowed heavily from the Roman ideas of possession.

Later, the British would bring their established possession laws to the New World and apply them in the colonies that were originally established in America. After the War of Independence ended, the newly formed United States court systems continued to employ these laws, expanding on the ideas of possession that have existed for hundreds of years before our legal system was established.

There are two terms many people commonly mistake for one another:

  • Ownership
  • Possession

It is important to note that there is a difference between possession and ownership. Despite the fact that these two terms get confused on a regular basis, ownership does not mean the same thing as possession. You've no doubt heard the term "possession is nine-tenths of the law." You may not know, however, that there are no laws or regulations in place that actually state this. This phrase does elude to a pretty important observation, though, and typically refers to the suggestion that, if somebody possesses something, they are most likely the person that owns it.

Many people also frequently refer to things that they own, such as clothing and household items, as possessions. The person that owns an item, however, may not necessarily be the person who possesses that item. If you were to loan your car to a friend, however, the person that is borrowing and driving the car is the one that possesses it. Just because you're loaning your car to a friend doesn't mean you're giving up your ownership of the car, though.

There are quite a few distinctions between the concepts of ownership and possession. In addition, the numerous nuances associated with possession can be so complicated, even many judges and lawyers have difficulty interpreting them all. To make things simpler, the word possession is often accompanied by descriptive terms that help to further define the type of possession being referred to, such as:

  • Actual possession
  • Adverse possession
  • Conscious possession

Definition of Actual Possession

What most people think of as possession is actually what is legally referred to as actual possession. Simply put, actual possession is physically having an item in one's personal custody or having direct control over that item. In other words, actual possession is the term that is commonly used to refer to being in immediate physical contact with the object in question. Somebody that is carrying a cellphone in their pocket, for example, is considered to have actual possession of that cellphone. As another example, if you happen to be wearing a device like a smartwatch, you have actual possession of that smartwatch.

By necessity, however, actual possession is very limited in nature. In many cases, factual evidence is used to clearly indicate whether or not a person has actual possession of an item they don't have direct physical contact with. To handle these scenarios properly, the court system has broadened the scope of consideration for possession to extend beyond the concept of actual possession.

Distinguishing Actual Possession from Constructive Possession

While actual possession involves physical control, constructive possession arises when an individual has the power and intention to control an object without physically holding it. Courts often assess whether a person had access to the location of the object and knowledge of its presence.

For example, if drugs are found in a glove compartment of a car that multiple people have access to, the prosecution must prove more than mere proximity. They must show that the individual had both the ability and the intent to control the drugs to establish constructive possession. In contrast, drugs found in the person's pocket would clearly demonstrate actual possession.

The key distinctions include:

  • Physical presence vs. inferred control
  • Immediate custody vs. shared access
  • Ease of proving culpability in court

Understanding these distinctions is critical in both criminal and civil contexts.

Actual Possession in Adverse Possession Claims

In the context of real estate law, actual possession is one of the essential elements required to claim title to property through adverse possession. To meet the legal threshold for adverse possession, a person must occupy the land in a way that is:

  • Actual: The claimant physically uses or resides on the land.
  • Open and notorious: The use is visible and obvious to anyone, including the legal owner.
  • Exclusive: The claimant uses the land without sharing control with others, including the owner.
  • Continuous: The occupation is uninterrupted for the statutory period defined by the state.

Examples of actual possession for adverse possession purposes include building a structure, erecting a fence, planting crops, or regularly maintaining the property. Simply walking by or thinking about using the property does not meet the standard. Courts require clear evidence of control and presence to prove actual possession.

Criminal Law and Actual Possession

In criminal law, actual possession is a crucial factor in prosecuting cases involving controlled substances, weapons, or stolen goods. A person is considered in actual possession when the illegal item is found on their person or in an area they directly control—such as their pocket, hand, or a bag they are holding. For instance, someone with drugs in their coat pocket would be in actual possession of those drugs.

Courts look at several indicators to establish actual possession in criminal cases, including:

  • Whether the item was found on the defendant’s body or in clothing they were wearing
  • Statements or admissions acknowledging control or ownership
  • Observations of the person handling or using the item
  • Fingerprints or DNA evidence on the item

Establishing actual possession can result in immediate legal consequences, especially in jurisdictions with strict liability statutes. However, actual possession must often be distinguished from constructive possession, where the individual has knowledge and access but not physical control.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the difference between actual and constructive possession? Actual possession means having physical control of an item, while constructive possession involves the ability and intent to control it without direct contact.

2. How does actual possession affect criminal charges? It can lead to stronger prosecution since physical custody of illegal items is more easily proven than inferred control.

3. Can you claim property through actual possession? Yes, under the doctrine of adverse possession, but it must meet other criteria like continuous and exclusive use for a certain period.

4. Is physical contact always required for actual possession? Generally yes, but courts may also consider closely associated control—such as an item in a bag the person is carrying—as actual possession.

5. How can I prove actual possession in court? Evidence like physical presence, testimony, security footage, fingerprints, or witness accounts can help establish actual possession.

If you need help with actual possession, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.