Key Takeaways

  • Accounting law governs financial documentation, reporting, and auditing standards in both private and legal sectors.
  • Court-ordered accounting serves as an equitable remedy for resolving complex financial disputes or breaches of fiduciary duty.
  • Failures in accounting compliance can result in significant legal and financial consequences, as illustrated by high-profile scandals.
  • GAAP provides uniformity and reliability in financial reporting, essential for public trust.
  • Legal professionals must adhere to unique accounting requirements, including IOLTA compliance and ethical billing practices.
  • The roles of forensic accounting and legal accountants are essential in litigation and fraud investigations.

The accounting law definition is the system used to record, summarize, analyze, and categorize the financial transactions of an individual or a business. This is used in legal cases to determine the amount of damages owed to a plaintiff. This is sometimes called accounting for profits.

Methods of Accounting

Common methods of accounting include:

  • Accrual — shows income earned and expenses incurred over a specific period, regardless of whether they were received or paid during that period.
  • Cash — records only income and expenses that have been paid or received during a specific period.
  • Completed contract — reports the income and expenses associated with specific long-term contracts.
  • Installment — calculates depreciation of regulated utilities for income tax.
  • Cost — shows the value of assets at their actual cost.
  • Fair value method — indicates the current market value of assets.
  • Price level — values assets in a financial statement by comparing their current value to the gross national product.

Court-Ordered Accounting

If the court requires accounting in a lawsuit, the defendant must account for his or her administration of the affairs in question. This may include:

  • The management of an estate by an executor.
  • The disclosure of the business actions of a partner.

This legal remedy dates back to ancient courts of equity, in which the officers of the chancery served as auditors on behalf of the king.

Today, plaintiffs can request accounting when a jury has difficulty resolving the complexity of the accounts referenced in a case or when a position of trust has been violated. U.S. courts have both law and equity jurisdiction. Moreover, they can order an accounting when needed.

In addition to the examples mentioned above, this could occur if the court wants to prevent a party from profiting from a wrong it has committed. For example, a bank teller who has invested embezzled funds in the stock market may be stripped of all the associated earnings, not just the original amount stolen. He or she must trace all financial transactions that have resulted from the injury in question.

Forensic Accounting and Litigation Support

Forensic accounting plays a critical role in resolving legal disputes where financial irregularities are alleged. In these cases, accounting law intersects with litigation by requiring detailed investigation into financial records.

Forensic accountants may be involved in:

  • Tracing Asset Transfers: Especially in fraud, embezzlement, or divorce cases.
  • Calculating Economic Damages: In civil lawsuits, personal injury claims, or breach of contract.
  • Evaluating Financial Statements: For signs of manipulation or misrepresentation.
  • Serving as Expert Witnesses: Presenting complex financial evidence clearly to a judge or jury.

Their findings are often pivotal in court-ordered accounting and can influence case outcomes significantly.

Failures of Accounting

Major changes have been made to professional accounting standards owing to a series of industry mishaps beginning in the late 1990s. Since 1973, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) has served to establish these professional accounting and reporting standards. Although this is a private organization, the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) recognize its authority.

The FASB revised standards after investors lost approximately $200 billion in collective earnings because of financial reporting and auditing failures involving:

  • Sunbeam
  • Superior Bank
  • Bausch and Lomb
  • Dollar General
  • Other major companies.

The most famous of these incidents was the collapse of the Enron Corporation in the third quarter of 2001, resulting in U.S. history's largest bankruptcy. Thousands of employees lost their retirement plans, and accounting firm Arthur Anderson was found guilty on federal charges of obstruction of justice. The courts found that Andersen:

  • Did not follow generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP).
  • Destroyed thousands of paper and digital documents.
  • Improperly categorized hundreds of millions of dollars.

After the Enron case, the FASB took a central role in leading the industry's self-regulation. New accounting rules were announced in early 2003.

Regulatory Bodies and Compliance Frameworks

To prevent the reoccurrence of high-profile accounting failures, several oversight organizations enforce standards and ethical practices in financial reporting. Key bodies include:

  • Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB): Issues GAAP and guides reporting standards for private entities.
  • Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB): Oversees audits of public companies to protect investors.
  • Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): Enforces regulations related to financial disclosure and investor protection.
  • State Bar Associations: Set guidelines for legal accounting, including client fund management and ethical billing practices.

Compliance with these regulatory bodies ensures transparency, reduces fraud, and fosters public confidence in the financial and legal systems.

Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP)

The existence of these rules, guidelines, and procedures creates public faith in the system by those who participate in the economic marketplace. The aftermath of the 1929's stock market crash showed the disastrous financial consequences of a lack of public faith.

Organizations including the SEC, the FASB, and the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) have developed modern accounting principles. The latter formed the Committee on Accounting Procedures in 1937 with the aim of standardizing industry practices. In 1959, the Accounting Principles Board replaced this committee, and it maintained responsibility until the 1973 formation of the FASB.

This board consists of seven compensated full-time members who identify, research, and resolve accounting issues. A vote of five to two or greater is required to make changes to the Statements of Financial Accounting Standards. The Financial Accounting Foundation oversees the FASB, which a 16-member Board of Trustees governs.

Ethical Considerations in Legal Accounting

Legal accounting isn’t just about following financial protocols—it’s also deeply rooted in ethics. Lawyers and law firms must handle financial matters in a way that upholds client trust and avoids conflicts of interest.

Common ethical obligations include:

  • Avoiding Commingling of Funds: Firm and client money must always be segregated.
  • Timely Client Disbursements: Funds held in trust must be released promptly once earned or due.
  • Transparent Billing Practices: Time entries, expenses, and rates must be accurately tracked and clearly disclosed to clients.
  • Maintaining Accurate Records: Law firms must preserve billing and trust records for several years, depending on jurisdiction.

Violations can result in disciplinary action, disbarment, or even criminal charges in extreme cases.

Legal Accounting Standards in Practice

In the legal industry, accounting standards are tailored to address unique operational and ethical needs. Law firms must adopt specific accounting systems to maintain regulatory compliance, ensure ethical client billing, and accurately manage trust accounts.

Key legal-specific accounting practices include:

  • Accrual-Based Accounting for Legal Services: Tracks revenue when earned, not when paid, which helps with long-term case management.
  • Cash Basis Accounting for Solo Practitioners: Simplifies income tracking by recording only when money is received or paid.
  • Client Trust Accounting (IOLTA): Lawyers are required to keep client funds in separate trust accounts, following strict rules about disbursement and recordkeeping.
  • Retainer Management: Law firms must treat unearned retainers as liabilities until earned and must not co-mingle them with firm operating funds.

Compliance with bar association guidelines and IRS requirements is vital. Law firms often rely on legal-specific accounting software such as Clio, CosmoLex, or QuickBooks for Attorneys to meet these demands.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is accounting law?
    Accounting law refers to the legal principles and regulations that govern financial recording, reporting, auditing, and compliance for individuals, businesses, and legal professionals.
  2. How does accounting law apply to law firms?
    Law firms must follow accounting laws that ensure proper handling of client funds, accurate billing, and trust account compliance—often governed by bar association rules.
  3. What is a court-ordered accounting?
    This is a legal remedy where a court requires a defendant to disclose detailed financial records, typically in fiduciary or complex financial disputes.
  4. Why are GAAP standards important in accounting law?
    GAAP provides a standardized framework for financial reporting, ensuring consistency, transparency, and comparability across industries.
  5. What role do forensic accountants play in legal cases?
    They investigate financial data for litigation support, helping courts assess damages, detect fraud, or trace asset movement.

If you need help with accounting law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.