Key Takeaways:

  • LLC members enjoy limited liability protection, safeguarding personal assets from business debts, except under specific conditions.
  • Personal liability arises when members commit fraud, negligence, or illegal actions, personally guarantee loans, or misuse LLC funds.
  • LLC members should maintain business formalities and separation of personal and business finances to avoid piercing the corporate veil.
  • Single-member LLCs may face unique challenges with liability protection in some states.
  • Steps to prevent liability include drafting an Operating Agreement, obtaining business insurance, and separating personal and business assets.

Who is liable in an LLC is a common question for new business owners. It is important for business owners to be aware of the LLC business structure, along with its many benefits. One of these benefits is the limited liability protection that the LLC offers its owners. Similar to a corporation, the LLC owners, also referred to as members, are generally not personally liable for the debts and obligations of the business. Therefore, if a legal suit is brought against the LLC, the personal assets of the owners are protected.

However, while this is one of the biggest benefits of the LLC business structure, this protection isn’t absolute, as there could be an instance when a plaintiff could “pierce the corporate veil” and hold an LLC member personally liable.

Limited Liability Protection

As previously noted, similar to the shareholders in a corporation, LLC members can’t be held personally liable for the business debts. This means that all personal assets of the owner(s), i.e. home, car, personal bank accounts, personal investments, etc., cannot be touched. The only investment that the LLC owners could in fact lose is his or her initial capital contribution in the LLC. While this protection is generally offered to all members, there are some circumstances when the member(s) might be personally liable for such debts and liabilities of the LLC.

Some of these exceptions include the following:

  1. If the member injures someone
  2. If the member personally guarantees a bank loan for the LLC
  3. If the member fails to pay taxes on his or her portion of the business profits
  4. If the member acts fraudulently, illegally, or recklessly and such action(s) harms the business or someone else
  5. If the member treats the LLC as an extension of him or herself

Undoubtedly, if a member acts illegally or fraudulently, then he or she will be held personally liable. This doesn’t mean that all members will be liable, only those who acted illegally. Furthermore, an example of a member acting recklessly includes a member obtaining several business loans with the knowledge that the business will not be able to repay such loans. Alternatively, it could also include the member obtaining business loans and then using such funds for personal use. Such action would also constitute illegal and fraudulent activity, along with treating the LLC as an extension of oneself. Therefore, some of the above circumstances can overlap.

Some other examples of a member treating the LLC as an extension of oneself includes co-mingling personal and business assets, or otherwise acting as though he or she has complete and utter control over the LLC as though it is nothing more than an alter ego of the member.

Piercing the Corporate Veil

The protection offered by an LLC is not foolproof and can be challenged in court through a process called "piercing the corporate veil." This occurs when a court determines that the LLC is not functioning as a separate legal entity but rather as an extension of its owners. Key situations that may lead to piercing the corporate veil include:

  • Failing to follow LLC formalities, such as keeping separate financial records or holding required meetings.
  • Commingling personal and business finances, such as using business funds for personal expenses.
  • Grossly underfunding the LLC at its inception, making it incapable of meeting its obligations.
  • Using the LLC to commit fraud or conduct illegal activities.

To prevent this, ensure that the LLC operates as a distinct entity, maintain proper documentation, and avoid actions that could undermine its legitimacy.

Personal Guarantees and Collateral

In some situations, LLC owners may need to provide personal guarantees or collateral to secure business loans. This voluntarily places personal assets, such as homes or vehicles, at risk if the LLC defaults. To minimize personal exposure, consider the following:

  • Negotiate business loans without personal guarantees whenever possible.
  • Limit the scope of personal guarantees to specific amounts or obligations.
  • Understand the terms of any collateral agreement and the potential implications if the business cannot meet its obligations.

LLC owners should carefully assess the risks associated with personal guarantees and seek alternative funding options if available.

Actions to Prevent Personal Liability

In order to prevent any of the above circumstances from arising, you should ensure that all members act fair and legally. Don’t misrepresent yourselves or your company. Don’t lie about your finances to potential clients, vendors, suppliers, etc.

Next, you should all ensure that your LLC is funded appropriately. You don’t want to obtain a business loan if you know that you will be unable to pay it back with interest. Be sure to invest significant capital to keep your business afloat.

You’ll also want to keep all personal assets separate from the business assets. This is why it is important to open a business bank account and credit card. Another way to ensure separation is to obtain an Employer Identification Number (EIN) from the IRS. This is essentially a Social Security Number for businesses.

Draft an Operating Agreement. This document will provide formalized procedures for all business decisions. It can also help create a separate existence of your business.

Another idea is to obtain business insurance. This can help protect your personal assets from liability. While it can’t protect you from liability in the event of fraud or illegal practices, it can prevent liability if you inadvertently injure someone else. An example of this would be a massage therapist accidentally injuring someone’s leg when performing a massage.

The Role of Business Insurance

Obtaining business insurance is a proactive way to minimize risks of personal liability. Insurance can cover certain claims, such as accidents or negligence, that occur during business operations. Common types of insurance for LLCs include:

  • General Liability Insurance: Protects against third-party claims for bodily injury or property damage.
  • Professional Liability Insurance: Also known as errors and omissions insurance, this covers claims of professional negligence or malpractice.
  • Product Liability Insurance: Safeguards businesses that produce or sell goods against claims of defective products.

While insurance cannot shield members from liability resulting from illegal or fraudulent actions, it provides an additional layer of protection against inadvertent risks.

Single-Member LLCs and Liability Challenges

Single-member LLCs often face greater scrutiny in liability cases because there are no other members to demonstrate shared ownership and decision-making. In some states, creditors may bypass the limited liability protection for single-member LLCs and access personal assets directly.

To reinforce liability protection, single-member LLCs should:

  • Maintain strict separation between personal and business finances.
  • Draft a detailed Operating Agreement, even if it's not legally required.
  • Ensure the LLC is adequately capitalized to meet its obligations.
  • Avoid actions that could be interpreted as using the LLC for personal purposes.

These steps help reinforce the LLC's status as a separate legal entity, reducing the likelihood of personal liability.

FAQ Section:

  1. What is "piercing the corporate veil"?
    • It is a legal action where a court removes an LLC's liability protection if the business is not operated as a separate entity, exposing owners' personal assets.
  2. Am I personally liable for LLC debt if I guarantee a loan?
    • Yes, if you personally guarantee a loan, creditors can pursue your personal assets if the LLC cannot repay the debt.
  3. What steps can I take to avoid personal liability in an LLC?
    • Maintain business formalities, separate personal and business finances, draft an Operating Agreement, and obtain business insurance.
  4. Do single-member LLCs have the same liability protection as multi-member LLCs?
    • In some states, single-member LLCs may face weaker liability protections, making it essential to follow strict business practices.
  5. Can my LLC’s assets be used to pay my personal debts?
    • Generally, no. However, creditors may obtain a "charging order" to claim your LLC income to satisfy personal debts, depending on state laws.

If you need help learning more about the limited liability protection exceptions, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5-percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law, and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.