Key Takeaways

  • A Subchapter S Corporation (or S corp) is not a legal entity but a tax designation that allows income, losses, deductions, and credits to pass through to shareholders.
  • S corps offer limited liability protection, pass-through taxation, and potential savings on self-employment taxes for shareholder-employees.
  • To qualify, a company must meet IRS criteria, including being a domestic corporation, having no more than 100 shareholders, and issuing only one class of stock.
  • S corps are attractive to small business owners seeking a balance between liability protection, tax efficiency, and credibility.
  • Additional considerations include operational formalities, strict shareholder requirements, and IRS scrutiny of compensation practices.
  • Subchapter S status can also affect financing, investment, and exit strategies, making it essential to plan for ownership changes, growth, and compliance.

What is subchapter S corporation? An S corp is a corporate entity with an S tax code classification from the IRS. It is not a legal entity, but a tax-based classification that the IRS gives to business owners who request the designation.

The tax code allows business income and losses to pass from the business to individual shareholders without paying business income taxes. Shareholders may then report business losses and income on their individual tax returns and would pay the taxes owed. The main attribute that separates an S corp from a C corp is that S corps do not pay business income taxes.

S corps tend to be a more attractive option for small owners than a standard C corp. However, a corporation must meet certain criteria before obtaining S classification status:

  • Must be a domestic corporation
  • Cannot have over 100 shareholders
  • Are restricted to one stock class (No tiered stock permitted)
  • Cannot be owned by non-residents and non-U.S. citizens
  • Other entities cannot own an S corp, such as other corporations or LLCs

S Corp Benefits

Like C corps, an S corp offers the following benefits:

  • Limited Liability Protection: S corp shareholders receive certain liability protections as they conduct business. For instance, they cannot be held liable for any liabilities or debts that a business incurs, and creditors cannot gain access to personal property in the form of houses or cars to satisfy business debts. Liability is only restricted to the amount a shareholder has invested in the company.
  • Pass-through Taxation: Pass-through taxation allows shareholders to save money and avoid paying business income taxes.
  • Income Offsets: If you juggle multiple income streams, any losses from the S corp may be used to offset a portion of other income sources.
  • Estate-Planning: S corps aid in transferring property or other assets to heirs upon your death.
  • Perpetual Existence: S corps exist forever, even if you are a sole-owner, or if owners leave or die.
  • Ownership Transfer: Owners may transfer shares without facing tax ramifications or entity dissolution. On the other hand, LLC owners risk dissolution if they transfer more than 50 percent interest to another party. Additionally, an S corp does not have to adjust property basis or adhere to complicated accounting measures. S corp owners with inventory may use the cash accounting method, which is an easier accounting measure when compared to the accrual method.
  • Heightened Credibility: The public views S corps with more credibility than other business entities. This is because it shows that owners have made a sound commitment to their business. Your business is more likely to attract additional customers, employees, and suppliers under an S corp.

Additional Advantages of Subchapter S Corporation Status

Subchapter S corporation status offers several advanced benefits beyond standard liability and tax savings, particularly as a business scales or seeks investment:

  • Reduced Double Taxation: Unlike C corporations, S corps are not taxed twice — once at the corporate level and again at the shareholder level. Instead, income is taxed only once on shareholders’ individual returns.
  • More Attractive to Investors: While ownership is limited, many investors appreciate the tax-efficient structure and predictable distributions of S corps.
  • Easier Business Succession: The pass-through structure simplifies the transfer of shares to heirs, which can be crucial in family-owned businesses.
  • Access to Capital Programs: Some federal programs, such as the Small Business Lending Fund (SBLF), offer incentives specifically designed for subchapter S corporations, including reduced interest rates as lending increases.
  • Potential Fringe Benefits: Shareholders who are also employees may be eligible for certain employee benefits, such as health insurance and retirement plan contributions, though these must be structured carefully to comply with IRS rules.

S Corp Taxation

Shareholders can save additional taxes if they work as employees. An employee classification helps shareholders save money on self-employment taxes.  For example, a shareholder who does extra work for a company may designate his or herself as an employee and take a salary. In addition, they can accept tax-free distributions or dividends while accepting the salary. Moreover, they can generate wage-paid and business-expense deductions.

Filing and Compliance Requirements for S Corporations

While the tax advantages of a subchapter S corporation are significant, maintaining that status requires careful attention to ongoing compliance:

  1. Election Filing: Corporations must file IRS Form 2553 within 2 months and 15 days of the start of the tax year they wish to elect S corp status.
  2. Shareholder Agreements: All shareholders must consent to the S corp election and comply with eligibility requirements.
  3. Annual Filings: S corps must file an annual return on Form 1120-S and provide each shareholder with a Schedule K-1 reporting their share of income, deductions, and credits.
  4. Payroll Compliance: Shareholders who are also employees must receive a “reasonable salary” for their work. Underpaying can trigger IRS audits and back-tax assessments.
  5. State Requirements: Some states recognize S corp status automatically, while others require additional filings or impose separate taxes.
  6. Corporate Formalities: Like C corporations, S corps must follow governance procedures such as issuing stock certificates, maintaining meeting minutes, and recording major decisions.

S Corp Basics

When creating an S corp, you need to remember the following:

  • Articles of incorporation
  • Recording corporate minutes
  • Conducting shareholder and directors meetings
  • Establishing voting procedures

The added paperwork and flings may include:

  • Employ Tax Documents
  • Form 1040 (Individual Income Taxes)
  • Form 1040 (Estimated Individual Taxes)
  • Forms 940, 941, and 2553
  • Form 4625 (Depreciation)
  • Schedule K-1 (Income, Deductions, and Credits)

Steps to Form a Subchapter S Corporation

Establishing a subchapter S corporation involves several deliberate steps beyond standard business formation:

  1. Incorporate the Business: File Articles of Incorporation with the state where you plan to operate.
  2. Adopt Corporate Bylaws: Set internal governance rules and hold an initial meeting of directors and shareholders.
  3. Obtain an EIN: Register with the IRS for an Employer Identification Number, required for tax and payroll purposes.
  4. File Form 2553: Make the S election with the IRS and ensure all shareholders consent.
  5. Register with the State: Fulfill state-level tax and registration obligations, which may vary.
  6. Maintain Records: Keep detailed corporate records, hold annual meetings, and follow required corporate formalities.

Properly completing these steps helps preserve S corp status and avoid reclassification as a C corporation.

Potential Consequences

Be aware that you may need additional paperwork, and you should consult with an accountant or attorney to know more about what may be required of your business. By failing to file the necessary paperwork, your S corp status may be worked. If this occurs, your business will be taxed as a C corp.

You should also know that the IRS tends to scrutinize S corp income characterizations due to the potential for abuse. This is why you should adequately characterize your income in the proper manner to avoid a response from the IRS.

For example, if you are shareholder who chooses to be classified as an employee, you should be paid what’s considered a reasonable salary based on the job position you’re filling. Making your salary artificially low could trigger an IRS response because it appears you’re trying to get out of paying additional self-employment taxes.

Strategic Considerations and Common Pitfalls

While subchapter S corporations offer significant tax and legal benefits, they also come with potential drawbacks and strategic considerations:

  • Ownership Restrictions: The 100-shareholder cap and prohibition on non-resident or institutional shareholders can limit growth and fundraising options.
  • Limited Stock Classes: With only one class of stock permitted, S corps lack flexibility in structuring preferred stock or investor rights.
  • Increased IRS Scrutiny: The IRS closely monitors S corp compensation practices to ensure shareholder-employees receive reasonable salaries.
  • State-Level Variations: Some states impose franchise or entity-level taxes on S corps, reducing their overall tax advantage.
  • Loss Limitations: Shareholders can only deduct business losses up to the amount of their investment basis, limiting loss-offset benefits.
  • Conversion Challenges: Changing from an S corp to another structure (like a C corp) later can trigger tax consequences and complex restructuring steps.

Understanding these challenges before electing S corp status can help you avoid costly mistakes and maximize the entity’s benefits over the long term.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. How is a Subchapter S corporation different from a C corporation?
    A Subchapter S corporation avoids double taxation by passing income and losses directly to shareholders, while a C corporation pays corporate taxes before distributing dividends.
  2. Can an LLC become a Subchapter S corporation?
    Yes. LLCs can elect to be taxed as an S corp by filing IRS Form 2553 if they meet all eligibility requirements, including shareholder and stock class limitations.
  3. What happens if an S corp violates eligibility requirements?
    It may lose its S status and be reclassified as a C corporation, which can result in double taxation and other financial consequences.
  4. Are S corps subject to self-employment taxes?
    Shareholder-employees pay FICA taxes on their salaries but not on distributions, potentially reducing total self-employment tax liability.
  5. Do all states recognize Subchapter S status?
    Not all states follow federal S corp rules. Some impose state-level taxes or require additional filings, so it’s essential to check local regulations.

If you need help identifying subchapter s corporation, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.