Key Takeaways

  • “Operation of law” allows for automatic transfer or termination of rights without direct action by involved parties.
  • In real estate, assets can transfer by operation of law due to death, divorce, or joint ownership arrangements.
  • Common property types that transfer this way include joint tenancy property, tenancy by entirety, and real estate held in trusts.
  • Certain real estate ownership forms, like joint tenancy with right of survivorship, automatically transfer property to surviving owners upon death.
  • Operation of law can also end contracts, such as agency agreements or real estate purchase agreements, under specific legal conditions.
  • Probate is often avoided when real estate transfers by operation of law, streamlining the distribution of property.

What does operation of law mean is a common question among those unfamiliar with how assets are passed from one party to another through legal means. Essentially, all contracts operate as legally binding agreements. This means that by law, the parties must abide by the contract or else they will be in breach. Such asset transfers include the following types of legal documents:

  1. Wills and estates
  2. Business contracts
  3. Real estate contracts

Transfer Through Operation of Law

When wanting to transfer assets that are owned by two or more owners, there are certain requirements, depending on the law in the particular state you live in. Some examples of this type of ownership include:

  1. Joint Tenants with Right of Survivorship
  2. Joint Tenants in Common
  3. Intestate Death

Joint Tenants with Right of Survivorship involve the ownership over real estate by two or more people. If John and Rose own a home equally, and want to operate the asset as joint tenants with Right of Survivorship, then when either John or Rose die, the other will take 100% ownership over the property.

If John and Rose own the property as Joint Tenants in Common, they each own the home with 50% interest. If Rose dies, then her 50% interest will be passed onto her estate and not John.

Intestate death refers to dying without a will. For example, let’s assume that John and Rose are married. If Rose dies intestate, her assets will pass on to John, her husband. However, some states provide that when Rose dies intestate, only a portion will go to her husband. The remaining assets might go to their children, Rose’s siblings, or other family members depending on the state laws.

Common Real Estate Scenarios Where Operation of Law Applies

In real estate, the “operation of law” principle plays a crucial role in determining how ownership transfers in various legal contexts, often without the need for a formal transaction. Common examples include:

  • Joint Tenancy with Right of Survivorship (JTWROS): When one owner dies, their share automatically transfers to the surviving co-owner(s), bypassing probate.
  • Tenancy by the Entirety: A form of joint ownership available to married couples. If one spouse dies, full ownership passes to the surviving spouse.
  • Transfer on Death (TOD) Deeds: Available in some states, these allow a property owner to name a beneficiary who automatically inherits the real estate upon the owner’s death.
  • Community Property with Right of Survivorship: In applicable states, this ownership model combines features of community property and JTWROS, ensuring the spouse receives full ownership upon death.
  • Intestate Succession: If a property owner dies without a will, state laws will determine the property’s distribution, which may include transferring real estate by operation of law to a spouse, children, or other relatives.

These mechanisms are designed to streamline the transfer process and reduce the burden of probate when real estate changes hands due to death or dissolution of marriage.

How Operation of Law Affects Real Estate During Divorce

Divorce can trigger automatic changes to property ownership through operation of law. For instance:

  • Severance of Joint Tenancy: In many states, filing for divorce automatically severs a joint tenancy, converting it into a tenancy in common. This changes the survivorship rights and allows each party to will their share independently.
  • Court-Ordered Transfers: As part of the divorce decree, courts may order the transfer of real estate from one spouse to another, executed by law even without mutual consent.
  • Equitable Distribution States: Courts may divide marital property (including real estate) equitably, though not always equally, through legal authority, even if titles aren’t updated at the time.

These automatic or court-directed actions ensure fairness and enforceability without needing fresh real estate contracts or manual transfers.

Contract Termination Through Operation of Law

Contracts can be terminated in a number of ways, including a termination by either party or through operation of law. Such examples of when the contract might be terminated include the following:

  1. If the person making or receiving the offer dies or becomes incapacitated
  2. Illegalities, i.e., illegal or fraudulent acts identified in the contract itself
  3. Contracts that might be deemed unenforceable, i.e., lack of legal capacity, etc.
  4. Subject matter that is otherwise destroyed

If either party dies or becomes incapacitated after signing the contract but before performance occurs, the contract will automatically terminate. Similarly, if the contract is deemed unenforceable, it will be void altogether. This might occur if the parties didn’t abide by all elements required when entering into the contract. Such elements include an offer, acceptance, consideration, mutual assent, and legal capacity. Therefore, if the parties are not legally capable of entering into a contract, the contract might be unenforceable. Examples of legal incapacity include if the parties are under the age of 18, mentally incompetent, or under the influence of drugs or alcohol.

Furthermore, if the parties can’t prove consideration, the contract will be void and unenforceable. Mutual assent must occur between the parties. If one of the parties was forced, threatened or coerced in any way, then the contract will be unenforceable.

If the subject matter itself is destroyed, the contract will be automatically terminated. For example, let’s assume that John and Rose entered into a contract to sell John’s car to Rose for $500. After they signed the contract, but before they performed under the agreement, John’s car was destroyed by a fire. This means that the contract is automatically terminated, since at no fault of either party, the car was destroyed.

Real Estate Contracts Terminated by Operation of Law

Certain events can automatically void real estate contracts through operation of law. Key scenarios include:

  • Death or Incapacity of a Party: If a buyer or seller dies before closing, the contract may terminate unless otherwise specified.
  • Destruction of the Property: If the subject property is destroyed (e.g., fire, flood) before the deal is closed, the agreement may be terminated automatically.
  • Legal Incompetency: If a party becomes legally incompetent before performing their contractual duties, the contract is no longer enforceable.
  • Illegality: If changes in law make the terms of the contract illegal, such as a new zoning ordinance, the contract may be void.

These safeguards protect parties from being bound to agreements that can no longer be fulfilled in good faith or in compliance with the law.

Termination of Principal/Agent Contract

Any contract entered into between a principal and agent might be terminated if one of the following circumstances arises:

  1. Partial performance under the agreement
  2. For cause
  3. Express contract permitting termination

If the agent only partially performs his duties under the agreement, the principal can terminate the contract for future performance.

If the principal/agent contract is entered into for a specific duration, and the principal has a valid reason, he can revoke the agreement before the expiration date on the contract. If the contract isn’t for a fixed term, but rather continuous with no end date, the principal can terminate the agreement with reasonable notice for any reason. This means that the principal doesn’t have to continue the principal/agent relationship if he chooses to end it. But he must give the agent reasonable notice of such termination. Lastly, if the agent has some sort of interest in the subject matter of the agreement, the contract can be revoked only if there is an express provision in the contract allowing termination.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What does “operation of law” mean in real estate?It refers to the automatic transfer or alteration of ownership rights in real estate due to legal events like death, divorce, or incapacity, without needing a formal agreement or deed.

2. Can property transfer without probate through operation of law?Yes. Joint tenancy, transfer-on-death deeds, and tenancy by the entirety are mechanisms that allow property to pass directly to a survivor or named beneficiary, bypassing probate.

3. Does divorce automatically change property ownership?In many cases, yes. Filing for divorce may sever joint tenancy or trigger court-ordered transfers of marital property by operation of law.

4. What happens to a real estate contract if one party dies?If a party to a real estate contract dies before closing and the agreement doesn’t include a survivorship clause, it may be terminated through operation of law.

5. Can the destruction of property void a real estate contract?Yes. If the subject property is destroyed before the transaction is completed, the contract is often automatically terminated under operation of law principles.

If you need help learning more about the operation of law, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law, and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.