Key Takeaways

  • A condition is a core obligation in a contract; a warranty is a supportive promise related to performance or quality.
  • Breaching a condition may void a contract; breaching a warranty typically leads only to damages.
  • Warranties can be express (explicitly stated) or implied (assumed by law).
  • Some warranties are classified as statutory, especially in contracts of sale.
  • "Warranty is a condition stated in the proposal" applies when a proposal incorporates warranties as enforceable contract terms.
  • Contract drafters should classify terms clearly to reduce legal ambiguity.
  • Different industries—like software, manufacturing, and services—may apply warranties differently.
  • Seeking legal advice helps ensure contract clauses are enforceable and aligned with business goals.

Warranty and condition in contract law refer to specific stipulations set in a contract of sale. A contract is an agreement that takes place between two parties to complete a mutual transaction. Warranty and condition include the specific features of those terms. It is important to understand the difference between the two definitions.

Definition of Condition

Drafting a legal contract requires clear and specific conditions. The conditions are the actions or steps that one or both parties will do to fulfill their side of the contract. The conditions are a requirement based on the contract agreement. There are two types of conditions present in a typical contract:

  • Expressed Condition: These are conditions that are clearly defined and agreed to.
  • Implied Condition: These are conditions that are not verbally discussed but are expected to be a part of the contract. Implied conditions might include the title of goods sold, the quality of the goods, condition of completeness, and a sale by description.

Definition of Warranty

A warranty is a guarantee as to the quality of the goods or services sold that are included in the contract. A warranty can also be expressed or implied. Warranties back up statements about sold products or goods. If a warranty claim proves to be false, solutions include:

  • A refund
  • A full void of the contract

Warranties are also available either:

  • With a time limit
  • For the entire life of the goods

However, the time requirements should be included in the contract.

Types of Warranties in Contracts

Warranties serve different functions depending on the type of contract. Common categories include:

  • Express Warranties: Specifically stated in the contract, often in proposals or formal agreements. For instance, a seller might state that a product will function for a minimum of one year.
  • Implied Warranties: Not explicitly stated but legally assumed. Examples include the implied warranty of merchantability (the product works as expected) and the implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose.
  • Statutory Warranties: Arise from specific laws, such as the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) or consumer protection statutes.
  • Limited Warranties: Only apply under certain conditions or offer restricted remedies, such as repair but not replacement.
  • Lifetime or Full Warranties: Provide ongoing protection for a product’s usable life, though definitions of “lifetime” can vary.

Understanding these types helps clarify how the phrase "warranty is a condition stated in the proposal" operates—particularly when a proposal evolves into a binding agreement.

Condition Versus Warranty in a Contract

Goods are the subject matter in a contract of sale. Millions of goods are sold on a daily basis, and understanding the difference between a warranty and a condition is important. A contract of sale lists the exact provisions needed to be complete in order to abide by the contract. These requirements could be either in the form of a warranty or a condition.

Conditions are the set stipulations of the contract, whereas warranties are considered to be an additional set of rules. They both might have time requirements, but the time limits set on the conditions of the contract are legally enforceable. Warranties are usually a specific term within the contract's conditions that are a written promise.

Knowing the difference between the two terms is important for:

  • Liability
  • Termination reasons

If a condition within the contract is breached, the innocent party may have the right to terminate the contract. They can also claim damages or may choose to continue to keep the contract in effect. A breach of warranty is often not enough to terminate a contract, but it could lead to damages claimed. Of course, it is always important to seek legal advice when dealing with a breach of warranty or condition within a contract.

When a Warranty Becomes a Condition in a Proposal

In some contracts, particularly those in business-to-business (B2B) transactions, a warranty can be structured as a condition precedent—a term that must be satisfied before the contract becomes enforceable. When a warranty is essential to the performance of the agreement, it may effectively become a condition stated in the proposal.

This typically occurs in proposals that:

  • Include performance guarantees essential to the buyer’s decision to proceed.
  • Describe warranties as prerequisites for project execution or payments.
  • Integrate warranties into service-level agreements (SLAs) or milestones.

For example, in a software licensing agreement, the vendor’s warranty that the software will be bug-free for 90 days may be listed as a condition that triggers continued service or payment. This illustrates how a warranty is a condition stated in the proposal and shows the interconnectedness of these terms in complex contracts.

Terms Classified by Statute

It is not always clear as which contract terms are conditions and which are warranties. Statutes can determine which terms are considered to be a contract condition or a warranty. Many legal jurisdictions follow The Sale of Goods Act of 1979. This legal act stipulates that:

  • Characteristics of goods sold, including descriptions, quality, and fitness, are often included as conditions.
  • Characteristics such as the enjoyment of goods and a lack of encumbrances are usually considered to be warranties.

Other conditions can also affect the classification of a condition and a warranty. For example, whether the contract is of a consumer or a commercial contract will also affect the specific term definitions. Other terms might be classified as intermediate terms. Intermediate terms are those that do not fit perfectly into either the conditions or warranties categories.

You can avoid confusion as to term definitions by including which category each lies under in the contract draft. However, if the contract does not distinguish which falls into each type, the following actions are taken:

  • The court will evaluate the statute or case laws.
  • The court will evaluate the breach of contract and damage terms. A breach of conditions can lead to contract termination while a breach of warranties does not.
  • The court can also identify contract stipulation mistakes and change the classification terms.

Warranty Clauses: Drafting Considerations and Best Practices

Drafting effective warranty clauses requires a clear understanding of what they cover, exclude, and require. Consider the following best practices:

  1. Specify Scope: Define what is covered—product quality, performance, timelines, etc.
  2. Set Limitations: Outline exclusions (e.g., misuse, modifications) to limit liability.
  3. Define Remedies: List what will happen if a warranty is breached—refund, repair, or replacement.
  4. State Duration: Clarify how long the warranty is valid and whether renewal is possible.
  5. Include Notice Requirements: Define how and when a claim must be submitted.
  6. Address Governing Law: Specify which jurisdiction’s laws apply to the interpretation and enforcement of warranties.

When drafting or reviewing a proposal, it’s crucial to determine whether a warranty functions independently or as a condition to the overall agreement. This is especially important in international or high-value contracts.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can a warranty ever be considered a condition in a contract? Yes, if the warranty is essential to contract performance or is explicitly listed as such, it may function as a condition.

2. What does the phrase "warranty is a condition stated in the proposal" mean legally? It means a warranty outlined in the proposal is integral to the contract and may be enforceable as a condition precedent or condition of performance.

3. What happens if a warranty is breached? Typically, the remedy is limited to repair, replacement, or damages. The contract usually continues unless the breach is fundamental.

4. What’s the difference between express and implied warranties? Express warranties are explicitly stated in writing or verbally. Implied warranties are automatically included by law, such as those ensuring merchantability or fitness.

5. Should I include both warranties and conditions in my contracts? Yes. Conditions ensure core obligations are met, while warranties provide additional assurance. Clearly categorizing them avoids ambiguity and legal risk.

You can consult an attorney on UpCounsel to ensure warranty and condition clauses align with your business goals and limit future disputes.

If you need help with warranty and condition in contract law, you can post your legal job on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.