Key Takeaways

  • Trademark theft occurs when a business uses a mark (name, slogan, symbol, etc.) that causes consumer confusion with an existing mark.
  • Infringement can be both a civil and criminal offense, especially when deception is intentional.
  • Courts evaluate several factors to determine trademark infringement, including similarity, intent, and consumer perception.
  • Trademarks are protected based on their distinctiveness—fanciful and arbitrary marks get the highest protection.
  • “Trademarks of a professional robber” refers metaphorically to identifiable patterns or signs that define professional-level trademark theft.
  • Criminal trademark infringement can lead to federal charges and prison time.
  • Organized trademark thieves often engage in calculated, repetitive, and large-scale offenses, resembling professional crime.

Trademark theft is the use of a name, slogan, word, phrase, or symbol that is used in commerce by another business. This is known as infringement and is defined by the court based on the likelihood of confusion by consumers due to unauthorized use of the mark.

Trademark Protection

Intellectual property (IP) includes trademarks as well as patents, copyrights, and trade secrets. Infringing on the trademark of another business constitutes fraud because this type of misrepresentation is legally prohibited.

If you sue another business for trademark infringement, most often the court will order the defendant to stop using the mark if your claim is successful. If you have federally registered your mark, you can request that the defendant pay your attorney fees. Although the Lanham Act allows financial damages to be collected in trademark lawsuits, they are rarely actually awarded.

Defending your trademark in court can be expensive because you have the burden to prove that the mark caused market confusion that led to a loss of revenue. This may require research and expert witnesses.

Criminal Trademark Infringement and Federal Penalties

While most trademark infringement cases are civil, some instances rise to the level of criminal offenses under federal law—especially when the use is willful and done for commercial advantage. The U.S. Department of Justice can prosecute these cases under 18 U.S. Code § 2320. A conviction for criminal infringement can result in fines, forfeiture of goods, and imprisonment.

You could face federal prison time if you're found guilty of counterfeiting registered trademarks—commonly seen in high-value goods like electronics, designer clothing, or pharmaceuticals. These violations often intersect with organized crime and may be prosecuted as white-collar offenses. The penalties increase for repeat offenders or cases involving public health and safety risks.

Factors Considered by the Court

  • The court requires direct evidence of similarities that could create confusion in their actual context in the marketplace. Evidence of past confusion requires this factor to be more heavily weighted.
  • If either party plans to expand the business to compete with the other, use is more likely to be considered infringement. Expanding product lines or geographic area are both considered here.
  • If there is no plan to expand in either of these areas, this does not mean confusion will not exist.
  • The court uses the standard of a regular buyer, though buyers with specialized expertise in a specific area will be held to a higher standard. This is often true with products that are unusual, expensive, and/or highly technical. The standard of care is determined with consideration to the other factors as well.
  • The marks will be considered in their context, including how and where the products are sold and in what circumstances they would be purchased. Evidence reviewed includes advertisements, store location, and the type of businesses in question.

Trademark Theft vs. Common Theft

Trademark theft differs from robbery or burglary in a legal sense, but metaphorically, people often ask, "what are the trademarks of a professional robber?" when referring to the patterns and behaviors that define organized or repeat infringers.

Professional trademark infringers often:

  • Operate through shell corporations or international suppliers.
  • Use near-identical marks that are hard to detect without scrutiny.
  • Target high-margin markets (e.g., luxury goods, software, pharmaceuticals).
  • Launch online storefronts or use e-commerce platforms for distribution.
  • Reproduce not only the mark but also packaging and marketing to mimic legitimate brands.

These behaviors align with professional criminal theft in that they require planning, execution, and deliberate misrepresentation.

Relatedness

The concept of relatedness in this context does not mean that the products are necessarily in the same industry, but it does mean that the typical consumer could associate them with one another. Most cases fall into one of these three groups:

  • Similar marks indicate likely confusion when products are direct competitors.
  • Products that do not compete but are related require other factors to determine whether confusion may occur.
  • Confusion is unlikely when the products are not at all related. For example, one review of businesses in Minneapolis with the word Speedy in the name found services ranging from locksmiths to car washes, meaning this is unlikely to be protectable as a trademark.

Examples of Professional Infringement in Practice

Trademark infringement doesn’t always look like obvious copying. Sometimes, it’s about how closely a product or brand mirrors a competitor’s aesthetic or customer impression. Here are a few real-world examples of professional-level infringement tactics:

  • Counterfeit Electronics: Using similar names or logos like “Samsing” or “iPhoney” to sell knock-offs that closely mimic major tech brands.
  • Clothing and Fashion Brands: Replicating logos, color schemes, and stitching of designer labels to deceive consumers.
  • Pharmaceuticals: Mislabeling generic drugs with similar-sounding brand names, risking public health.
  • Franchise-style Schemes: Creating businesses that look and feel like a popular chain (e.g., similar menu, décor, and uniforms) but are unauthorized.

Courts often consider these coordinated strategies as evidence of willful and professional infringement.

Characteristics of the Mark

When considering conflicting marks, the court will look at the words themselves and their meaning as well as how they look and how they are pronounced. It will be viewed holistically and not divided into original features. It is also compared to see if it would be confusing to customers when viewed alone.

Distinctiveness

The court names the trademark that was used or registered first as the "senior trademark." The more unique this mark, the higher the level of protection available. Distinctiveness considers these factors:

  • Generic symbols or words, those that describe the product rather than its distinguishing features, are not distinctive.
  • Descriptive symbols or words are considered distinctive only if customers recognize the mark associated with the product.
  • Suggestive trademarks are considered distinctive because they require imagination to connect the words with the product.
  • Arbitrary trademarks are those that are not associated with the products they describe by a logical relationship (Apple computers, for example).
  • Fanciful trademarks are among the most distinctive. These words have no other meaning outside the use associated with the product (Xerox, for example).

Intent

If the mark was chosen by the defendant to specifically cause confusion, this alone may constitute infringement. Purposeful infringement is done to derive benefit from the trademark owner. Knowledge of the senior mark can serve as proof of intent to infringe.

What Are the Trademarks of a Professional Robber?

In the legal world, the phrase “trademarks of a professional robber” can be interpreted as patterns or methods used by those who habitually and systematically commit trademark theft. These traits include:

  • Sophistication: Use of advanced tactics like domain spoofing, SEO manipulation, or AI-generated product descriptions to enhance legitimacy.
  • Scale and Repetition: Infringement is not a one-time incident but part of a broader, repeated scheme to profit.
  • Deception as Strategy: Imitating not just logos but the entire brand experience to mislead consumers.
  • Elusiveness: Use of proxies, false addresses, and hard-to-trace online accounts to avoid detection.
  • Exploitation of Global Loopholes: Leveraging countries with weak IP enforcement to manufacture and distribute infringing goods.

These identifiers are figurative “trademarks” of a professional infringer and help distinguish isolated errors from calculated crimes.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is trademark theft?

Trademark theft is the unauthorized use of a registered or common law trademark in a way that could cause confusion for consumers.

2. Is trademark infringement a criminal offense?

Yes, in some cases. Willful infringement intended for commercial gain can result in federal criminal charges.

3. What are the trademarks of a professional robber?

This metaphor refers to the patterns used by organized or professional-level infringers—like sophistication, scale, deception, and repeat offenses.

4. Can I sue someone for using my brand name?

Yes. If the use creates confusion or damages your brand, you can file a lawsuit for trademark infringement.

5. Do I need a registered trademark to sue?

No, but federal registration gives you stronger legal standing and access to broader remedies like attorney fees and statutory damages.

If you need help with trademark theft, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.