Key Takeaways

  • A redemption agreement allows a corporation to buy back shares from a shareholder under agreed-upon terms.
  • These agreements are common in closely held corporations and are often used for succession planning or to handle triggering events like death, disability, or retirement.
  • They provide clarity on valuation, timing, and payment terms, and are typically funded by corporate funds or life insurance policies.
  • Legal oversight is crucial to avoid tax pitfalls, ensure regulatory compliance, and align with shareholder rights and fiduciary duties.

A stock redemption agreement is a contract between a corporation and the stockholder, where the corporation repurchases the stock from the owner; one of the most common buy/sell agreements. First, a buy/sell agreement comprises a contract restricting owners from transferring ownership shares in a tightly knit business. Such a contract tends to be used as a vehicle to offer an orderly and planned transfer of a business interest. The agreement can be used in the following forms:

  1. Partnership
  2. Corporation
  3. Limited liability company

Shareholders within a close corporation may wish to instill a stock redemption agreement for the following reasons:

  1. To offer business continuity if disability, death, or retirement of a member occurs
  2. To create a market for close corporate stock that would be hard to sell otherwise
  3. To make sure that ownership of the corporation remains with people that were chosen by current owners
  4. To offer liquidity to the estate of a shareholder who is deceased to compensate for a decedent’s estate costs and taxes
  5. To support the family of a deceased owner from any proceeds of the close corporate sale of the stock

Disadvantages of Buy/Sell Agreements

One of the most common disadvantages of a buy/sell agreement is the cash paid regarding premiums on the life insurance of the shareholder. The life insurance (which is usually used to fund the buy/sell agreement) is not available for payment of close corporation investment and expenses. Moreover, it issues distributions to shareholders.

The agreement also notes that shareholder stock would be sold (or offered for sale, at the very least) to other stockholders. This could also apply to the close corporation during a certain event. Such an event can come in the form of retirement, death, or disability. With that, such occurrences may also entail instances that include the following:

  1. Divorce
  2. Personal bankruptcy
  3. Incapacitation

The buy/sell contract may also be created as a right to first refuse if a shareholder wishes to sell the close corporation stock

Common Legal Risks and Pitfalls in Redemption Agreements

Redemption agreements must be carefully structured to avoid common legal risks. Poorly drafted terms can lead to disputes over valuation, taxation, and timing. Key issues include:

  • Improper valuation methods that do not reflect fair market value or lack clarity.
  • Triggering events not clearly defined, which may cause confusion or litigation.
  • Funding complications, especially when insurance proceeds are insufficient or unavailable.
  • Tax treatment missteps, where payments may be treated as dividends rather than capital gains, increasing tax liability.
  • Breach of fiduciary duty, especially if remaining shareholders use redemption to dilute other interests unfairly.

It’s highly recommended to involve legal counsel when drafting or reviewing a redemption agreement to ensure enforceability and minimize legal exposure.

Types of Agreements

You should be aware of the three types of stock buy/sell contracts:

  1. Cross-purchase contracts
  2. Hybrid agreements
  3. Redemption agreements

When to Use a Redemption Agreement

A redemption agreement is particularly useful in the following scenarios:

  • Succession planning for family-owned or closely held corporations.
  • Disputes among shareholders, where a buyout offers a clean separation.
  • Retirement or voluntary exit of a shareholder.
  • Death or disability of a shareholder, triggering a planned redemption funded by insurance.
  • Preventing third-party ownership of shares by giving the company the first right to purchase them.

Unlike cross-purchase agreements, which involve remaining shareholders buying shares, redemption agreements centralize control by keeping shares within the company.

Stock Redemptions

When it comes to stock redemptions, it benefits the shareholders because the contract essentially buys out the shareholder. The contract also allows you to detail the terms regarding the transfer or purchase of the shares. The redemption agreement usually grants a close corporation the right of first refusal if an offer from a third party exists. This is a common arrangement in many close corporations for the following reasons:

  1. For the sake of a disabled or deceased shareholder
  2. A shareholder has been terminated from the company

If you have more than two stockholders, especially when disability or life insurance is designed to fund a buy/sell agreement, such buyouts are arranged in the form of stock redemption, which is paid through corporate funds.

When the buy-out occurs, the shares are brought back into the business, but are then rendered in the unissued category. There are times when shares are known as treasury stock within the corporation. A redemption is a good way to get rid of certain shareholders in a company, while preserving ownership among the remaining stockholders. If a stock redemption contract gets funding from a life or disability insurance policy, the company would pay the premiums. In addition, the close corporation would own the policy, and the business would be the beneficiary.

Structuring a Redemption Agreement

Effective redemption agreements usually include the following elements:

  • Triggering events: Conditions under which redemption may or must occur.
  • Valuation methodology: Whether fair market value is determined via appraisal, formula, or mutual agreement.
  • Payment terms: Lump sum or installment, interest rates, and any security interest.
  • Funding source: Typically from company reserves or insurance policies.
  • Share reclassification: Clarification on whether redeemed shares are retired, reissued, or held as treasury stock.

These details help prevent ambiguity and litigation while supporting a smooth ownership transition.

Premium Costs

The costs of the premiums are divided in proportion by all shareholders. This is because the business takes responsibility for all the payments. Also, young shareholders, or those with few shares, do not have to pay large insurance premiums to cover older stockholders and other stockholders who own additional shares.

The administration of such a buy/sell contract is rendered easier because there is only a single policy for every stockholder. Moreover, the legal contract may be drafted as a single agreement. Stock redemption payments that deal with non-liquidated corporate distributions could result in taxable divides for a shareholder recipient.

This could happen if a transaction does not qualify as a properly sold stock, according to IRS guidelines. With that, if shareholders retain a large amount of capital losses from other business transactions, the sale treatment is the ideal solution. The capital losses can then be a method of offsetting the capital gain that’s triggered by a transaction involving stock redemption.

Importance of Legal Counsel in Redemption Agreements

Having an attorney involved in drafting or reviewing a redemption agreement is crucial for the following reasons:

  • Tax Compliance: To ensure the transaction qualifies as a sale rather than a dividend distribution under IRS rules.
  • Regulatory Alignment: Particularly if the company is subject to SEC regulations or state-specific statutes.
  • Conflict Mitigation: Avoids vague provisions that could spark shareholder disputes.
  • Fiduciary Duty: Ensures that directors are meeting their obligations when authorizing redemptions.
  • Documentation: Guarantees that board resolutions, consents, and corporate formalities are properly executed.

Legal professionals can also help tailor redemption terms to the business’s long-term strategic goals, especially during restructuring, succession planning, or investor exits.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a redemption agreement?
    A redemption agreement is a contract in which a corporation agrees to repurchase shares from one of its shareholders under specific conditions.
  2. How is a redemption agreement different from a cross-purchase agreement?
    In a redemption agreement, the company buys back the shares; in a cross-purchase agreement, the remaining shareholders buy them.
  3. What triggers a redemption agreement?
    Common triggers include death, disability, retirement, shareholder disputes, or voluntary sale of shares.
  4. How is the price determined in a redemption agreement?
    Valuation can be based on fair market value, a fixed price, a formula, or third-party appraisal, depending on the agreement terms.
  5. Are there tax implications for redemption agreements?
    Yes. If not structured properly, proceeds may be taxed as dividends rather than capital gains. Legal and tax guidance is essential.

To learn more about a stock redemption agreement, you can post your job on UpCounsel’s marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.