Key Takeaways:

  • Definition & Purpose: The statute of limitations sets a time limit on legal actions to ensure timely prosecution and fair trials.
  • Variability by Case Type: Different statutes apply to civil and criminal cases, with serious crimes like murder having no time limit.
  • Legal Defense: Defendants can use the statute of limitations as a defense if a case is filed after the allowable period.
  • Tolling the Statute: Certain actions, like fleeing the jurisdiction, can pause or restart the statute.
  • Exceptions & Special Cases: Some crimes, such as sexual offenses involving minors and violent felonies, have no statute of limitations.
  • Consumer Debt & Financial Claims: Debt collection and financial claims are often subject to specific statutory limitations.
  • State-by-State Differences: Statutes vary by state, with some extending limits under unique circumstances.
  • Federal vs. State Statutes: Federal crimes often have different statutes of limitations than state-level offenses.

A statute of limitations is a law that creates a period of time in which a person can be legally charged with a crime. Different crimes fall under different statutes, but this prevents someone from being charged with a crime that allegedly took place over 50 years ago, depending on the type of crime.

What Is a Statute of Limitations?

Found in the laws of ancient Rome, statutes of limitations are a basic part of the legal systems of the United States and the world. Prosecutors have always been limited in when and how they are able to bring cases against citizens, keeping the legal system in check.

This doesn't mean that you can get away with murder if you just stay under the radar for 20 years. More serious crimes have a much longer statute of limitations than minor offenses. For instance, an individual can only sue another party for breach of contract for so long, and eventually, the window of opportunity will close.

Both civil and criminal cases are subject to statutes of limitations, but they differ significantly. The time period for taking legal action begins either on the discovery date or the date of injury, depending on the offense. For instance, if someone is injured at work, they have a set period to sue their employer, starting from the date of the accident.

As a Defense

The defendant in a legal action will typically use a statute of limitations as a primary defense to argue that a case was brought against them beyond a reasonable time period. This defense needs to be used during the beginning of the case when the defendant first answers the complaint of the plaintiff. If the statute of limitations is not brought up at that point, the defendant cannot try to use it later during the case.

Tolling the Statute of Limitations

In some cases, the statute of limitations may be "tolled" or paused, effectively extending the period in which a case can be filed. Tolling typically occurs under the following conditions:

  • The Defendant Leaves the Jurisdiction: If a person accused of a crime leaves the state or country, the statute may pause until they return.
  • Discovery Rule: In cases where harm is not immediately apparent, such as medical malpractice or toxic exposure, the statute starts when the injury is discovered.
  • Minors and Incapacitated Individuals: If the injured party is a minor or legally incapacitated at the time of the event, the statute may not start until they reach adulthood or recover capacity.

These exceptions prevent individuals from escaping liability due to technical time constraints.

Why Statute of Limitations?

Statutes of limitations are meant to protect the credibility of evidence. Most types of evidence deteriorate over time. Eyewitnesses remember things less clearly, DNA samples are less available, and documents are harder to find. Once the statute of limitations has run its course, the offender can no longer be brought to court and is therefore free.

Criminals are usually required to remain visible in some ways in order to be protected under a statute of limitations. The idea is that they are out in the open and able to be caught and prosecuted for their crime. If they are working in the public workforce and living in the state where they committed the crime, they are not hiding from the authorities. So, if they aren't tried for the crime during an ample period of time, the state loses its opportunity for justice.

Society operates under the belief that, if a criminal is out in the open for a specific period of time and the authorities don't catch them, then they deserve to be free from possible prosecution.

Criminals that flee the place of the crime, leaving the state or country, forego this protection under the statute. If they move back to the state, the period of time under the statute restarts. Say a crime is committed in New York in 1980, with a statute of limitations of 20 years. If the criminal leaves the state months after the crime, but then returns to New York in 2001, they are not considered free from prosecution. The statute wasn't running while they were out of state, so the clock starts when they reenter the state. This is called tolling the statute.

Statute of Limitations for Financial and Debt Claims

In addition to criminal and civil cases, statutes of limitations also apply to financial matters, such as debt collection and consumer rights:

  • Debt Collection: Credit card debt, personal loans, and medical bills are subject to statutes that range from 3 to 10 years, depending on state law.
  • Tax Debts: The IRS generally has a ten-year limit to collect unpaid taxes.
  • Securities Fraud: Cases related to securities violations typically have a 5-year statute under federal law.
  • Bankruptcy Filings: Certain debts discharged in bankruptcy may still have legal limitations on collection attempts.

Consumers should be aware that creditors may still attempt to collect "time-barred" debts, but legal action may not be enforceable after the statute expires.

Types of Cases and Their Statutes of Limitations

The statute of limitations varies based on the type of case, broadly categorized into civil and criminal statutes:

  • Civil Cases: These include contract disputes, personal injury claims, property damage, and defamation. Depending on the state, personal injury claims typically have a statute of limitations of 2-3 years, while breach of contract cases can range from 3 to 10 years.
  • Criminal Cases: Lesser offenses like misdemeanors may have a statute of limitations of 1-2 years, while felonies often have longer statutes or no time limit at all.
  • Federal vs. State Laws: Federal crimes generally follow different statutes than state-level offenses. For example, tax evasion has a six-year statute under federal law, while wire fraud can have a ten-year limit.

The time limit is crucial in ensuring evidence remains reliable and cases are filed within a reasonable period.

Crimes With No Statute

There are some crimes that are not covered by a statute of limitations. Offenders of the following crimes can be tried after any amount of time has passed since the illegal action:

  • Sexual offense including a minor
  • Arson
  • Violent crimes
  • Kidnappings
  • Forgery

Certain crimes have statutes in some states and not in others, for instance, treason has no statute in the state of Colorado.

Classification systems are used in most states to group felonies into certain categories regarding statutes of limitations and jail time. Class A felonies, usually including crimes like murder, which result in some kind of prison sentence have no statute of limitation. Misdemeanors, like trespassing and disorderly conduct, usually have a statute of about two years. Small claims, like patent infringement, usually have a statute of two to five years.

State-by-State Variations in Statute of Limitations

While federal law establishes specific statutes for certain crimes, each state has its own laws governing time limits for civil and criminal cases. For example:

  • California: No statute for murder, 10 years for certain fraud crimes, and 2 years for personal injury cases.
  • New York: No statute for Class A felonies, 6 years for breach of contract, and 3 years for medical malpractice.
  • Texas: No statute for sexual assault of a minor, 4 years for fraud, and 2 years for defamation.

Understanding these variations is crucial, especially for individuals pursuing legal claims across state lines.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What happens if a case is filed after the statute of limitations expires?
    If a case is filed beyond the statute of limitations, the defendant can request a dismissal, and courts typically reject the claim.
  2. Can the statute of limitations be extended?
    Yes, under certain conditions like tolling for fleeing suspects or delayed discovery of harm.
  3. Are there crimes that have no statute of limitations?
    Yes, serious crimes like murder, certain violent felonies, and sexual offenses involving minors often have no time limit.
  4. How does the statute of limitations affect debt collection?
    Creditors cannot sue after the statute expires, but they may still attempt to collect the debt informally.
  5. Do statutes of limitations differ between states?
    Yes, statutes vary widely by state, with different limits for civil, criminal, and financial cases.

If you need help with a statute of limitations, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.