Key Takeaways

  • Shareholder withdrawal refers to when a shareholder exits a company by either transferring or redeeming their shares.
  • Buyout agreements and clauses in withdrawal agreements provide structured methods for managing a shareholder's exit.
  • Additional clauses include the Right of First Refusal, Shotgun Clauses, and Insurance Clauses, ensuring smooth transitions and appropriate compensation.
  • Legal procedures help avoid conflicts during the transfer of shares, especially in smaller corporations or cases of shareholder disputes.

Transferring Shares

Shareholders collectively own the corporation. Their common stock has three essential rights:

  • The right to vote to elect members to the board of directors at the annual general assembly
  • The right to receive a portion of the company's dividends, if applicable
  • The right to receive a percentage of the company's liquidated assets, if the company dissolves.

A board of directors manages a corporation and acts on behalf of the corporation's shareholders. Though shareholders own stock in the company, if they don't hold the title of officer, director, or company employee, they don't have legal authority to take part in the day-to-day management of the company.

Shareholders may therefore leave a corporation without interrupting company operations. The shares are simply transferred to a new owner, whose information is taken down in the corporation's stock ledger.

Shareholder Withdrawal Process

When a shareholder decides to withdraw, the process typically involves surrendering their share certificates (receipts) to the company. This formal action signals the termination of their ownership in the company. The company may compensate the withdrawing shareholder with cash or another agreed-upon consideration. The exact process can vary depending on the terms laid out in the shareholder’s agreement or company bylaws. This withdrawal process helps the company maintain clear records of ownership and enables shareholders to liquidate their interest in a structured manner.

Buyout Agreements

Corporation owners are able to control the transfer of shares by putting provisions in place in the corporation's bylaws or by facilitating a separate buyout agreement. Common restrictions on share transfers are stipulations requiring that shareholders sell shares back internally to the corporation or to another shareholder.

To better facilitate share transfer, buyout agreements usually entail how much interest the withdrawing shareholder should be paid. Adding this detail means that the ownership transfer can be completed simply by carrying out a stock purchase agreement and recording the details of the exchange in the corporation's stock ledger.

However, ownership transfer can be complicated for various reasons. Smaller corporations may have few shareholders, each playing a pivotal role in the business. If an important shareholder leaves the corporation, it could leave a hole in the management structure of the corporation that can't be replaced by simply selling shares to a new shareowner.

If the shareholders haven't put a buyout agreement in place, disagreements could arise about how much interest the withdrawing shareholder should be paid. If they can't come to an agreement among themselves, shareholders may need to have a business valuation conducted by an outside party.

Additional Buyout Agreement Clauses

A shareholder buyout agreement often includes several clauses designed to protect the interests of both the withdrawing shareholder and the remaining stakeholders. Common clauses include:

  • Right of First Refusal (ROFR): This clause grants existing shareholders or the company itself the first option to purchase the withdrawing shareholder’s shares before they can be sold to outsiders.
  • Shotgun Clause: A type of buy-sell agreement where a shareholder can offer to sell their shares to the other shareholders, and if they decline, they must purchase the offering shareholder’s shares at the same price.
  • Insurance Clause: Typically paired with buy-sell clauses, this provides for the purchase of shares in the event of a shareholder's death, ensuring liquidity.
  • Mandatory Offer: This clause mandates that if a shareholder decides to sell their shares, they must first offer them to the remaining shareholders or the company, ensuring that ownership stays within the company.

Clauses in a Shareholder Withdrawal Agreement

A shareholder withdrawal agreement has specific clauses to ensure the smooth transition of the shareholder out of the company.

Right of First Refusal: Under this clause, the shareholder withdrawing from the company must offer shares to associates in the company before offering to sell them to third parties. This clause exists to retain a proportionate amount of shares within the company, essential in maintaining the company's private status.

Mandatory Offer: This offer happens when the shares offered for sale do not depend on the desire of the bidder. This clause exists for the protection of the bidder's associates, even when the bidder doesn't intend to sell their shares.

Shotgun clause: Also called a buy-and-sell clause. Similar to the right of first refusal, this clause states that a shareholder must first offer their shares for sale to associates in company. If the associates aren't interested in buying these shares, they are obligated to offer their shares up to the bidder under the same conditions and at the same price.

Evaluation clause: This clause's function is to set the price of the actions. Regardless of whether the sale is voluntary or due to a death, this clause evaluates the fairest price. There are many different evaluation techniques including:

  • Set market value.
  • Performance value.
  • Agreed value.
  • Value determined by a third party.

Insurance clause: An insurance clause almost always accompanies a buy-and-sell clause, which states that the shares will be automatically purchased in the case of a shareholder's death.

Company purchase clause: If a shareholder needs to sell his shares to the company, the buy-and-sell agreement may stipulate that the withdrawing shareholder's shares be purchased by the company rather than the shareholder's associates.

The shares, when sold to other shareholders, provide a capital gain. If sold to the company, the shares provide the seller with taxable dividends.

Penal Clause: The penal clause helps simplify shareholder appeals by imposing penalties for shareholders who infringe on the agreement. The penal clause sets the penalty amount. It can also lower the price of shares of the shareholder who infringed on the agreement and force that shareholder to put their shares up for sale to other shareholders.

Vote clauses: These clauses exist to stop minority shareholders from having a say in the company's administrative decisions.

Administration clauses: These clauses define the parameters of administration, operations, and company financing to prevent majority shareholders from setting minority shareholders aside.

Legal and Financial Considerations

The financial and legal implications of a shareholder withdrawal are significant and must be handled carefully to avoid disputes.

  • Valuation of Shares: The price of the shares being transferred or sold must be agreed upon. Common methods of valuation include using the company's market value, performance metrics, or an independent appraisal.
  • Tax Implications: Both the corporation and the withdrawing shareholder must be aware of potential tax consequences, such as capital gains tax or dividend taxation, which may apply depending on how shares are transferred or sold.
  • Company Bylaws and State Laws: It is crucial to review the company’s bylaws and any state-specific laws governing shareholder withdrawal, as these may affect the terms of the withdrawal process.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What happens when a shareholder decides to withdraw from a company?
    When a shareholder withdraws, they typically surrender their share certificates to the company, which cancels their shares. The shareholder may receive compensation based on an agreed value or other forms of consideration.
  2. What is a buyout agreement, and why is it important?
    A buyout agreement sets the terms for how shares will be sold or transferred when a shareholder decides to leave or when specific events occur, such as death or bankruptcy. It ensures fairness and avoids conflicts among shareholders.
  3. How does the Right of First Refusal (ROFR) work in a shareholder withdrawal?
    ROFR gives the remaining shareholders or the company the first opportunity to buy shares that a withdrawing shareholder wants to sell, ensuring control over who holds ownership.
  4. What are the common clauses in a shareholder withdrawal agreement?
    Key clauses include the Right of First Refusal, Shotgun Clause, Insurance Clause, and Mandatory Offer, all designed to manage the shareholder's exit smoothly and protect remaining shareholders.
  5. Are there tax implications when a shareholder withdraws?
    Yes, the withdrawal can trigger capital gains taxes or dividend taxes, depending on how the shares are transferred or sold. It's essential to consult with a tax advisor to understand the full financial impact.

If you need help with a shareholder withdrawal, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.