Key Takeaways

  • Shareholder rights in a private company vary based on stock class, state law, and internal agreements like shareholder or operating agreements.
  • Minority shareholders in private corporations are protected against majority abuse through fiduciary duties, access to information, and legal remedies.
  • Shareholders may have appraisal rights, preemptive rights, and derivative rights depending on the company’s bylaws and state regulations.
  • Private companies must comply with obligations like holding shareholder meetings, allowing inspection of books, and disclosing major changes.
  • Disputes often arise around stock dilution, denied dividends, or unfair treatment, especially in closely held corporations.

Shareholder rights in a private corporation depend on several factors, including the classes of stock offered by the company. For instance, the owners of preferred stock will typically have more rights than shareholders that own common stock.

Stock Ownership Rights and Protections

When you purchase corporate stock, the stock that you own comes with certain rights. Corporations are different from other business entities, such as partnerships, in that a corporation's owners do not participate in operating the company. A corporation's shareholders have protection from the liabilities of the company, meaning their personal assets will not be at risk if the corporation is ever sued. The primary exception to this lack of liability is if a shareholder has personally guaranteed a corporate debt.

The drawback of stock ownership is that if the corporation fails, you can lose your investment. Most corporations in the United States last for only seven years, and many corporations fail even sooner.

Minority Shareholder Protections

Minority shareholders in private companies often lack the power to influence decisions, making legal protections vital. These protections help ensure fair treatment and prevent oppression by majority owners. Common safeguards include:

  • Fiduciary Duties: Controlling shareholders and directors owe fiduciary duties to minority shareholders. Breaching these duties—such as through self-dealing or denying dividends unfairly—may give rise to legal claims.
  • Access to Information: State laws and corporate bylaws often guarantee the right to review financial records, shareholder lists, and board meeting minutes, even for minority stakeholders.
  • Oppression Claims: If minority shareholders are “frozen out” or their interests are disregarded, they may sue under claims of shareholder oppression or breach of duty.
  • Appraisal Rights: In certain mergers or asset sales, shareholders who dissent have the right to demand a judicial appraisal of their shares.
  • Buy-Sell Agreements: These may include provisions to protect minority interests by requiring fair buyout terms if a shareholder exits or is removed​​.

Levels of Shareholder Ownership Rights

Purchasing stocks and becoming a corporate shareholder provides several privileges. It's important to remember, however, that there are different levels of shareholder rights. Corporations offer three different securities classes, each of which comes with specific rights:

  • Bonds
  • Common stock
  • Preferred stock

You can understand the hierarchy of these classes by examining what happens when a company declares bankruptcy. Understandably, many people assume that common shareholders would be first in line to collect payment when a company goes bankrupt. In reality, the complete opposite is true, and the owners of common stock are last in line to get paid during the liquidation of a corporation. When a company declares bankruptcy, creditors take priority, meaning they will be the first paid from the company's liquidated assets. Next in line is bondholders, then preferred shareholders, and finally owners of common stock.

Absolute priority is what determines the hierarchy of these different classes of security. Essentially, these bankruptcy rules determine which party gets paid first and how much they will receive. Absolute priority is one of the many different rights that exist between these security classes.

For example, in most corporations, voting privileges are reserved for common shareholders. On the other hand, preferred shareholders take precedence when it comes to paying dividends. Bondholder rights are different from shareholder rights, as a bond represents a contract between the party that issued the bond and the bond owner. This contract determines the rights of a bondholder.

Some general rights enjoyed by shareholders include:

  • Voting rights on important corporate issues.
  • Rights to a corporation's assets.
  • Rights to transfer stock.
  • Rights to dividends.
  • Rights to examine corporate books.

Corporations are generally required to hold an annual shareholders meeting. During this meeting, the shareholders can appoint a board of directors and may also vote on corporate issues. Some people in the corporation have the ability to call a special meeting on urgent issues. During this meeting, only the special issue can be voted on. No other issues may be raised.

Shareholders also have the right to inspect a corporation's voting list whenever they wish. Also, shareholders can appoint a proxy vote if they are unable to attend a shareholders meeting in person. States will generally have rules about how proxy appointments can occur and when they can be revoked.

The person appointed as a proxy must follow the directions of the shareholder, meaning they will need to vote according to the shareholder's wishes. Shareholders can also decide to conduct business without holding a meaning through a unanimous vote. Running a corporation without holding shareholders meetings is more common with closely held corporations.

In a public corporation, it would be extremely difficult to obtain unanimous consent, as there will be many more shareholders, all of whom will have their own interest. In states such as California, shareholders meetings do not need to take place in person and can take place via conference call as long as all shareholders on the call have the opportunity to speak and cast their vote. In general, a corporation has the ability to issue new stock shares whenever it wishes. When new shares are issued, existing stockholders' ownership will be diluted.

Shareholder Agreements and Custom Rights

Private companies often rely on shareholder agreements to customize and clarify rights and obligations not addressed by law or bylaws. These agreements can:

  • Define who may serve on the board of directors.
  • Establish veto powers for major decisions (e.g., mergers, acquisitions, issuing new shares).
  • Set rules for selling or transferring shares, including rights of first refusal.
  • Include anti-dilution clauses to protect ownership percentages during future stock issuances.

In closely held corporations, shareholder agreements may serve a similar function as operating agreements in LLCs, creating a roadmap for internal governance and resolving disputes.

Legal Remedies for Shareholder Disputes

When disputes arise—especially in private corporations where transparency is limited—shareholders may need to seek legal remedies, including:

  • Derivative Lawsuits: Shareholders can sue on behalf of the company if directors or officers act unlawfully or harm the corporation.
  • Direct Actions: If a shareholder's personal rights are violated (e.g., being denied a rightful dividend), they may file a direct lawsuit.
  • Demand for Inspection: Shareholders may legally compel the company to provide access to books and records.
  • Judicial Dissolution: In severe cases, such as persistent abuse or deadlock among shareholders, courts may order the corporation to dissolve.

These legal tools help ensure accountability and protect shareholder investments​.

Preemptive and Voting Rights

Some private corporations grant preemptive rights—the right for shareholders to purchase newly issued shares before outsiders. This helps protect against ownership dilution.

In addition to voting on director elections, private shareholders may vote on:

  • Fundamental changes like mergers or asset sales.
  • Amendments to bylaws or articles of incorporation.
  • Approval of major financial decisions, depending on company structure.

The specific scope of voting rights depends on state law and the company’s governing documents.

Shareholder Meeting Requirements and Proxies

While shareholder meetings are required, the format and frequency can vary significantly in private companies. Key points include:

  • Annual Meetings: Required in most states, even for private companies, to elect directors and discuss corporate matters.
  • Special Meetings: May be called by directors, officers, or a qualifying percentage of shareholders to address urgent matters.
  • Proxy Voting: Shareholders can appoint a proxy to vote on their behalf, and this right is protected under state laws.
  • Written Consent: In small private companies, unanimous written consent can replace formal meetings.

State law governs the notice period, quorum requirements, and procedures for these meetings​.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What rights do shareholders have in a private company?
    Shareholders may have voting rights, dividend entitlements, inspection rights, and the ability to sue in cases of mismanagement or breach of duty.
  • Are minority shareholders protected in private companies?
    Yes. Protections include fiduciary duties, access to information, appraisal rights, and the ability to file oppression or derivative lawsuits.
  • Can a private company issue more shares without shareholder approval?
    It depends on state law and the company’s governing documents. Some require shareholder consent, especially if preemptive rights exist.
  • What is a shareholder agreement, and is it required?
    A shareholder agreement outlines rights and responsibilities among shareholders. While not legally required, it’s highly recommended for private companies.
  • How do shareholders resolve disputes with the company?
    Disputes can be resolved through internal procedures, legal claims like derivative lawsuits, or even judicial dissolution in severe cases.

If you need help understanding shareholder rights in a private company, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.