Key Takeaways

  • S corporation stock sales must be properly recorded in the corporate stock ledger and reported via Schedule K-1s and Schedule D.
  • The buyer’s stock basis is based on the fair market value of property exchanged or purchase price.
  • Transactions must ensure the S corporation remains within IRS compliance, such as not exceeding 100 shareholders.
  • The sale can occur as a stock sale or asset sale, with significant tax consequences depending on structure.
  • Elections under IRC Sec. 338(h)(10) or 336(e) may apply in qualifying transactions and affect tax outcomes.
  • Rollovers of shares in corporate acquisitions must be planned carefully to avoid unintended termination of S status or unequal tax burdens.

The sale of S corp stock happens whenever a shareholder hands off stock by swapping it for material goods or a documented contract to disburse the holder later in life.

An S corporation is a venture with about 100 shareholders or less that is taxed as a partnership even though they share the corporation's liability protection. Based on the number of shares they own, the holders add a certain fraction of the corporation's expenses and profits on their individual tax return. 

The S corporation has the duty of keeping the track of the person that owns its shares since the corporation makes sure that the number of shareholders does not exceed 100 percent.

How to Record an S Corporation Stock Sale

Step 1

The first step is to revise the stock ledger of the S corporation to reflect the new ownership. A stock ledger has the information of anyone that possesses the shares of an S corporation. Even though the ledger could apply for its specific entries, the ledger must itemize the current owner's designation, information about the trade, and individual that assigned the stock. The latest owner's contact data, phone numbers and the address details must be integrated. 

Step 2

The next step is to give out K-1s to the new and former shareholder. The S corporation deals out the K-1 along with the information of all the proceeds and losses that a holder must take account of on his personal tax return. Before the commencement of the sale, the previous shareholder is required to incorporate all income and losses accrued by the S corporation. Also, after selling the stock, the new shareholder must enter all income and losses accumulated by the S corporation.

Step 3

The current shareholder must make a note of the property value he gives up to acquire the stock. The amount the current holder pays for the shares is the worth of his base in the S corporation stock. This foundation will be utilized to determine the amount of tax payable by the new shareholder when he sells his future shares. The sum the current shareholder must keep is the market value of the exchanged property or the amount he could acquire for the possessions in the course of selling them for cash as of the day of the sale.

Step 4

The selling shareholder should finalize and record a Schedule D tax form that details any stock's gains or losses. When the shares are traded at a worth greater than the basis of the holder's stock in the S corporation, a document must show the capital gain that can be taxed.

If the value of the shares sold is less than the source of the shareholder, a loss of capital will arise. The Schedule D consists of a shareholder's capital gains and losses in the course of the time to establish what tax he will need to recompense on those dealings. By and large, any long-term gain amassed from assets held longer than a year is taxed at a rate of 15 percent.

Legal and Tax Structure of the Sale

When a shareholder sells S corporation stock to another shareholder, it’s critical to determine whether the transaction is structured as a stock sale or an asset sale. Each carries different legal and tax implications:

  • Stock Sale: The buyer acquires the shareholder’s interest directly. The S corporation continues uninterrupted, and the new shareholder steps into ownership with a new basis. This is common when the business entity and contracts are to remain unchanged.
  • Asset Sale: The corporation sells its assets to a buyer, and proceeds are distributed to shareholders. This can create double taxation: once at the corporate level (if the S status is lost or invalid) and again at the shareholder level upon distribution.

Buyers and sellers must consider liabilities, contract assignments, goodwill, and the treatment of intangible assets in both structures.

IRC Section 338(h)(10) and 336(e) Elections

In certain qualifying transactions—typically where a corporation sells its stock as part of a broader acquisition—S corporations may benefit from electing special tax treatments under:

  • IRC Section 338(h)(10): Allows a stock sale to be treated as an asset sale for tax purposes. Available when an S corp subsidiary is sold as part of a transaction with a corporate buyer that acquires at least 80% of the stock.
  • IRC Section 336(e): Provides similar treatment to the 338(h)(10) election, but is used when an individual or non-corporate shareholder sells their stock and elects to treat it as if the corporation sold its assets.

These elections can provide tax planning opportunities but require IRS filings and alignment with buyer/seller objectives.

Risks of Inadvertent Termination of S Corporation Status

A sale of S corporation stock to another shareholder must preserve the S corporation's eligibility under IRS rules. Some actions that can inadvertently terminate S corp status include:

  • Exceeding the 100-shareholder limit
  • Allowing an ineligible shareholder, such as a non-resident alien or a partnership, to acquire shares
  • Creating a second class of stock, which can occur if special rights or preferences are granted to the buyer

If S corp status is terminated, the business becomes a C corporation and loses pass-through taxation benefits. Shareholders may then face double taxation and added compliance requirements.

S Corporation: Cut-Off vs. Pro Rata Year End

A lot of taxpayers understand that the code of tax is occasionally imbalanced and quite complex. Taxpayers are ignorant of the possible downsides and concrete factors that can befall the innocent. 

Usually, an S corporation is an entity that flows 100 percent of its income, loss or gains to its shareholders on the basis of a share owned. Then, the shareholders pay the tax on their personal return, and an S corporation can normally distribute the amount of income reported to the shareholder tax-free. 

The following instance is a consideration of an S corporation that made $10,000 in a year:

  • The shareholder will get the report of this $10,000 and then get taxed on their Form 1040, which is their personal return.
  • The S corporation now acquired $10,000 of extra cash in its bank deposit.
  • The S corporation can distribute the $10,000 to the shareholder and the shareholder will not pay tax on the $10,000 again since the money will be taxed at the level of the shareholder.

Cut-Off vs. Pro Rata Allocation Methods Explained

When S corporation stock is sold during the tax year, the IRS allows two methods to allocate income and loss between the buyer and seller:

  1. Pro Rata Allocation: Splits income/loss based on the number of days each party owns the stock within the tax year. This is the default method.
  2. Cut-Off Method: Allows the corporation to close its books on the day of the sale, allocating income and loss based on actual operations before and after the transfer.

To use the cut-off method, all affected shareholders must consent, and it must be documented accordingly. This method can more accurately reflect operational activity, especially when ownership changes mid-year due to a significant transaction.

Shareholder Rollover Considerations in M&A

In mergers and acquisitions, a selling shareholder may "roll over" a portion of their S corp shares into equity of the acquiring company. This often happens when the acquiring entity offers stock instead of cash for part of the transaction.

Key considerations include:

  • Valuation of rollover equity
  • Maintaining single class of stock in the S corporation to avoid IRS violations
  • Unexpected tax outcomes, such as triggering capital gains on the rolled-over shares if not handled properly

Proper tax structuring and legal planning are essential to avoid disqualifying the S election or creating unanticipated income recognition for the shareholder​.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an S corporation have foreign shareholders after a stock sale? No. Only U.S. citizens or resident individuals can be shareholders of an S corporation. Foreign ownership will terminate the S status.

What happens to my K-1 if I sell my S corporation shares mid-year? The S corporation will issue two K-1s—one for the seller covering their ownership period and another for the buyer, based on either pro rata or cut-off allocation.

Do I have to report a gain if I received stock instead of cash? Yes, potentially. If the transaction doesn't qualify as a tax-deferred exchange (such as under Section 351), the IRS may treat it as a taxable event.

How does goodwill factor into a sale of S corporation stock? In a stock sale, goodwill typically stays with the corporation. However, in an asset sale, goodwill may be transferred and amortized by the buyer, which can impact the tax outcome.

Can an S corp issue preferred stock during or after a sale? No. S-corporations can only have one class of stock. Issuing preferred stock would violate this rule and terminate S corp status.

If you need help with the sale of S corporation stock, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.