Revocation of Acceptance Cases in Contract Law

Key Takeaways

• Revocation of acceptance allows a buyer to cancel acceptance of goods if they fail to conform to the contract.
• Under UCC § 2-608 and § 2A-517, revocation must meet certain timing and condition standards.
• Buyers must show substantial impairment and act within a reasonable time.
• Courts examine buyer conduct, notice to the seller, and available remedies in revocation of acceptance cases.
• Lease agreements, like sales contracts, allow revocation under UCC Article 2A.
• The concept of revocation of acceptance is distinct from rejection and is subject to stricter rules.

Revocation cases involve canceling or annulling something that has been given to another person, including a contract or an offer.

Introduction to Revocation

Revocation can come in a variety of forms, and revocation cases can involve both criminal and civil issues.

You can find many examples of revocation, including:

• An offer being withdrawn.
• A military member having their privileges removed.
• A person losing their right to a driver's license.

Even if you want to revoke something that you have granted to another person, your ability to do so will depend on many different factors. A revocation can either be implied or expressed. When expressly revoking a will, for example, the revocation should as formal as the will, if not more so. This rule may not apply depending on the state where the revocation takes place. Under English law, implied revocations occur when a child is born or when a marriage takes place.

Revocation Definitions

When the term revocation is used in contract law, it can mean that a contract has been terminated or that an offer has been withdrawn.

When an offer has been made, the offeree has the power to accept the offer. If acceptance occurred, the person who made the offer must perform their duties. The offeror, however, has the legally ability to revoke the offer at any time before it has been accepted. Revoking an offer usually occurs when the offeree takes too long to consider the offer or sends a counteroffer that includes terms not acceptable to the offeror.

Revocation can only take place before acceptance. If acceptance occurs, the offer is now a legally binding agreement. Buyers can also use revocation as a legal remedy if the item that they purchased does not match what was described in the contract. When a buyer receives goods that do not conform to the contract they signed, they can either reject the goods or revoke their acceptance. The buyer must show that the goods do not match the contract before they will be allowed to revoke acceptance.

Several methods are available for terminating an offer. First, the termination can be communicated to the offeree either indirectly or directly. Second, the offer can be revoked by publication. Unlike other forms of communication, revocation will occur as soon as the notice is published and not when the offeree is alerted to the revocation.

Many people don't realize that having a driver's license is a privilege and not a right. Because of this, a person's driver's license could be suspended or even revoked in many circumstances. While the revocation of a driver's license is usually the result of an illegal act by the driver, actually revoking the license may take place separately from criminal proceedings.

The Department of Motor Vehicles in every state will have individual guidelines for revoking a license. In every state, a driver's license can be revoked if a person is convicted of DUI multiple times or accrues too many violations or traffic ticket points on their license. If a person's license is suspended and they are caught driving, revocation of their license may be the consequence.

Several violations can result in a revoked driver's license, including:

• Driving recklessly.
• Racing a vehicle.
• Fleeing an accident scene.
• Ignoring a traffic summons.

Some offenses not related to driving can cause a person's license to be revoked, such as:

• Ignoring a court order for child support.
• Being convicted of a drug offense.
• Altering license plates/registration stickers.

Power of attorney can also be revoked in many circumstances. When a person grants Power of Attorney, it means they are allowing someone else to make certain decisions on their behalf. Power of Attorney can be very broad or can be limited to a single responsibility. In either case, Power of Attorney must be granted in writing, and the document granting these powers must be signed in front of witnesses. Wills can be revoked when a new will is written that contradicts the terms of a previous will or when an old will is destroyed.

Once Power of Attorney has been granted, it can be revoked whenever the grantor wants, as long as they are determined legally competent. Revoking Power of Attorney must also take place in writing and a signature will again need to be witnessed.

Available Remedies After Revocation of Acceptance

When revocation is successful, buyers may pursue remedies such as:

• Refund of the purchase price
• Damages for incidental and consequential losses
• Recovery of costs related to transporting or disposing of nonconforming goods

However, the seller may be entitled to an offset for the buyer’s use of the goods or deterioration not related to the defect.

Legal outcomes often hinge on the clarity of the contract, documented communications, and the extent of the nonconformity. Buyers and lessees considering revocation of acceptance are encouraged to consult a qualified attorney to evaluate their position. You can find experienced contract attorneys through UpCounsel’s network.

Real-World Case Example: Horwitz v. Sonnenschein

In Horwitz v. Sonnenschein Nath & Rosenthal LLP, the Illinois Supreme Court clarified revocation of acceptance under state-adopted UCC provisions. The case involved a buyer seeking to revoke acceptance of a dental practice due to misrepresentations and nonconforming conditions.

The Court emphasized that:

• Even partial use of the subject matter does not preclude revocation.
• The buyer’s reliance on seller assurances can justify delayed revocation.
• The standard of "substantial impairment" remains pivotal.

This case illustrates the nuanced balancing courts undertake in revocation of acceptance disputes and underscores the importance of documenting defects and communications with the seller.

Revocation vs. Rejection

Revocation of acceptance is distinct from rejection. While rejection occurs before the buyer accepts the goods, revocation occurs after acceptance has taken place.

Understanding this distinction is crucial for determining available legal remedies and procedures.

Legal Standards in Revocation of Acceptance Cases

Courts reviewing revocation of acceptance cases focus on several key legal standards:

• Substantial Impairment: The defect must meaningfully diminish the item's value to the buyer.
• Reasonable Time: Courts evaluate how long the buyer waited to revoke acceptance after discovering the defect.
• Notice Requirement: Timely and specific notice to the seller is critical for valid revocation.
• Buyer Conduct: Continued use of the goods may signal waiver of the right to revoke.

For example, if a buyer continues to use a defective product extensively or attempts to resell it, courts may infer that revocation is improper. However, limited use to mitigate damages or test the product may be permissible.

Revocation of Acceptance Under the UCC

In the context of sales and lease contracts governed by the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), revocation of acceptance refers to a buyer’s right to rescind acceptance of goods that fail to conform to the agreed terms. This legal remedy is primarily governed by UCC § 2-608 for sales and § 2A-517 for leases.

Buyers may revoke their acceptance when:

• The nonconformity of the goods substantially impairs their value.
• The impairment was not discovered before acceptance, or the buyer accepted under the assumption that the issue would be cured.

Revocation must occur within a reasonable time after the buyer discovers or should have discovered the defect. The buyer must also notify the seller. Failure to comply with these requirements may bar revocation.

For leases, UCC § 2A-517 provides similar protections to lessees when the goods do not conform to the lease contract. Lessees may revoke acceptance if the nonconformity substantially impairs the value and was not initially apparent.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is revocation of acceptance? It is a buyer’s legal right to cancel their acceptance of goods that fail to conform to the contract, under certain conditions outlined in the UCC.

2. How is revocation different from rejection? Rejection occurs before accepting goods, while revocation happens afterward and requires a substantial impairment of value.

3. What is “substantial impairment” in revocation cases? It refers to a defect or nonconformity that significantly reduces the value or utility of the goods to the buyer.

4. Can I still use the goods after revoking acceptance? Limited use to mitigate damages may be acceptable, but continued or extensive use could undermine the revocation claim.

5. How soon must I revoke acceptance? Revocation must be done within a reasonable time after discovering the defect and requires timely notice to the seller.

If you need help with revocation cases, you can post your legal needs on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.