Key Takeaways:

  • Misrepresentation involves false statements that impact contract agreements and can be classified as innocent, negligent, or fraudulent.
  • To prove misrepresentation, a plaintiff must show that a material fact was misrepresented, they relied on the false statement, and they suffered damages.
  • Types of misrepresentation include:
    • Innocent misrepresentation: No intent to deceive.
    • Negligent misrepresentation: Failure to verify the truth of a statement.
    • Fraudulent misrepresentation: Intentional deception.
  • Legal consequences of misrepresentation include contract rescission, compensatory damages, and, in cases of fraud, punitive damages.
  • Proving fraudulent misrepresentation requires clear evidence that the defendant knowingly made a false statement with intent to mislead.
  • Defenses against misrepresentation claims include lack of reliance, lack of intent to mislead, or that the plaintiff should have conducted their own due diligence.
  • Hiring an attorney can be crucial in navigating complex misrepresentation claims.

Proving misrepresentation refers to the burden of proof laid on the plaintiff to give substantial evidence that the defendant misrepresented information which hurt the plaintiff or caused him some sort of loss.

What Is Misrepresentation?

Misrepresentation falls under the larger umbrella of fraud. Such claims are recognized in most courts throughout the country. A claim of misrepresentation states that the defendant caused harm to the plaintiff and should be held liable for the damages. The defendant can be held liable under these claims even if he didn't intend harm or loss through his actions.

Other names for misrepresentation include:

  • Innocent misrepresentation
  • Negligent misrepresentation

What the court calls this type of claim depends mostly on where the case is heard.

Types of Misrepresentation and Their Legal Implications

Misrepresentation can take multiple forms, each with different legal consequences. Understanding these distinctions is critical in determining whether a claim is valid and what remedies may be available.

  1. Innocent Misrepresentation
    • Occurs when a false statement is made without knowledge of its inaccuracy.
    • The misrepresenting party believed the statement was true at the time of the agreement.
    • The usual remedy is contract rescission rather than financial damages.
  2. Negligent Misrepresentation
    • Happens when a party fails to take reasonable care in verifying a statement’s accuracy.
    • The party making the claim may be liable for damages if it can be proven that their negligence led to financial loss.
  3. Fraudulent Misrepresentation
    • The most severe form, where a false statement is made intentionally to deceive the other party.
    • The injured party may sue for damages, including punitive damages in some cases.
    • Can lead to criminal liability if it involves fraud.

What Must Be Proven?

The plaintiff has to show evidence that a material fact was misrepresented in such a way that the plaintiff agreed to a contract he didn't intend to agree to. This fact must have been false when the agreement was formed.

The injured party also has to prove that he wouldn't have agreed to the terms of the contract if the misrepresented information had been truthful or not included at all.

Loss or injury to the plaintiff and benefit to the defendant also must be shown. If a contract was formed under misrepresented information, but no one was hurt and no one benefited, the court basically takes a "no harm done" approach.

Steps to Prove Misrepresentation in Court

Proving misrepresentation involves establishing key legal elements. Courts typically require proof of the following:

  1. False Representation – The plaintiff must demonstrate that a material fact was falsely stated.
  2. Intent or Negligence – Depending on the type of misrepresentation, the defendant must have either intended to deceive or failed to verify their claim.
  3. Reliance – The plaintiff must prove they reasonably relied on the false statement when agreeing to the contract.
  4. Causation – There must be a direct link between the misrepresentation and the plaintiff's decision to enter into the contract.
  5. Damages – The plaintiff must show they suffered financial or legal harm due to the misrepresentation.

Courts may award remedies such as contract rescission (undoing the agreement) or financial compensation for damages incurred.

Misrepresentation vs Fraud

Even though misrepresentation falls into the category of fraud, they do have some differences. Fraud usually assumes intent on the part of the defendant.

The three basic types of misrepresentation are:

  • Innocent misrepresentation is claimed when the defendant didn't know that the information he included in the agreement was false.
  • Negligent misrepresentation is claimed when the defendant simply didn't try to determine whether the information was true or not.
  • Fraudulent misrepresentation is claimed when the defendant intentionally falsified the information for his benefit or knew it was false.

Consider an example. Say an individual is purchasing a car. The car owner assures the buyer that the brakes are in great shape and safe. The buyer purchases the car and drives away only to end up in an accident due to faulty brakes. When the car is examined after the accident, it is found that the brakes were old and severely worn.

If the buyer chooses to sue the original owner of the vehicle for damages, he will need to prove some form of misrepresentation. The buyer can prove fraud if there is evidence that the owner was well aware of the condition of the brakes but explicitly said they were in good shape.

Misrepresentation may be proven if the buyer can show that the brakes were, in fact, in poor shape when the owner sold the car saying that they were fine. The buyer can show his bodily injuries and loss of a working vehicle as damages and the money paid to the original owner as the benefit.

In some cases, the plaintiff must be able to prove that they lost more than the defendant gained in order to prove misrepresentation. Some states allow for misrepresentation even if the loss was greater than the gain.

Defenses Against Misrepresentation Claims

Defendants facing misrepresentation claims have several legal defenses that can mitigate or nullify liability. Some common defenses include:

  • Lack of Materiality – The misrepresentation must be about a material fact that significantly influenced the contract decision. If the false statement was minor, the claim may not hold.
  • Lack of Reliance – If the plaintiff did not rely on the false statement when entering the contract, the misrepresentation claim may not be valid.
  • Due Diligence – If the plaintiff had an opportunity to verify the facts but failed to do so, courts may not hold the defendant liable.
  • Truth of the Statement – If the defendant can prove the statement was factually correct at the time it was made, the claim is likely to be dismissed.
  • Contractual Disclaimers – Some contracts include clauses that limit liability for misrepresentation, making it harder to prove wrongdoing.

These defenses highlight why both parties should thoroughly review contractual agreements before signing.

What Is a Fraudulent Misrepresentation in Contracts?

Contracts are only enforceable if the parties involved all agree to the terms and conditions included.

Usually, if any of the terms in a contract are false, the contract is considered invalid because it is based on inaccurate information. Information that is intentionally falsified is called fraudulent misrepresentation.

False information in a contract can still be considered misrepresentation even if the party who included the information was unaware that it was inaccurate. This is especially true if the party that included the false information was careless in their formation of the contract. Contracts are legally binding agreements that should be taken seriously.

Any time a party in an agreement includes information simply to get the other party to agree to his terms without checking to make sure that all of the facts are true, he may be able to be held liable for misrepresentation.

Under contract law, parties can only be held liable for misrepresentation if the false information negatively affected the agreement or other party somehow. For instance, if a party included the wrong middle name in a contract but no harm was caused to the other party, the contract is still considered valid and no one can be taken to court over a misrepresentation claim.

Legal Remedies for Misrepresentation

When misrepresentation is proven, the legal remedies available depend on the severity of the case:

  1. Rescission of Contract
    • The contract is canceled, returning both parties to their pre-agreement state.
    • Common in innocent and negligent misrepresentation cases.
  2. Compensatory Damages
    • The plaintiff can claim financial compensation for losses suffered due to misrepresentation.
    • Typically applies to negligent or fraudulent misrepresentation.
  3. Punitive Damages
    • Available in cases of fraudulent misrepresentation, where the defendant acted with intent to deceive.
    • Designed to punish the wrongdoer and deter similar conduct.
  4. Equitable Remedies
    • Courts may order a party to fulfill certain obligations or provide alternative remedies.
    • Particularly relevant in contract disputes where financial compensation is insufficient.

Given the complexity of misrepresentation claims, seeking legal counsel can be beneficial in determining the best course of action.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the difference between fraud and misrepresentation?
    • Fraud involves intentional deception, while misrepresentation can occur without intent. Fraud carries heavier legal penalties, including possible criminal charges.
  2. Can I sue for misrepresentation if I didn’t suffer financial loss?
    • In most cases, you need to prove damages to have a valid claim. However, rescission may still be available as a remedy.
  3. How long do I have to file a misrepresentation claim?
    • The statute of limitations varies by state but generally ranges from 2 to 6 years from the date the misrepresentation was discovered.
  4. What should I do if I suspect misrepresentation in a contract?
    • Gather all relevant documents, communicate with the other party, and consult a lawyer to assess your legal options.
  5. Can misrepresentation be accidental?
    • Yes, innocent misrepresentation occurs when a false statement is made without intent to deceive. While not fraudulent, it can still result in contract rescission.

If you need help with proving misrepresentation, you can post your job on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.