Key Takeaways

  • A poor man’s trademark is an outdated and ineffective strategy for proving ownership of intellectual property.
  • Mailing a logo or written work to oneself provides little to no legal protection under U.S. copyright or trademark law.
  • Only federal registration provides enforceable nationwide rights and access to statutory remedies for copyright or trademark infringement.
  • Common misconceptions include believing common law rights cover broad territories or that mailing materials proves ownership.
  • Alternatives like federal trademark and copyright registration offer actual legal benefits and protections.

People have used a poor man's trademark for years. Also called a poor man's copyright, this entails a person mailing their own art and writing to themselves through the U.S. Postal Service. These pieces of mail are not opened once received. How does an individual profit from this? Mailing an item back to oneself proves that the item was created on a particular date. A poor man's trademark is a copyright that is in place as soon as the piece was made.

Poor Man's Trademark

Making an item official through registration protects it from those who want to copy your work by giving it an official date of when it was made. If the item is damaged by utilizing the U.S. mail, you cannot receive damages. It is a good idea to pay $55 to register your work and get it protected. There are many benefits to having an item registered with a copyright.

A trademark is a way to make your brand and company stand out from others. A trademark could be a name, color, or logo. It begins as soon as it is used and does not need to be registered. To protect your trademark, it's a good idea to get it registered in the United States. If someone were to use your registered trademark without your permission, they could get penalized.

The poor man's trademark gives you no protection over your copyright and is not a safe way to have others recognize your copyright. Receiving a copy of your logo that you mailed to yourself does nothing to protect you or the logo you created. Even though registration can be pricey, having your trademark protected will help you in the long run.

What Is a Poor Man's Trademark?

A “poor man’s trademark” is an informal, outdated concept involving mailing a copy of your work—such as a logo or slogan—to yourself and keeping it sealed to establish a date of creation. This idea is borrowed from the more common “poor man’s copyright,” which refers to doing the same with written or artistic works. Proponents believe the postmarked envelope serves as legal evidence in case of infringement disputes.

However, neither the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) nor the U.S. Copyright Office recognizes this practice as legally binding or sufficient to establish ownership or enforce rights. Trademarks, unlike copyrights, do not automatically grant exclusive rights upon creation. Without federal registration, proving priority of use and enforcing exclusivity becomes significantly harder.

Why the Poor Man’s Trademark Fails

The poor man’s trademark offers no enforceable legal protection and fails for several reasons:

  • Not Recognized by Courts or the USPTO: Courts typically require concrete evidence of commercial use and distinctiveness, not a postmarked envelope.
  • No Legal Rights Established: Mailing a trademarked design or phrase to yourself does not create common law rights, nor does it substitute for federal registration.
  • No Presumption of Ownership: Without registering your mark, you lack the presumption of validity, which means you'll need to provide more evidence if you ever face an infringement case.
  • Limited Scope: Even common law trademarks only offer protection in the geographic area where the mark is actively used—not across the U.S.

Federal trademark registration, on the other hand, provides nationwide protection, the ability to sue for damages, and public notice of ownership.

Common Trademark Mistakes

Customers want to recognize businesses and what they can do. A trademark allows customers to do so. Your enterprise uses lots of time and money to create products for customers, and you need to find a way to let customers know what kind of products your business sells.

Here are some ways to avoid errors and misinterpretations about trademarks:

  • Do not just search for what is registered. Look for trademarks that have already been made.
  • Do not ignore abandoned or canceled trademarks.
  • Usage of trademarks still gives businesses rights to the trademark even if it is not registered or has not been maintained.
  • Trademark rights may still apply even if the trademark has not been registered.

Common law trademark rights are restricted to geographical areas. Nationwide rights are given once you register at the federal level.

If the trademark was owned by another company in the past, the owners still have rights at the federal and common law level. Placing a "TM" next to your trademark only gives you rights in the area where you are doing business under common law trademark rights. If your trademark is not registered at the federal level, another business can get federal protection for the same trademark.

Do not base your trademark just on what your business can do. The U.S. Patent and Trademark office will most likely reject trademarks that are "merely descriptive." Your competition can use precise ways to describe their services and goods, which is a reason that a descriptive trademark is dismissed. You are more likely to register a name not related to your business.

Another common mistake is believing your trademark can describe all your services and goods. Services and goods are broken up into different categories. You can own a trademark within one class, but another company can still use it in another category. If the ways in which you and another business use the same trademark are so similar that it causes confusion, this can be a reason for a trademark to be restricted.

Do not expect to be able to use a given trademark for a variety of goods and services. This is further explained above. The wrong question to ask is, "What might I use this trademark on?" You must use the registered trademark for all services and goods listed. Otherwise, your registration will be canceled. Keep in mind that you want to get as much protection as you can on your trademark.

Alternatives to the Poor Man’s Trademark

Instead of relying on ineffective tactics, consider these legitimate ways to protect your brand:

  • Federal Trademark Registration: Offers the most robust legal protections, including nationwide rights, the ability to bring legal action in federal court, and use of the ® symbol.
  • State Trademark Registration: Provides protection within the state but lacks the reach and benefits of federal registration.
  • Common Law Trademark Use: Offers some protection, but only in the immediate geographic area where the mark is used. It lacks the presumptive legal benefits of federal registration.
  • Copyright Registration (for creative works): For logos or designs that also qualify as artistic works, copyright registration may offer a secondary layer of protection.

Spending the time and money to register a trademark with the USPTO is a far better investment than relying on the myth of the poor man's trademark.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is a poor man's trademark?
    It refers to the practice of mailing a copy of your logo or design to yourself to prove creation date. It offers no legal protection.
  2. Does a postmark prove ownership of a trademark?
    No. The U.S. courts and USPTO do not consider a postmark as valid evidence of trademark rights.
  3. Is a poor man's trademark legally recognized?
    No. It has no standing in trademark law and does not establish any rights or protections.
  4. What’s the best way to protect my logo or brand?
    Register it as a federal trademark with the USPTO. This gives you enforceable legal rights and national recognition.
  5. Can I still use my trademark if it's not registered?
    Yes, but your rights are limited to the area where you use it. Federal registration is the only way to secure nationwide rights.

If you need help with a poor man's trademark, you can post your legal need on UpCounsel's marketplace. UpCounsel accepts only the top 5 percent of lawyers to its site. Lawyers on UpCounsel come from law schools such as Harvard Law and Yale Law and average 14 years of legal experience, including work with or on behalf of companies like Google, Menlo Ventures, and Airbnb.